Saw it last night and enjoyed it but found it... somehow lacking. Good and enjoyable but not as good as the 1st.
The overall direction and action was handled well and I liked the step up in gory kills. I liked the idea of some lycans being left to go 'feral' and the Super Lycan was pretty cool too. I also liked the look of the lycans more in this one compared with the past films. The story was alright.. as a continuation and fast forward, it worked but it (the pacing of the film/story) felt rushed IMO. It kinda felt like there was no real middle to the film, you know.. [blackout]she gets caught and froze and escapes and before you know it and really get any proper sense of what's going on, she's making her assault on Antigen and clearing up.[/blackout]
Part of what makes the original good is that Lucian is such a great and likeable character/villain (it's helped that he's played by Michael Sheen). Even though the lycans are the 'bad guys' you can imagine watching Underworld from their point of view with Lucian as the main character and you would see the vampires as the bad guys.. (oppressing the lycans and wanting Michael to use him to wipe out the lycans once and for all)
Whereas in the 4th, they're not really that fleshed out, not really that likeable (as characters) and are portrayed as more straight up villains with regular kind of 'villain motives'. I guess the answer to this would be that it's a different Lycan clan with different plans but it was just a bit of a shame I thought, to lose that kind of 'neither good nor bad' dynamic. I also thought, based on the trailers and the opening dialogue of the film that the humans were gonna be the main villains, with the vampires and lycans potentially teaming up... so maybe 'cos I was expecting that, that might be why it didn't quite work for me.
The worse bit of the film, for me though, was the 3D.. Except for a couple scenes, it just wasn't that noticeable IMO. The fight scene in the coven where David has his chain whip out, where Selene jumps over the fire and the 3D effects on the silver nitrate gas in the air looked alright but for the most part, I didn't even get a sense a depth.. I might as well have been watching it in 2D really.
I'm not sure if it's 'cos it was a conversion or not but it was just a bit of a poor do on the 3D front really... the 3D trailer for John Carter looked fantastic, by comparison.