The Dark Knight Rises What's Joker up too?

I disagree. Sure you could have had him in the sequel and done more with the character, but as it stands I think his exit and the way he was used is perfect. In TDK he really has no character arc to speak of, just seemingly appearing at the beginning of the film, screwing up everything for everyone, and just as abruptly disappearing at the end of the film, literally left hanging. This Joker has no real end because he has no beginning. He is a concept; you could use him in another story but the end result would be the same.

Couldn't have said it that good! Great post, man!
I know that Joker fans would've loved to see more of him. I'm a big fan myself and despite that I still prefer the way Nolan went. Even if Heath was still alive, having two subsequent movies with him is just a waste of the huge potential the Batman Rogue Gallery has. I'm really happy they explored Bane and Talia, instead of going for Joker again. Dr. Crane made a cameo but he didn't do it as Scarecrow, so that's okay and Ra's Al Ghul was in a hallucination. Having the Joker return in flesh and blood would distract the attention from the main villain - Bane.
 
I like to just think he's getting plenty of therapy from Harleen Quinzel
 
I thought the novel made mention of the Joker, but can't remember for sure.
 
Couldn't have said it that good! Great post, man!
I know that Joker fans would've loved to see more of him. I'm a big fan myself and despite that I still prefer the way Nolan went. Even if Heath was still alive, having two subsequent movies with him is just a waste of the huge potential the Batman Rogue Gallery has. I'm really happy they explored Bane and Talia, instead of going for Joker again. Dr. Crane made a cameo but he didn't do it as Scarecrow, so that's okay and Ra's Al Ghul was in a hallucination. Having the Joker return in flesh and blood would distract the attention from the main villain - Bane.

This !
 
You're forgetting that last scene, Demon Hunter. The last Joker scene at the end of The Dark Knight proved that this trilogy did support that aspect of the comics. I quote:
"You won't kill me, out of some misplaced sense of self righteousness, and I won't kill you, cause you're just too much fun. I think you and I are destined to do this forever."

"You'll be in a padded cell forever"

"Well maybe we can share one".

This was just scratching the surface of the Batman-Joker rollercoaster of a friendship.
Had The Joker appeared in the Dark Knight Rises, there could have been alot more revealed, and maybe we could have seen this relationship develop more and go further into knots and complexities, and maybe we could have seen Batman struggle to balance the joker on the line of friendship and rivalry, and maybe we could have gotten an explanation as to what he had been up to all this time.. maybe he figured out Bruce was Batman during all those 8 years in Arkham.. after all, what are you we gonna do sitting locked up in an asylum for 8 years? you have nothing to do but think. Maybe he put the pieces together, he's smart and calculative, even if he's a psychopath.

These are all MAYBES, i'm just trying to point out that things that could have been different in favor of the audience and maintained a certain respect to Heath.

Of course in the end, we can't change the fact that the Joker wasn't in the movie.

This !
 
I thought the novel made mention of the Joker, but can't remember for sure.
It did. They mentioned he might be Arkham's sole remaining patient, or he might have escaped, no one knew for sure.. not even Selina.
 
Sure. Here:
http://www.youtube.com/user/TheJokerBlogs

Oh, and here's my latest idea for a potential Joker cameo that would've rocked the movie. Don't know how long it'll stay up on youtube, but hope you get to see it anyhow.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuDAPb4XLGM

- M&DC

Man i saw the joker clip before it went down....Now THAT needed to be in Rises. Death of course is a sad thing but Heath worked really hard for TDK. I'm sure if Nolan asked his family they'd would of loved for his sons character to have been put in Rises. That is the greatest respect. To show people what a great character you had created. (yes he was shown in TDK, but if it was possible to add him in TDKR then that would of been as nice as well)
 
if it were me, here's how i would've included joker in the plot :


it would kind of be a mixture of sorts between things like dark knight returns, no man's land and arkham city.

for starters , just as in dark knight returns where joker was sitting in arkham catatonic for years waiting for batman to come back, the same thing would be what i would've done in rises. although i would've basically had everyone underestimate the joker even more so in rises.

it's been 8 years, and he's been locked up doing absolutely nothing, so at this point most of gotham think of him more as a joke. i would've had his first scene to be him in arkham being interviewed by a reporter without makeup, somewhat similar to how they interviewed charles manson when they captured him. so the reporter is basically being a total dick to him, asking him all sorts of questions like how he must feel knowing that batman's back or knowing that he's lost his respect as a criminal mastermind. things just to get joker really pissed off. not a good idea.so then joker starts messing with him back, asking him things like how it must feel to have a wife who's probably cheating on him as they speak, etc. which then causes the reporter to ask " well, what about you then ? you got a girl here ? " and the joker would respond , in sort of an in your face smartassy way " as a matter of fact i do... my psychiatrist " .

so the reporter would ask " oh ? and how do you think she feels about you ? " to which the joker replies " why not ask her yourself ? she's right behind ya. " and then harley quinn would be behind the reporter , and she'd kill the reporter as the joker watches smiling and giggling.

so harley breaks joker out , right around the time all the destruction caused by bane starts happening, so joker seems to enjoy the state of gotham, being able to kill randomly and more freely than ever. only thing is, he's pissed off that he isn't the one causing all the destruction. and he's also pissed that bane was the one to get to reveal the truth of harvey dent instead of him, as well as the fact that bane is responsible for batman's current grief in the movie.


so joker does a speech in front of arkham on top of his "slaughter is the best medicine" truck, as a way to mock bane's speech in front of blackgate, telling gotham how HE was the one who caused harvey dent's downfall and that bane should've " given credit where credit is due " , and breaks everyone in arkham out and him and harley basically start their own little army against bane, to show him " how chaos is really done " . so now it's an all out war ( as if it wasn't already, lol )so joker would have his own section and army in the city, while bane has his and gordon has his cops.


so , similarly to no man's land, joker would kidnap all of gotham's babies in an effort to regain batman's attention, only at this point batman's busy dealing with bane in the riot in the middle of town and all, so he's waiting and waiting for batman to show up and eventually he gets fed up and realizes he's not coming so he leaves harley to watch over the captured babies while he takes matters into his own hands. then i'd have catwoman go after harley while joker goes to find batman and kills bane , similarly to the video posted earlier.

in one last attempt to have his " fun " with batman , joker challenges him to a " race " to see who'd get to the nuclear bomb first, and he chases after talia's truck in his own slaughter truck while batman's also trying to stop her, and like in the movie, the truck would crash , yada yada yada, but then batman would try to get rid of the bomb, only to have joker attacking him trying to stop him from doing that , as he feels it'd be " poetic " to have their last fight as they and everyone else in gotham's about to be blown to hell, they duke it out, joker gets stopped at gunpoint by gordon, then like in the movie batman takes care of the bomb, as joker looks over at the explosion , realizing he'll never get to have any " fun " again, so he takes out his signature knife and uses it to kill himself.

so basically joker spends the majority of the movie trying to regain his status in gotham and also trying to get batsy's attention again.


now, this could all be a terrible idea, and you could all say " **** fanboy, don't ever write for movies" , or maybe some would like it. i don't really care, it was just a random bunch of ideas that popped into my head and i felt like getting them out. and i also realize the movie would have to be quite a bit longer to fit all this in as well, lol
 
Last edited:
I think that's cool, but how about The joker NOT kill himself. not his style at all. and second, make that reporter who's interviewing him Jack Ryder, aka the Creeper, since he's a reporter too.. that would be cool to have another reference like that in the movie.
 
I think that's cool, but how about The joker NOT kill himself. not his style at all. and second, make that reporter who's interviewing him Jack Ryder, aka the Creeper, since he's a reporter too.. that would be cool to have another reference like that in the movie.
idunno, i figured if he saw his ultimate foe/obsession/ only reason for living blown to smithereens in a nuclear explosion, that would very much be his style. plus heath's joker was clearly very masochistic,enjoying pain and being on the edge of death quite alot, and didn't seem to mind dying or really care about his life at all considering all the times he put his life in danger constantly. ( giving harvey dent a gun and putting it to his head, laughing while almost falling to his death, literally having grenades strapped to him, etc.)

and good idea about the jack ryder reference actually ! didn't even think that one through.

edit : i also kinda envisioned that during that scene, joker would pull a kakihara from ichi the killer, smoking a cigarette and having the smoke blow out of his scars or something.just something i randomly thought would be cool and add to it lol
 
Last edited:
I dont like the idea of Joker killing Bane.

Bane is supposed to be the Midgard Serpent for Batman, he's the Dragon who fights Beowulf, the great beast that marks the end for Batman. He has been, and always should be, a greater threat than Joker.
 
I dont like the idea of Joker killing Bane.

If anything it would be the other way around. Bane was too controlled and cautious to let the Joker potentially screw everything up, despite the fact that they had essentially the same goals.
 
I dont like the idea of Joker killing Bane.

Bane is supposed to be the Midgard Serpent for Batman, he's the Dragon who fights Beowulf, the great beast that marks the end for Batman. He has been, and always should be, a greater threat than Joker.

Did you like the idea of Catwoman killing Bane any better than a god of villainy like Joker doing it?
 
I agree that it did add to Selina but at the same time took away from Bane by giving him such a....unginified exist from the film.
 
I think it makes much more sense for the Joker to do it personally.

Even though he's the purest form of evil in the series, he's essentially a fan favorite. It makes sense that he wouldn't want Bane to destroy his play land (Gotham) or his play friend (the Batman)

Him showing up in place of Catwoman to save Bruce, and off Bane would have been poetic and would've got a HUGE reaction from the crowd. It would've been a suprising and iconic moment.

Batman, appreciative still knocks the clown out cold before along side Catwoman going to stop the nuke.

I also don't have problems with the reasoning for no mention of him at all. He appears out of no where, ala the end of BB and start of TDK. Just a pure force of evil. No need to mention him in the 8 years since. No Batman in Gotham, no Joker to be inspired to play.

It's literally that simple. I also like the idea of Arkham and the Narrows still being shut off from the rest of Gotham, and Joker being the LONE inmate of the asylum.
I would prefer Joker disappearing rather than batman taking him out, after a moment like that. But yes i also love the idea of Joker being mentioned as the lone inmate of the asylum.
 
idunno, i figured if he saw his ultimate foe/obsession/ only reason for living blown to smithereens in a nuclear explosion, that would very much be his style. plus heath's joker was clearly very masochistic,enjoying pain and being on the edge of death quite alot, and didn't seem to mind dying or really care about his life at all considering all the times he put his life in danger constantly. ( giving harvey dent a gun and putting it to his head, laughing while almost falling to his death, literally having grenades strapped to him, etc.)

and good idea about the jack ryder reference actually ! didn't even think that one through.

edit : i also kinda envisioned that during that scene, joker would pull a kakihara from ichi the killer, smoking a cigarette and having the smoke blow out of his scars or something.just something i randomly thought would be cool and add to it lol
I never thought he enjoyed pain or anything, but rather it was chaos that he loved. He seemed to find life inconsequential, a truly dangerous and extremist nihilist. He was hellbent on proving that human beings are naturally self-preserving and capable of horrors in the face of it.

I think even if Heath were alive, he still wouldn't have made an appearance in the final movie. He was simply not needed to help close Bruce's arc, but was essential to where Bruce and the city came to be at the start of TDKR. He served his purpose, and would simply be a distraction in this film.
 
I think even if Heath were alive, he still wouldn't have made an appearance in the final movie. He was simply not needed to help close Bruce's arc

Not the way they wrote TDKR he wasn't, and that was only written that way because they could not include Joker. Had Heath lived I can tell you now we would be seeing a different movie with TDKR.

He served his purpose, and would simply be a distraction in this film.

How can you say that when you have no idea how he would have been used in the movie? Were you distracted by Crane and Ra's in their cameos?
 
I don't know if this has been posted before in this thread or in an another discussion, but I just saw it in again imax and noticed that in this scene:

0.jpg


In the movie, there is a subway entrance to the right of everything in this picture that has the graffiti tag "KAO$" on it.
I think it's the movie's only subtle hint at the Joker being loose in the city.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"