Definitely the Rogue cut because it makes every other part sensible. Logan was swinging back and forward and wounded Kitty, which didn't make much sense without the Rogue's role. The Hank and Raven's scene makes it slower and personally I don't like JL's Mystique so it is just white noise to me (too bad RR played a powerful Mystique and JL made a plastic doll). Magneto's past and future back to back when rescuing Rogue / taking back the helmet is pretty awesome. The hand of the sentinel narrated the story more reasonable. PS. Damn, if only Jean were alive, she would have kicked the sentinels' asses.