YES or NO, should Cyclops be killed off?

Yes or No

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Don't get me wrong here. I like Cyke, but I think him being killed off by Jean is a good way to introduce her to the film (with her being over run by power at this point). It introduces her as one of the dark beings of the film and makes her come back absolutely explosive. I think it will give the film a lot of balance. Someone always dies. If Cyke is killed off, I assume Storm will take over as the secondary leader of the X-Men. I'm still finding myself wondering why she isn't already, but Cyke is indeed a great leader. He's smart and intelligent, and is one of Xaviers' first students, which means a great deal. Him being killed by Jean... hmm, I believe to this there is a good side and a bad side. Hard to explain. I guess there is a lot of negativity to it, but a few positives, thinking drama-wise. I can understand however, how all the Cyke fans out there feel. I'd be the same if it happened to Storm, so I'm not sure where to go on this one.
 
micky-fox said:
Don't get me wrong here. I like Cyke, but I think him being killed off by Jean is a good way to introduce her to the film (with her being over run by power at this point). It introduces her as one of the dark beings of the film and makes her come back absolutely explosive. I think it will give the film a lot of balance. Someone always dies. If Cyke is killed off, I assume Storm will rake over as the secondary leader of the X-Men. I'm still finding myself wondering why she isn't already, but Cyke is indeed a great leader. He's smart and intelligent, and is one of Xaviers' first students, which means a great deal. Him being killed by Jean... hmm, I believe to this there is a good side and a bad side. Hard to explain. I guess there is a lot of negativity to it, but a few positives, thinking drama-wise. I can understand however, how all the Cyke fans out there feel. I'd be the same if it happened to Storm, so I'm not sure where to go on this one.

I'd rather have her kill off Professor X. It seems more thematically appropriate for her to kill off her mentor (and the man who blocked off her powers), and Cyke is more important to the storyline.
 
I think Wolverine should die. Jackman said his solo movie will be a prequel and that this is definitely the last X-flick (spinoffs withstanding). So why not have him go out with a bang? I think it would add depth to the character having him change from a self-centered loner in X1 to a martyr for the mutant cause in X3.

That said, here's hoping for a metal skeleton hitting the ground after his hairy hide is scorched by a Sentinel (ala Days of Future Past)! His death could inspire the Brotherhood and X-Men to unite and kick some robot butt. Maybe Cyke will be looking at Logan's tombstone at the end instead of the other way around.
 
If X3 makes just a little bit more than X2, mark my words, there will be X4. The X-Men universe is huge and they have yet to explore it in the movies. :o And I'm sure Hugh was only joking.
 
Dark Beast said:
Why? Why is it so bad to kill of a charactre that hasn't been doing anything THAT necessary to the plot? I don't want another X2. I'd rather have a fair part with a sad sad death.

I see both sides. On one hand, he was an important character in the comics who was underdeveloped in the movies. On the other, Wolverine will be filling his niche in this episode, so why have him stick around? I do agree that it adds to the danger of the Phoenix having Jean snuff him. If she'll turn on her own lover, who wouldn't she kill?

On the other hand, I would love to see all the X-Men in the final battle (with Sentinels no less). I don't know how this will be possible though...wouldn't Xavier be able to track Cyclops down if he did survive Jean's attack? The only way I can see around this is if the Professor bites the bullet before he can get to Cerebro (which isn't shown in this movie).
 
liverlips said:
I think Wolverine should die. Jackman said his solo movie will be a prequel and that this is definitely the last X-flick (spinoffs withstanding). So why not have him go out with a bang? I think it would add depth to the character having him change from a self-centered loner in X1 to a martyr for the mutant cause in X3.

That said, here's hoping for a metal skeleton hitting the ground after his hairy hide is scorched by a Sentinel (ala Days of Future Past)! His death could inspire the Brotherhood and X-Men to unite and kick some robot butt. Maybe Cyke will be looking at Logan's tombstone at the end instead of the other way around.

Yup, I agree. Wolverine should die. Though I think Jackman might be kidding us with the prequel thing... in part maybe. I mean both in the comic world and movieverse because he is so overexposed his character should take a break. He is not the main X-man.

Though as for him speaking about this being the last ever film. How come his colleagues seem to speaking in different terms. Both Kelsey and Vinnie are up for sequels. They're contracted to do so if their characters are optioned. Not to mention that some of the people behind the scenes are talking in terms of sequels too (check IGN for an article about Beast). I think Jackman might be out of the loop a bit.

Though it's entirely possible that there would be a larger break between this and the next one and we would have little or no original members of cast returning. Not to mention that it would be hard to imagine the Fox execs not doing more movies until they go downhill.

As for Cyclops, it's looking worse and worse for him considering they aren't showing anything of him that lets us know if he makes it past the lake scene. In fact we don't see much of him at all.
 
So, if Wolverine does die, how will he die? Jean demolcularizes him?
 
Mr Lex Luthor said:
So, if Wolverine does die, how will he die? Jean demolcularizes him?
Do you mean Cyclops? Yeah, I think that Jean will someow demolcularize him.
 
Mr Lex Luthor said:
So, if Wolverine does die, how will he die? Jean demolcularizes him?

She could toss him into the flames of "Mount Doom"
 
I wasn't sure how to take Jackman's hint: does he actually KNOW it's a prequel and is forced to say "thinks" or is he prohibited from telling us his character survives X3.

As for Cyke, I agree that it doesn't look good for him as he doesn't appear in any of the trailer scenes and the fact Wolverine is chosen to lead the team. However, he could be blindly roaming the wilderness or laid up in the infirmary. I guess we'll find out soon enough.
 
lordofthenerds said:
Do you mean Cyclops? Yeah, I think that Jean will someow demolcularize him.
No, I meant Wolverine.
 
I voted No because in the comics he was an important role in the phoenix saga, but this being a movie, I'm going to say he will die, and just the way the AICN script review said he will. There's alot of evidence right now that is pointing to him being killed at the lake, pics, and trailers. I remember reading an interview, that when mardsen signed on with superman, that the writters for x-men were considering writing his character out of the film, but then mardsen said he wanted to come back to reprise his role of cyclops, I think he siad he would even do it for free. I beleieve at first, they thought mardsen wasn't going to return, and also Halle said she wanted a bigger part, so they were going to have him replaced by another actor, then have him killed off in the beginning, and have storm take over his role as the leader. but then mardsen decided to return, but due to his limited time, they decided to keep the cyclops death included in the movie, and too keep Halle happy. So if this does happen, and your unhappy, you can blame part of it on Halle.
If I had it my way, when Jean takes of his glasses at the lake, he ends up shooting her, knocking her back and thinking that he killed her, but then she arises, not as jean, but as the pheonix, and throws scott into the rocks behind him, she then turns back into jean, and after seeing scott laying still on the ground, freaks out and faints or something. Proffesor X, senses that Jean is alive, tells logan and storm to get to the lake. They arive there to find Scott and Jean lying on the beach (maybe jeans powers are going haywire, and a bunch of rocks and crap are floating in midair (scotts glasses too)). They take them both back to the mansion, Jean awakens to see Scott in a bed next to here, bairly klinging to life. Logan tells her that scott looks in bad shape and probably won't survive. Jean freaks out, tells logan that she did that to scott, but it really wasn't her, that a dark power is inside of her that can controll her when it wants did it, she then tells logan to kill her so she can't hurt anymore people. yada yada, logan can't, then all a sudden, the phoenix arises, attacks a few people, then leaves the mansion, then later joins with magneto.. fast forward to the end, the pheonix is attacking everyone, including the brotherhood, maybe rogue or someone goes to the mansion, and descovers the scott is awake, they tell him whats going on. He arrives at the battle scene, and tries talking to Jean, telling her he loves her, and to fight the pheonix, Jean fights the pheonix, and wins temporarly, she meets scott, and tells him that she can't hold off the pheonix forever, that the pheonix will gain controll again, she tells scott to kill her, he refuses, but understands that she must die in order to save the world, he tells her that he can't not live without her, and that he will go with her, Jean them summons the strength of the pheonix, and destroys both her and scott together. and that's what the memorial at the end could be, a memorial to Scott and Jean.
I hope that's what happens, but who knows, I know Singer would have never killed off scott in the beginning, I guess we only can wait to the first reviews of the test sreenings, to know forsure what happens.
 
Mr Lex Luthor said:
No, I meant Wolverine.
Oh, I doubt if he'll die. Avi said that he has to become a leader at the end of the movie in the X3 preview from the FF dvd, and I doubt if he means a dead leader.
 
I'll have to rent the FF dvd then, even though that movie was god awful
 
realestmutant45 said:
Hell NOO!!
00000009.gif
To The Hype!!!!!!!!!
 
Cyclops shouldn't die. Its a ****ing travesty. But they will kill them off.
 
This board if out of control its increasinmg by the minute.....Must admist its quite entertaining ofcourse NO NO NO NO. Killing off the leader just because of a filming dispute is RIDICLOUS. They could of incorporated him into the story in a far superior way then killing him off in the beginning if thats what happens. He is a must in both the comics and movies.
:ghost:
 
killing off or writting off characters because of disputes happens all the time in film, Terminator 3, Sarah Connor was in the script, Linda didn't want anypart of it, so they killed her off. Alien 3, they killed off Behn's character right away, and he wanted to return. all we know is he has a small amount of screen time, and if they are comparing that to X2, that means we will barely see him in this film, meaning he will be killed off. Don't sit there and think just becuase he's the leader they aren't going to kill him off, this series has been about Wolverine being the center of attention, they have not gone into cyclops backstory, all we know from the films is that him and Jean are together, and they want to introduce pheonix as a monster, and there is no better way then having her kill the person she loves, is she kills him, what would stop her from killing everyone, that's what they want. it sucks, but that is what will happen. and all these theories about him being lost in the woods or whatever, they have not spent even a partial ammount of energ into making cyclops character interesting, why would they do it now. The movie has so many charaters in it and sub plots that there's no way they can fit a story of cyclops being nursed back to health by the bartender in the 1st x-mens. I would really like for cyclops to have an important role in this film, I would really like to see him show up in the end and bring Jean back from the dark side, but I really doubt it will happen, he will die, and that will be more impactful then anything else cyclops has done in these movies......
 
I hate Cyke beeing killed. I just hate ist. It's one of so many ridiculous ideas,the script has...

I wanted him to kick some ass finally in X3, but nooo...
 
JokerNick said:
killing off or writting off characters because of disputes happens all the time in film, Terminator 3, Sarah Connor was in the script, Linda didn't want anypart of it, so they killed her off. Alien 3, they killed off Behn's character right away, and he wanted to return. all we know is he has a small amount of screen time, and if they are comparing that to X2, that means we will barely see him in this film, meaning he will be killed off. Don't sit there and think just becuase he's the leader they aren't going to kill him off, this series has been about Wolverine being the center of attention, they have not gone into cyclops backstory, all we know from the films is that him and Jean are together, and they want to introduce pheonix as a monster, and there is no better way then having her kill the person she loves, is she kills him, what would stop her from killing everyone, that's what they want. it sucks, but that is what will happen. and all these theories about him being lost in the woods or whatever, they have not spent even a partial ammount of energ into making cyclops character interesting, why would they do it now. The movie has so many charaters in it and sub plots that there's no way they can fit a story of cyclops being nursed back to health by the bartender in the 1st x-mens. I would really like for cyclops to have an important role in this film, I would really like to see him show up in the end and bring Jean back from the dark side, but I really doubt it will happen, he will die, and that will be more impactful then anything else cyclops has done in these movies......

I agree. I never undestood all these half baked plots about Cyclops
 
cyke's going to be back by films end. im telling you this right now.


he shot for TWO WEEKS. so far we know he has the scene with jean and he has a scene in the X-mansion (proof provided by the illegaly released pictures) those two scene's ALONE would take five days tops. hell, magneto shot for two weeks in X2 and look at how much of the movie he's involved in.
top this all off by the fact that their is a cyclops costume that has been made for marsden to wear (again, the picture of scott in uniform) they would not waste that ammount of money on only promotional material. cyclops will somehow return by films end it's just logic, and you can quote me on this.
 

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,265
Messages
22,075,365
Members
45,874
Latest member
kedenlewis
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"