Wow, way to kiss Slott's ass, everybody. Seriously, am I the only one who sees that as being ******ed? Everyone's more than willing to rag on Quesada and JMS for creating the OMD nightmare that leads into BND, but no one wants to own up to the fact that Slott was there, pitching in to ruin Spider-Man.
Dan Slott, I used to really root for you, man. You were the underdog, always championing for the integrity of the continuity and the characters. You were the new Brevoort. Now, like Brevoort, you've either given up on trying to preserve the Marvel Universe or you honestly think you're telling the kinds of stories that that fans (of which, I would've counted you at one time) want to read. We don't. The "vocal minority" of the internet is quickly turning into the vocal majority.
So go on and make your money, Dan. Cash in on those royalty checks and keep your belly full. Just know that you're doing it at the expense of 40+ years of history and millions of fans. Know that with every page of BND that you hand in, you're raising your finger to the fans that much higher.
You've worked hard to get this spot, man. I hope it's worth it.
You act as if Dan Slott is some editor, or a writer-who-acts-like-an-editor like Bendis. Yeah, he's been part of those "creator summits" since 2006, but he still is just a writer. Joe Q has been mentioning his disdain for the Parker marriage a year before OMD hit. Do you really think if Slott went, "Y'know, I really don't have a problem with the marriage and I don't need a retcon to be set up for me nixing it," they would have stopped? And then what then? Does Slott storm off in a huff, or post some rant online like JMS, and then what? Either he creates a hostile work environment, jeopardizes his own books as a result, and loses the chance to write Spider-Man, a dream for any creator. I would also add that suddenly being known for disagreeing with "the boss" when they make drastic decisions won't help your career. Slott has to work in this biz. Everyone has seen what happens to types the Gerber who rattle too many cages. Yeah, the fans love 'em...all the way to the poor house. No one gives them any work. Even DC, competitive as it is, might be hestiant considering all the stuff they do. But Slott seems comfier with Marvel, and I like him there, too.
OMD was happening so long as Joe Q had the power. JMS himself said he couldn't derail it and wanted his credits taken off, but sucked it up as a professional. Slott is doing likewise, at the very least.
If you were offered the chance to write Spidey after OMD, you would take it. If not, you are either a fool or a liar.
Think about it like this; who ELSE do you trust as making the best of BND, and possibly starting the road back to the way things were, if editorially given the chance?
Ouch, way to not pull punches. I honestly don't know what Slott's involvement in any of the OMD stuff was, but I can't fault him for taking the opportunity to write Spider-Man when he got it. If I were in his shoes, I'd likely do the same. I'd understand if people didn't want to buy it because of outrage over what came before and the auspices that my work would be operating under, but it's still Spider-Man at the end of the day. That's a childhood dream for a lot of writers, I'm sure.
I'm more in line with this sentiment.
Why deprive myself of possibly good Spider-Man comics, which I have been waiting for from Slott for over 2 years, just out of some need to "stick it to Marvel to vent my rage" when said action would had NO, ZERO EFFECT. Your LCS will not notice one iota the crunch of the fans "boycotting". For every one fan online, maybe 10 just buy the books and go about their lives. Likely more. Everyone hated THE OTHER, but it still sold very well. My LCS will order a few dozen copies of BND, and whether or not I happen to buy one won't effect how many they order the next time. By the time comics hit the shelves, Marvel has been paid long before.
Besides, what if Slott bucks the odds, creates great stories, and starts directing things towards a more sane direction?
I will say, though, that after OMD, USM is now officially redundant.