I'm really sorry I didn't respond to this sooner. I've had a lot of distractions (some of them actually crucial to my life) and I wanted to avoid being perfunctory about this.
kame-sennin said:
Thank you. I thought your astral plane write up was fine and the most logical way to shorten it would be to simply cut down the length of the battle. If you think about it, psychic battles probably don't last that long in real time anyway, so this is a good way of showing how much information is going on in the character's minds in a brief amount of time.
I don't remember what the book was called, but there was a collection of short stories about the X-Men that included one about the Professor's first battle with the Shadow King. Someone, possibly a child, was throwing a ball to someone else across a short distance, in the vicinity of the cafe where Xavier and Amahl Farouk were staring each other down and having a big ol' tussle on the Astral Plane. This gave a timeframe which ultimately made the fight last about a second in real time. On the Astral Plane, it can seem to take God knows how long (it's happening at the speed of thought) but for the purposes of the movie, it would have to be reasonably short, but obviously more than a second.
Who said it would be voluntary

.
I don't like Professor X being too shady.
The way I imagined it, Proffesor X would be the psychic equivalent of an internet classroom, where his students would be able to see and hear what's going on in a real class taking place a great distance away. Taping into a proffesor's mind to create this would not be such a violation , IMHO, that Xavier woud feel bad about doing it without said proffessor's opinion.
Of course, these are just random ideas, and I really like the virtual classroom thing. Additionally, teaching the X-men courses the way he tought some of them English would also work, and be the easiest "movie way" of explaining their education.
I'll have to think about this some more.
As there are exceptions to every rule, I think this falls under the exception. If having Cyclops explain his origin's to another character is a key part of his arc, then it works. But I still think you should show some part of the origin for Bobby. Maybe Cyclops can be the only character without an origin scene which might add to the mystery of the character, and we do not find out the depressing truth untill much later in the film during a quiet scene with Jean? Just throwing out ideas.
I definitely want to show a scene where Scott Summers is running away from an orphanage (or similar institution) and he accidentally shoots the cable that drops the I-beam and then shoots the I-beam so that it doesn't hit anybody. Perhaps that could be the teaser and the scene with Xavier and Farouk could be later on, as an actual flashback.
If Mr. Sinister is a big part of the plot of 'Uncanny X-Men 4,' I'd have a flashback or two for Scott Summers as a kid and/or young teen. I guess I should bring Havok into the story at that point as well. Also, i I put him on Storm's Gold Strike Team, that would balance out the numbers between the two teams. I think I posted my ideas for that movie and how Jean Grey will reappear, having been switched with a clone created by Mr. Sinister in 'Uncanny X-Men 2.'
Maybe Jean's flashback should be in the second film, where the dangers of her powers at high levels truly come into play. If that's the case, then in the first movie, I'd just have Jean tell Scott about her psychic trauma at age 10. I would have her telepathy starting to develop throughout the first movie, too, and in the final battle sequence, Jean will, among other things, relay messages between the team members telepathically (although they should also have electronic communication devices, composed mostly of plastic... perhaps Magneto will render them useless anyway and Jean's power is needed). When she starts using her telepathy during her first year back at Xavier's, she'll tell Scott why she didn't tell the other X-Men she had that talent before.
I agree. You have to walk a fine line with Cyclops because you risk making the character boring and uninteresting to the audience. However, if the filmmaker generally cares about the character (and I imagine you do), than I doubt this would be a problem.
Exactly. If the people doing the movie want to get it right, then they will get it right, God dammit! Cyclops needs to be interesting, or at the very least, entertaining. The fact is, not everybody is going to be all that interested in Cyclops-- and I do not mean that in the same way people say "you can't please everybody, aim for the 'general audience'"-- I mean that different people prefer different characters, and I want Cyclops to be as accessible to most people as he can be while still remaining very much in character.
And don't get me started on the Batman thing. Heaven forbid a mysterious creature of the night should... hide his emotions! People are idiots.
Hey, feel free to
get started... but do it in the
Batman Safe Haven, though, please.
Go hog wild.
That's becoming very popular in film and television today (Begins, Lost, ect.), but that doesn't mean it's bad. I think the key deciding factor has to be the pace of the film. If the pace of the film is even and comfortable, leave the beginning at the beginning. If it's not, than you might want to inter disperse the origins. But leave that damn Xavier intro at the beginning of the film. It's a good tease, and drives home the point you are making in your X-men film; that Xavier believes he is a hero who must fight against renegade mutants who threaten humanity (as well as other mutants). That's an interesting point that's almost non-existant in the current franchise, and hasn't been touched on much in recent comics (except Whedon's). Now adays, the X-men are looked at as more of a paramilitary strike force, and if you want your X-men to come off as heros (or would-be heros), you should show that.
That's a good point. I definitely want to emphasize the heroism aspect of Xavier and the X-Men (although I still want to show Xavier as more of a hard-ass headmaster than he was in the Singer movies, although I think I'll draw the just before, "X-Men, meet me in my study in 15 seconds... tardiness will be punished!").
It always seemed peculiar to me how Xavier believed that by gathering a training a group of superpowered field operatives, he could somehow bring humans and mutants to an age of peace and acceptance. At some points it seemed like the fighting supervillains was a secondary goal. I want to make it clear that Xavier's first intention for the X-Men themselves is to make them an effective "peacekeeping force" (soldiers that try to neutralize superhuman threats and save civilians without killing anyone), while his life's ultimate goal is to educate the world about mutants and spread the message that peace can be achieved through knowledge and empathy. The X-Men themselves will be given a range of options for occupational training, the specialty being a course that combines education of genetics, sociology, political theory and history, and other studies that will leave a graduate of the Xavier Institute in a position to actually, literally
teach others about Xavier's Dream and how it can be acheived through education and cooperation. When I say teach, I don't just mean at the Xavier Institute for Higher Learning, I mean in other schools and places as well.
The Beast will take this course of study, among other physical sciences (he's going to finish earning his Ph.D.s in Biochemistry and Genetics towards the beginning of 'Uncanny X-Men 2'), but that doesn't mean he will immediately begin teaching people, since the Xavier Institute is the only school where there is such a course, and it takes time to open colleges and universities to this kind of option. Let's face it, it would be a preachy class with a strong political bias, so it's not exactly a sure pick in today's world, where education is widely seen as something that should be neutral (regardless of whether it really is).
So yeah, not everyone at Xavier's is required to become an X-Man or a teacher, but those are options.
I'm hesistant about villain flashback scenes as you run the risk of exhausting the audience. A Magneto flashback could work, as it was one of the only things the current franchise really nailed. As for the Scarlet Witch, perhaps Magneto could perform some act of kindness during the course of the film, or, something could come up and she would be reminded of the debt she owes him. I'm not sure either way. Hell, someone could ask her why she works for him and she could say, "Magnus saved us from the bloodthirty human mob. I would die for him." (And I am well aware that suggesting this is a bit hypocritical, but rules are meant to be broken

). I would also avoid Xavier/Magneto flahbacks. It should be obvious from the dialogue that they were once friends, and you'll have more than one movie to develop their relationship. You won't need to cram everything into one film.
I haven't thought of a solid plot for Magneto in subsequent films, although recently I started toying with the idea that Magneto could show up in 'Uncanny X-Men 2' when the Sentinels are wreaking havok and aid the X-Men in destroying them. He could also try to help Jean Grey contain the nuclear explosion resulting from one of the Sentinels' power sources becoming unstable. I would have Magneto at a good distance away at the moment (fighting a Sentinel or three over there), so he'd be projecting his force field from afar and wouldn't be in the same danger that Jean is in (if their combined force fields actually contain the blast... if they didn't, everyone in the city would be in danger, obviously), as she is right up close to it, shielding herself as well as the world outside the telekinetic (and then also electromagnetic once Magneto realizes what's up) sphere of energy. Magneto would feel some guilt over Jean's apparent death (she turns out to be in a coma, though), but he wouldn't have directly contributed to it.
He would not be present for most of the movie, though. If Mystque's Brotherhood of Mutants and the Morlocks are the villains of 'Uncanny X-Men 3' and Mr. Sinister and/or Apocalypse are the villains of 'Uncanny X-Men 4,' I'm not sure how to fit another major Magneto plot in, other than to restructure the plot outlines for the others. I could do a write-up for a fifth one eventually, but I'd like feedback on whether you think the general ideas for 3 and 4 are good ones first.
I do want the Scarlet Witch to follow Magneto partly because she believes he's right in his quest. This is partly because she experienced firsthand the savagery and unreasoning hatred with which baseline humans can treat mutants, partly because Magneto is the first person she met who is willing to try to help her control and master her powers, partly because he's extremely charismatic when he wants to be,
largely out of obligation because Magneto saved her from a mob of humans and she feels obligated, and it's partly a vaguely "Stockholme Syndrome" type dynamic that relates to the previous reason. He has asked her to to help him in return for what he did, and she would rather believe there's a good reason behind him obligating her to bring harm to other people than to believe she's being forced to do this completely against her wishes. It's a defense mechanism.
Quicklsilver, on the other hand, doesn't give a damn one way or another what happens to the human populace or about Magneto's ultimate goal, but since his sister refuses to leave Magneto, he resolves to stay with the Brotherhood, whether Magneto wants him to or not. He's not afraid of Magneto, at least in terms of his own safety, and Magneto values this trait to some degree and keeps the hope alive that Quicksilver will adopt his viewpoint and start believing in the cause. Quicksilver is sort of Magneto's unofficial second-in-command in terms of field operations. While he isn't devoted, he's more trustworthy than Mastermind and far more competent in general than the Toad. Unus the Untouchable doesn't even
want to be the number two guy in the gang, so we don't know whether he'd be competent or not, but we get the impression he isn't up to it.
Anyway, if I don't give Wanda a mob attack flashback, I will just have them reveal what happened through dialogue. I
had wanted to show it instead of telling it with a brief scene that picks up after Wanda's powers caused an accident and a mob gathers and corners her. There would be a shot or two of Quicksilver trying to come to her aid, but he is being held down by many humans who are actually piling on top of each other in order to keep him down (his powers would easily shake off people who were simply holding his arms or whatever) and it looks like he's taken a severe beating already, the bruises explaning part of why he isn't stronger at the moment. The look of terror and helplessness in Pietro's eyes would be heartbreaking. Suddenly, Magneto comes floating down from the sky in his shining red armor (I'm going to have sections of it be flat-out plate armor, similar to the knights and gladiators of old... it fits with the gladiator-style helmet) and his cape spread out and flapping in the wind. He would command the mob in a booming voice to leave her be, and when they hesitate, he tosses them in all different directions with his power, not caring whether they live or die. This grandiose shot would hopefully give the audience a better idea of why she would stay with this man even though she knows he's dangerous and basically a fanatical terrorist who's willing to pretty much anyway to achieve his goals. I really wanted to keep something like that in, which would also, by implication, explain why Toad is there and why he's such a sycophant (he's a "toady," get it? Man, that Stan Lee sure was clever with words...), and why Mastermind and Unus see him as their ticket to the big time.
Quicksilver is glad that Wanda was saved, but he is jealous when it comes to her and who gets to save or protect her, which gives him one more reason to dislike him. He knows what Magneto is and that he's extremely dangerous. Furthermore, he allies himself with lecherous psychopaths like Mastermind and creepy, vile, borderline stalker-types like the Toad (who has a huge crush on Wanda, which he doesn't hide, and no social skills whatsoever). I mean, if
your sister (assuming you like her) resolved to work with a hateful, violent, unspeakably powerful terrorist who could do anything to you from tossing you through the air with a thought to making a refrigerator eat you to dropping a building on you, who hires a remorseless bastard who can make you see, hear, taste, smell and feel anything he wants to and a lonely, creepy unstable freak with deadly, inhuman strength, would
you be okay with it? That's Quicksilver's role in the movie, and he's constantly keeping an eye on her, rarely ever leaving her out of sight. By the end of the movie, when the X-Men defeat the Brotherhood, leaving Magneto (wounded) to escape, Mastermind to get while the gettin's good, and Toad and Unus in government custody, Quicksilver will gather up the nerve to tell his sister once and for all how it's going to be from here on out. She's coming with him, like it or not, and she is not going to be joining up with Magneto and his minions or any other dangerous faction again... peroid!!
I don't feel I need to actually have a flashback with Xavier and Magneto. Xavier would gather his students and tell the truncated story, and explain why people like Magneto are so dangerous. One of the students, probably Beast (the most philosophically interested member), will ask him how an uninvolved individual or group would be able to to distinguish a charismatic and powerful leader like Magneto from a charismatic and powerful leader like Professor X in terms of who is actually "right." Hank would put a disclaimer first and say that he means no disrespect, and Xavier would tell him that he should not be afraid to ask such questions. On the battlefield and/or on rescue missions, the X-Men are expected to follow the chosen field commander (Cyclops) without dispute for the most part, but at the school (or any non-dangerous situation), they not only
can ask such philosophical questions, but
should. I would like it if Professor X would lay it out for the X-Men and the audience, how morality is essentially relative on a factual/intellectual level. In practice, however, he strongly believes that a person of action must choose their set of values or side of an issue, and act according to their value system. It is important that the X-Men realize that there is
some truth to Magneto's rhetoric, and that is why intelligent people may join his cause (he doesn't want them underestimating Magneto's followers' intellect in general), and also why Magneto is so dangerous. Someone like Unus the Untouchable is dangerous because he has power and is selfish. Someone like Magneto is more dangerous, not only because he has a hell of a lot more power, but because he truly believes he is right and is not at all insane for believing what he believes. I want it shown that the X-Men are not treated like mindless minions to execute Xavier's will. It's a progressive institution on many levels, and although certain rules are strict, the intellectul atmosphere is not oppressive.
I'm just bustin your balls, I'm kind of an anti-corporate guy. However, I completley agree that having real life brand names scattered through a film does help to make the audience feel that they are seeing a world similar, if not identical, to their own. As a matter of fact, removing brand labels, which is done in some films, often stands out and seems awkward. The key is restraint. Does it make sense for Peter Parker to use a soda can as webbing target practice in SM1? Of course it does. Is there anything wrong with the can clearly reading "Dr. Pepper"? Absolutley not. But is it nessescary for that can to get a full two second close up (an eternity in film) when Peter Parker loudly and awkwardly slams the can down on his dresser? Just a bit.
So yah, it's no biggy that Wolverine drinks name-brand beer, and storm crashes into a giant billboard. Just as long as the cinematographer hasn't sold his soul to Wallmart, it'll be ok
It makes a hell of a lot more sense for Spider-Man to use an empty soda can for webbing practice than his framed picture of May and Ben. What an unexcusably badly imagined scene. That was. Way to go, Raimi and Koepp, you managed to compromise or completly strip away pretty much every single facet of Peter Parker's personality.
Yeah, I get what you're saying. I'm not strictly anti-corporate (as in don't trust corporations, but I just don't have an overabundance of energy directed against corporations in general, but I frequently and vehemently condemn certain examples, mainly movie studios and comic book publishers, as all you people well know). I don't like needlessly compromising good art for commercial value. I don't think it's anywhere near impossible to accomodate both sets of demands, if the creators want to do a good job and have the ability.
My pleasure. I really like how this X-men franchise is turning out, and I'm impressed that you're able to start from the first team and still make it really engaging.
Thank you very kindly.
I really appreciate your input, man.
