Contest of Marvels II Thread 4

Titania VS Diablo

I think I will have Titania advance, unless someone has a debate that convinces me Diablo could beat her.:xmen:
 
REBUTTAL: Justice vs Prodigy

Security will be off until it's turned on, and considering Justice is a respected member of the Avengers and New Warriors, I sincerely doubt the prison will register him as a threat. Secondly, Justice will be able to get info on the Raft, whereas I doubt Prodigy will. That means he's going to make a beeline for the control room.

I really don't recall the corridors being all that narrow, and two people wide is still enough for Justice to fly around. He's still going to cover land quicker than Prodigy will. I will agree that there won't be any long stretches of corridors, but they'll be long enough for Justice to have that little bit of extra speed.
What the hell? the prison is now sentient enough to recognize "hey, that kid's a New Warrior and used to be an Avenger, I shouldn't touch him." BULL! Besides, the New Warriors are basically unknowns. His time as an Avenger is long past. The second he tries to force his way through any barrier the prison's defenses will certainly kick in and try to put him down. maybe they'll gas him, maybe they'll hit him with tranq darts, but the second he triest to force his way through anything, He will be fighting the prison's defenses, which will register him as a Meta-human trying to break out. I don't care wht you say, this is a Maximum security prison designed to hold meta-humans. It will have automated defenses to stop a telekinetic and it will have power dampening technology.


That's not what I'm saying at all. I'm saying Justice has been in prison, and prisons usually don't really differ much when it comes to their lay-outs. Experience in that area beats out the technology (how exactly is Prodigy going to bring up a HUD map without first hacking into the Raft's technology?). Besides, Justice will be able to acquire schematics to the Raft and use that.
Again, I work in prisons. I have visited several aside from the one I work in primarily. they all vary from each other in large degrees. just because he went to A prison, doesn't mean he knows ALL prisons. that's just bull. and Prodigy is getting his Head's-Up Display map because he'll have likely downloaded the building's schematics in his day of preptime. He'll have done all his research thoroughly. He'll know the terrain, and he'll know his opponent. How would Justice get the schematics? how will Justice get the blue-prints?


A) Take a chill pill. I've explained this before. Justice will make his way to the control room as well. His powers allow him to be faster. He just needs to wait Prodigy out.
B) "Building long before HoM", that means several weeks. He's a genius, I know that, and I've admitted to it. That doesn't mean he's broken into a control room in a few minutes, hacks the computer, hacks the video feed etc. etc.
C) It did not take the X-Men several years to build and program. The original Danger Room was a pretty basic one and the later Shi'ar one they had little to no hand in adapting.
A: you haven't explained it well enough. he may be faster, but he won't know where the hell he is. the prison is large with many narrow dark corridors. It would take luck for him to locate the master control before Prodigy.
B: It mean's he's hacked the X-men's computers to duplicate their simulation files. it means he's great at writing and rerwriting programing. It means he can quickly learn how to manipulate a system
C: It took them many years to get the Danger Room to what it is today and Prodigy understood schematics and blue-prints that included Advanced Alien Technology and rebuilt it in a matter of weeks. That, to me, suggests he's smart enough to override a computer.


A) How are you avoiding such a move exactly. Get the picture in your head. Giant invisible hand scooping somebody up. Even if you know he's going for that tactic, it's hard to avoid. I'd almost say impossible.
B) I don't see how blanketing will kill him at all. :huh: It'll put him down against the ground. Justice would never use the force necessary to kill Prodigy, but he doesn't need to. I'm really befuddled on how you automatically assume this tactic kills Prodigy.
A: because, as soon as Justice is aiming at him with a plan in mind, Prodigy is already moving, forcing him to rework his plan. Okay, he's got a hand aimed at him, but damnit if the kid isn't already in another spot, so now he has to concieve of a hand there, but the kid's moving again.
B: You are talking about something that would be all encompassing and would either force him to the ground or wall against the hard sharp metal of the prison, or something that would seize his entire body, thus cutting off his air supply.


Not true, actually. The cells are designed to nullify powers. There's nothing suggesting that the rest of the prison is outfitted with the same power dampening technology. That'd be horribly expensive and impractical. The prisoners aren't supposed to get out of their cells. Heck, by the way it's written, it's not actually power dampening tech anyway, it's pumping the prisoner full of drugs. Big difference.
you're telling me that you think a prison designed for the specific purpose of holding and containing meta humans, some of which with advanced healing factors that would render drugs USELESS, is going to rely SOLEY on drugs and is not going to take advantage of any other form of power dampening, and will most certainly not put any power dampening technology anywhere but the cells. Because you know it's illegal for them to spend all their time in the cells. this is a U.S. Prison. they have a right to yard time, even inmates in solitary get yard time, I promise you that. It's illegal to refuse it to them. (the only reason they get away with total isolation in 42 is because it is not within U.S. Jurisdiction)


A) That's not really how telekinetics work. It's a mind power which works almost instantly. Most telekinetics' powers are in effect the moment they think of it.
B) Again, how is he going to mess it up? He has no other powers. Then there's the fact that some strategies you simply can't avoid. Some you will need to overcome with brute strength, something Prodigy does not possess.
A:It doesn't work instantly virtually all telekinetics, among others, gesture to focus their powers. you rarely see them where they don't.
B: He's going to mess it up by causing Justice to constantly change his tactic and target as he constantly moves to exactly be in the wrong place.



But Prodigy will have to apply it in the literal sense for that knowledge to be effective.
What?


No, it won't. The prison works with drugs, not power dampening tech.
I've addressed this

Now, as for the whole "dodge attacks thing", a little graphic I quickly whipped up to illustrate:
I give it a C... unless you're in Kindergarten

WINNER=PRODIGY
 
Nick Fury vs Empath

Empath is not an opponent someone without mental powers wants to take on. But this is Nick Fury. And with Nick, it's all about the prep-time.

Empath will know about Nick, even if it's only through team resources. Nick, will know everything there is to know about Empath. Well, he'll know everything SHIELD know, which is usually everything about everybody.

But Nick's biggest prep-time advantage is not just information, but resources. Nick has access to all SHIELD equipment, and even if he's never used it before, he's seen it all (and was probably the one to authorize it's construction) and has access to the information on how to use everything.

Since SHIELD is no stranger to fighting all types of super-powered beings, there should little doubt that they have equipment designed to protect the user from mental attacks from telepaths. And that would include Empath.

Without his power over emotions, Empath can only rely on his fighting and other skills. And no matter how good those are, it's almost a certainty that Nick is his equal or superior in these department, especially in strategy and tactics.

So, in battle, with SHIELD technology for offense and defense, and years of experience, there's no reason Nick Fury shouldn't win this fight.

None of that even takes into account the location of the match. This is a facility designed to keep superhumans imprisoned. This would include technology to keep guards safe from telepaths. There shouldn't be any reason Nick can't use the facility and weapons within it against Empath. Nick could probably get all the blueprints and facts about the prison as well. (SHIELD was probably involved in the design and construction of the facility. At the very least, they would have been consulted.)

If Empath is lucky, Nick won't kill him, and will only drug, knockout, or imprison him.


Nick Fury wins
 
Fury is a human that no longer controls Shield ;).

Empath would know who Fury was and depending on Fury's access, he could get information on Empath.

Empath would arrive and sense where Fury was and simply turn him into a zombie. This would be instantaneous and there are no defences against it. The battle is then over.

Winner - Empath


This battle is not going to be as quick or easy for Empath as you may think. There's every reason to think Nick will win this fight.

(I'm not sure when Nick lost command of SHIELD. If it is part of an ongoing storyline, it wouldn't be counted, and he'd still be in command. I think it was before anything currently going on, so I'll assume he's out of SHIELD right now. My previous argument holds if he still is in.)

Fury may not be in command of SHIELD, but he is the master of preparation. This can be seen in the safehouses he set up that are used in Civil War. I know Civil War is an ongoing storyline that can't be used, but those safe houses had to be setup well in advance. Nick probably set them up and filled them with all the SHIELD equipment and data he could years ago. And he would still be able to use these. (The idea of a man like Fury not having safe houses planted around the for years seems ludicrous).

At this point, it again boils down to Fury using telepathic protection to give himself the time to stop Empath. The protection doesn't have to be perfect, just give him the time to use the prison's defenses and weapons, or any equipment he brings to the battle. Nick is someone who would train his mind with mental shields against (weaker) telepaths. That, combined with technological protection, should give Fury all the time he needs.


Nick Fury wins
 
REBUTTAL: Justice vs Prodigy
What the hell? the prison is now sentient enough to recognize "hey, that kid's a New Warrior and used to be an Avenger, I shouldn't touch him."
[...]
I don't care wht you say, this is a Maximum security prison designed to hold meta-humans. It will have automated defenses to stop a telekinetic and it will have power dampening technology.
- The prison would require a certain amount of programming to ensure it doesn't take down heroes along with its villains. There's a reason the prison doesn't register every metahuman as a threat. He's got Avengers clearance (and really, it wasn't that long ago. 2 years Marvel time tops).
- Tranq darts and gas can be avoided using telekinetics.
- It won't have power dampening tech, because it hasn't been shown to have it. It's an assumption that flies in the face of what've seen. The villains are put in place with drugs, not power dampeners. Start caring then.

Again, I work in prisons. I have visited several aside from the one I work in primarily. they all vary from each other in large degrees. just because he went to A prison, doesn't mean he knows ALL prisons. that's just bull. and Prodigy is getting his Head's-Up Display map because he'll have likely downloaded the building's schematics in his day of preptime. He'll have done all his research thoroughly. He'll know the terrain, and he'll know his opponent. How would Justice get the schematics? how will Justice get the blue-prints?
Avengers clearance anybody? He's still a reserve member. Once an Avenger, always an Avenger and all that hooey. Beyond that, I'll conceed to the "knows prisons thing", but it doesn't change a thing about simple use of sight. Justice sees a corridor. Justice flies to the end of it in a second. Rinse and repeat.

A: you haven't explained it well enough. he may be faster, but he won't know where the hell he is. the prison is large with many narrow dark corridors. It would take luck for him to locate the master control before Prodigy.
Use of blueprints.

B: It mean's he's hacked the X-men's computers to duplicate their simulation files. it means he's great at writing and rerwriting programing. It means he can quickly learn how to manipulate a system
"Quickly"? It took him weeks.

C: It took them many years to get the Danger Room to what it is today and Prodigy understood schematics and blue-prints that included Advanced Alien Technology and rebuilt it in a matter of weeks. That, to me, suggests he's smart enough to override a computer.
I really don't see where you get the "it took them many years"-thing from. When they got the Shi'ar tech, I don't recall it taking a long time at all to have it installed and be the new Danger Room. The X-Men have had the same Danger Room for over a decade now, real-time.

A: because, as soon as Justice is aiming at him with a plan in mind, Prodigy is already moving, forcing him to rework his plan. Okay, he's got a hand aimed at him, but damnit if the kid isn't already in another spot, so now he has to concieve of a hand there, but the kid's moving again.
Because that kind of a plan would certainly take ages. Justice thinks, mental hand appears. Let's just even say for a moment that Prodigy is capable of dodging this. Y'know what to do? Move hand, faster than Prodigy can move. Telekinetics are instant, Prodigy isn't.

B: You are talking about something that would be all encompassing and would either force him to the ground or wall against the hard sharp metal of the prison, or something that would seize his entire body, thus cutting off his air supply.
He says he has to do with a particular vengeance. He can gently force Prodigy to the ground. It also doesn't really cut off anything of his air supply, unless Justice wants that to happen. And oh yeah, if your air supply is cut off, you go unconscious first. You don't immediately die. Justice can let up then.

you're telling me that you think a prison designed for the specific purpose of holding and containing meta humans, some of which with advanced healing factors that would render drugs USELESS, is going to rely SOLEY on drugs and is not going to take advantage of any other form of power dampening, and will most certainly not put any power dampening technology anywhere but the cells. Because you know it's illegal for them to spend all their time in the cells. this is a U.S. Prison. they have a right to yard time, even inmates in solitary get yard time, I promise you that. It's illegal to refuse it to them. (the only reason they get away with total isolation in 42 is because it is not within U.S. Jurisdiction)
We are shown nothing of power dampening technology. That is an assumption. We try and avoid using assumptions in this contest. The drugs were obviously good enough to make the Purple Man think he still had control of his powers, when he didn't. All of what you're saying can obviously be accomplished with such drugs. This is not the real world, boyo, it's the Marvel universe.

A:It doesn't work instantly virtually all telekinetics, among others, gesture to focus their powers. you rarely see them where they don't.
I don't ever actually recall a telekinetic gesture with his/her hand to focus their power. Either way, Justice has shown that he doesn't need to do this. Most telekinetics are also trained enough that thought instantly becomes action.

B: He's going to mess it up by causing Justice to constantly change his tactic and target as he constantly moves to exactly be in the wrong place.
Yep, because Prodigy has superhuman speed... Oh wait, he doesn't. A forcefield around him isn't something he can avoid. Ask some of the Invisible Woman's foes.

I give it a C... unless you're in Kindergarten
It deserves a C. It was a five minute thing in Microsoft Paint. Funny how you dodged the validity of it, because I obviously couldn't make my point clear to you verbally.

There are some things you cannot avoid!

WINNER=JUSTICE
 
- The prison would require a certain amount of programming to ensure it doesn't take down heroes along with its villains. There's a reason the prison doesn't register every metahuman as a threat. He's got Avengers clearance (and really, it wasn't that long ago. 2 years Marvel time tops).
- Tranq darts and gas can be avoided using telekinetics.
- It won't have power dampening tech, because it hasn't been shown to have it. It's an assumption that flies in the face of what've seen. The villains are put in place with drugs, not power dampeners. Start caring then.
=programing that would cause it to recognize anyone who triest to break through barriers as an enemy. plus it wasn't watched over by meta's like 42. the entire staff were base-line humans. and as far as his Avenger's clearance, by the time this contest takes place, the Avengers have disbanded, and his clearance won't get him a cup of coffee, much less allowances from security devices.
=If he's omnicient, yeah that makes perfect sense. Oh, and his sheilds block gas? but later on you said they don't. so which is it?
=It isn't assumption it's logical thinking. Like I said, it houased several metas with enhanced healing factor upon whom drugs would be worth exactly dick. relying soley on drugs WOULDN'T MAKE SENSE!


Avengers clearance anybody? He's still a reserve member. Once an Avenger, always an Avenger and all that hooey. Beyond that, I'll conceed to the "knows prisons thing", but it doesn't change a thing about simple use of sight. Justice sees a corridor. Justice flies to the end of it in a second. Rinse and repeat.
Again, his Avengers clearance doesn't mean anything anymore. The Avengers that he was a part of were dissolved at this point. besides, when he left the Avengers, they would have revoked his clearance. That would only be sensible. Your Once-An-Avenger crap doesn't work because at this point we are discussing "New Avengers" a whole new monster. oh, and to use your words, "That works because Justices has super-speed... oh, he doesn't."


Use of blueprints.
that he pulled from his anus??


"Quickly"? It took him weeks.
to BUILD IT and that had to be from scrounged parts, he built the whole thing, by himself, from scrounged parts, in a couple of weeks, in his spare time, and nobody noticed him doing it.


I really don't see where you get the "it took them many years"-thing from. When they got the Shi'ar tech, I don't recall it taking a long time at all to have it installed and be the new Danger Room. The X-Men have had the same Danger Room for over a decade now, real-time.
The Danger Room, in it's current incarnation has taken years to get to this point. years of constant upgrades done by Beast, Forge, and eventually the Shi'ar (Who in case you forgot are a few hundred years ahead of us technologically speaking) and Alex understood it well enough to build a reasonable facsimile BY HIMSELF from scrap parts in a few weeks with nobody noticing.


Because that kind of a plan would certainly take ages. Justice thinks, mental hand appears. Let's just even say for a moment that Prodigy is capable of dodging this. Y'know what to do? Move hand, faster than Prodigy can move. Telekinetics are instant, Prodigy isn't.
No, telekinetics are not instant, they take time to concieve, to become active will, to materialize, to focus energy, to gesture. Just like it takes time to move your muscles. It is not instant. It may only take a few seconds, but it is a few seconds that Prodigy can use.


He says he has to do with a particular vengeance. He can gently force Prodigy to the ground. It also doesn't really cut off anything of his air supply, unless Justice wants that to happen. And oh yeah, if your air supply is cut off, you go unconscious first. You don't immediately die. Justice can let up then.
So Justice waits until Prodigy stops moving and then lets up? fine, at that point, when he comes to inspect the victim, Prodigy kicks him in the head having just held his breath and relaxed his body to fake unconciousness. So his force field doesn't cut off air, but up above you said it would protect him from gas? this sounds like a move that would kill Prodigy.


We are shown nothing of power dampening technology. That is an assumption. We try and avoid using assumptions in this contest. The drugs were obviously good enough to make the Purple Man think he still had control of his powers, when he didn't. All of what you're saying can obviously be accomplished with such drugs. This is not the real world, boyo, it's the Marvel universe.
This is a prison, and I fancy that I know a few more things about prisons than you do... boyo. and if you recall in the last decade Marvel has been trying to make the 616 reflect reality. This location was introduced in a story written by Bendis after all. relying on drugs ONLY is too stupid even for beurocrats.


I don't ever actually recall a telekinetic gesture with his/her hand to focus their power. Either way, Justice has shown that he doesn't need to do this. Most telekinetics are also trained enough that thought instantly becomes action.
You know that moment where they throw up their hands? or that moment when they point at something? or maybe that moment where they ball up their fist? you know how directly after it, their telekinetic power approximates that movement? That's gesturing.


Yep, because Prodigy has superhuman speed... Oh wait, he doesn't. A forcefield around him isn't something he can avoid. Ask some of the Invisible Woman's foes.
I'm trying to think of another way to phrase my argument because you still aren't understanding. Prodigy knows how Justice will attack. He knows what moves he'll make. you yourself said that He'll know how Justice uses his telekinetic abilities. Well he will use that knowledge to know exactly how to keep Justice on the defensive. he will use that knowledge to make sure he isn't in a position where Justices can encapsulate him, or blanket him, or seize him.


It deserves a C. It was a five minute thing in Microsoft Paint. Funny how you dodged the validity of it, because I obviously couldn't make my point clear to you verbally.
It was a joke, relax. Sorry if I offended you. You want me to try and refute it? FINE; You still don't understand my point. Since Prodigy knows ALL POSSIBLE MOVES JUSTICE WOULD MAKE he can find ways out of them and make sure he is not in a position to be hurt. He will find ways to be so that Justice can't catch him with a blanket or seize him.

WINNER=PRODIGY
 
Nick Fury vs Empath - Rebuttal

Empath is not an opponent someone without mental powers wants to take on. But this is Nick Fury. And with Nick, it's all about the prep-time.

Empath will know about Nick, even if it's only through team resources. Nick, will know everything there is to know about Empath. Well, he'll know everything SHIELD know, which is usually everything about everybody.

I am not sure Shield will know too much given this is a Spanish mutant. But given his name I think Fury could figure out that he is dealing with someone who affects people's emotions.

But Nick's biggest prep-time advantage is not just information, but resources. Nick has access to all SHIELD equipment, and even if he's never used it before, he's seen it all (and was probably the one to authorize it's construction) and has access to the information on how to use everything.

Since SHIELD is no stranger to fighting all types of super-powered beings, there should little doubt that they have equipment designed to protect the user from mental attacks from telepaths. And that would include Empath.

Without his power over emotions, Empath can only rely on his fighting and other skills. And no matter how good those are, it's almost a certainty that Nick is his equal or superior in these department, especially in strategy and tactics.

So, in battle, with SHIELD technology for offense and defense, and years of experience, there's no reason Nick Fury shouldn't win this fight.

None of that even takes into account the location of the match. This is a facility designed to keep superhumans imprisoned. This would include technology to keep guards safe from telepaths. There shouldn't be any reason Nick can't use the facility and weapons within it against Empath. Nick could probably get all the blueprints and facts about the prison as well. (SHIELD was probably involved in the design and construction of the facility. At the very least, they would have been consulted.)

If Empath is lucky, Nick won't kill him, and will only drug, knockout, or imprison him.

Regarding whether Fury is in charge of Shield at the time of the battle is something the bosses have to state. However, he was no longer in charge for a period that started just before the civil war books. He was hoever in charge just before Planet Hulk.

In any case, I do not remember of any device that would protect Fury from Empath's powers. Fury cannot just invent it for this match.

Empath's powers would allow him to sense Fury from anywhere in the Raft and he could wipe out Fury's mind very quickly. If you wish to base your whole startegy on a deus ex machina sort of device then it should be described and referenced here. Fury is not Batman.

On a side note, if Fury did get such a device, lets not forget that Empath is an active member of a team that fights in the field and as such has fighting skills which would be at least on par with someone used to controlling things from HQ.

Empath wins
 
This battle is not going to be as quick or easy for Empath as you may think. There's every reason to think Nick will win this fight.

(I'm not sure when Nick lost command of SHIELD. If it is part of an ongoing storyline, it wouldn't be counted, and he'd still be in command. I think it was before anything currently going on, so I'll assume he's out of SHIELD right now. My previous argument holds if he still is in.)

As I stated above, I am not sure so I will leave it to JH or Phaed to decide.

Fury may not be in command of SHIELD, but he is the master of preparation. This can be seen in the safehouses he set up that are used in Civil War. I know Civil War is an ongoing storyline that can't be used, but those safe houses had to be setup well in advance. Nick probably set them up and filled them with all the SHIELD equipment and data he could years ago. And he would still be able to use these. (The idea of a man like Fury not having safe houses planted around the for years seems ludicrous).

At this point, it again boils down to Fury using telepathic protection to give himself the time to stop Empath. The protection doesn't have to be perfect, just give him the time to use the prison's defenses and weapons, or any equipment he brings to the battle. Nick is someone who would train his mind with mental shields against (weaker) telepaths. That, combined with technological protection, should give Fury all the time he needs.

I do not want to sound repetitive but this battle is very simple. Either Empath's powers will work, (and unless there is some device out there in Shield's control, there is not) in which case, this battle would be over before it starts.

Empath has taken over whole cities before. He has a great range and could therefore wipe out Fury's mind from anywhere on the Raft.

Now, if you can prove (which requires explaining the device that already exists) that Empath's powers can be negated then the match is more even and Empath with his field skills will have to damage the device in a physical battle with Fury.

Empath wins
 
SUMMARIZING COMMENTS: Justice vs Prodigy

I've gotten a little tired of the going in circles, so I'm going to summarize a few thoughts and strategies here. I'll work in some things that need a final rebuttle, but most of your arguments are refuted here.

General comments
- Justice has Avengers clearance and should have access to info about the Raft.
- Vance can clear the corridors of the Raft must faster thanks to his telekinetics. Whether they are short or long distances, he is without a doubt faster than Prodigy, who has no physical superhuman powers.
- Justice has fine tuned control of his powers to such a degree that he can even detect when somebody is lying through the use of his telekinetics.

Strategies to subdue Prodigy
- Create a forcefield around him. There is no way to avoid this.
- Blanket the area, forcing Prodigy to the ground. Again, no way to avoid this.
- Lift him up by spreading a telekinetic field under him. Can't avoid since it encompasses the entire area.

Ways to avoid security measures
- Avengers clearance.
- Forcefield.
- Psionic bolts that have quite the potency for destruction.

On the Raft and power dampening
Here are some scans on:
A) The lay-out of the prison.
B) The technology for prisoner-subdueing.

- You were right, the corridors aren't small... they're gigantic.

- Drugged out of his gourd, away from human contact, superpowered chaperone required.

(I know you're thinking: "powers neutralized", but she only comments on the drugs.)
- Remember that gigantic corridor thing? Justice covers these kinds of things in a minute.

- To come back to that Purple Man fellow.

- Ryker's got power dampeners though. It doesn't encompass the entirety of the building. They're just collars. Then, not everyone has them. So you were right, in part, that I can admit (although this is the Ryker's facility, not the Raft).


Knowing that however, strengthens my argument. There is no way Prodigy will be able to get a collar on Justice or drug him. His telekinetic forcefield will see that. Even then, like I've said, it's highly doubtful that Prodigy will make it to the control room before Justice does, since the corridors to move through are huge, and Justice is a lot faster. Heck, even if Prodigy gets to the control room earlier, he's going to have to hack into the systems and then actually use the technology there to his advantage. Except there isn't actually any real tech that would help him.

=If he's omnicient, yeah that makes perfect sense. Oh, and his sheilds block gas? but later on you said they don't. so which is it?
I'm not saying it blocks gas. I'm saying it can be avoided. He has the advantage of speed and power. He can break through a few walls.

Again, his Avengers clearance doesn't mean anything anymore. The Avengers that he was a part of were dissolved at this point. besides, when he left the Avengers, they would have revoked his clearance. That would only be sensible. Your Once-An-Avenger crap doesn't work because at this point we are discussing "New Avengers" a whole new monster. oh, and to use your words, "That works because Justices has super-speed... oh, he doesn't."
Let's even say that for a second, Justice's reputation as a hero and his affiliation with groups like the Avengers are nulled: He can still get to the control room faster. Using telekinesis he can accelerate to great speeds while flying.

to BUILD IT and that had to be from scrounged parts, he built the whole thing, by himself, from scrounged parts, in a couple of weeks, in his spare time, and nobody noticed him doing it.
A) We really don't know how long it took him, and it still had glitches.
B) I'm also going to remind you that you can't actually use this argument, as it is against the rules.

No, telekinetics are not instant, they take time to concieve, to become active will, to materialize, to focus energy, to gesture. Just like it takes time to move your muscles. It is not instant. It may only take a few seconds, but it is a few seconds that Prodigy can use.
Practically instant. A second or two for the hard stuff. The creation of a telekinetic wall is pretty much instant, since it takes little to no time to concieve and is there where he wants it immediately. They really don't need the gesturing. It's a visual thing that not all telekinetics do. Justice among them half the time.


So Justice waits until Prodigy stops moving and then lets up? fine, at that point, when he comes to inspect the victim, Prodigy kicks him in the head having just held his breath and relaxed his body to fake unconciousness. So his force field doesn't cut off air, but up above you said it would protect him from gas? this sounds like a move that would kill Prodigy.
You're the one who said it would cut him off from air. I responded by saying that even then, people go unconscious first. Secondly, Justice can use his telekinetics to see if someone is lying, and by effect, if they're even conscious. Besides, once he's forced to the ground, Justice can just pick him up with his telekinetics.

You know that moment where they throw up their hands? or that moment when they point at something? or maybe that moment where they ball up their fist? you know how directly after it, their telekinetic power approximates that movement? That's gesturing.
I know what gesturing is. I also know that telekinetics really don't need to do iit, and Justice doesn't either.

I'm trying to think of another way to phrase my argument because you still aren't understanding.
It's just that is having trouble understanding. Not everything can be avoided by seeing it coming. You state that Prodigy will make sure he is in a position that he can avoid something like blanketing, seizing or the like, but he can't. It's a physical impossibility.

It was a joke, relax. Sorry if I offended you.
No offense taken.

Now, I'm really pretty much done with this debate. I've given all of the evidence needed for Justice to win this, and have shown that Prodigy really has little chance to win this (unless Justice suddenly became a moron). Great debate, but we're going around in circles so much, it hurts.

WINNER=JUSTICE
 
General comments
- Justice has Avengers clearance and should have access to info about the Raft.
His Avenger's Clearance is worthless since they disbanded. It doesn't mean dick anymore.
- Vance can clear the corridors of the Raft must faster thanks to his telekinetics. Whether they are short or long distances, he is without a doubt faster than Prodigy, who has no physical superhuman powers.
So he'll be running into walls then? You make it sound like he has super-speed. The best he can do is go at a running speed. he doesn't have the reaction time necessary to maintain high speeds in a confined environment.
- Justice has fine tuned control of his powers to such a degree that he can even detect when somebody is lying through the use of his telekinetics.
Which means that Prodigy knows exactly how good Justice is and exactly how to lie to him.

Strategies to subdue Prodigy
- Create a forcefield around him. There is no way to avoid this.
- Blanket the area, forcing Prodigy to the ground. Again, no way to avoid this.
- Lift him up by spreading a telekinetic field under him. Can't avoid since it encompasses the entire area.
Before Prodigy let things get this close, he would have found a way to neutralize Justice's powers.

Ways to avoid security measures
- Avengers clearance.
Worthless as this fight takes AFTER the Avengers dissassembled and there is no one here who could remember that he was an Avenger except Prodigy
- Forcefield.
Good idea, he should wear himself out before he gets to Prodigy. Using telekinetics exerts energy. He isnt' the Phoenix, using his powers drains him, if slowly, it drains him. So for that little idea to work, he would need a constant forcefield. Or he would need to erect an instantaneous forcefield when he detected that he'd tripped automatic systems, which would not block the gas... or it might.
- Psionic bolts that have quite the potency for destruction.
this would certainly trigger automated defense systems that any person can logically understand are there

On the Raft and power dampening
Here are some scans on:
A) The lay-out of the prison.
B) The technology for prisoner-subdueing.

- You were right, the corridors aren't small... they're gigantic.

- Drugged out of his gourd, away from human contact, superpowered chaperone required.

(I know you're thinking: "powers neutralized", but she only comments on the drugs.)
- Remember that gigantic corridor thing? Justice covers these kinds of things in a minute.


Knowing that however, strengthens my argument. There is no way Prodigy will be able to get a collar on Justice or drug him. His telekinetic forcefield will see that. Even then, like I've said, it's highly doubtful that Prodigy will make it to the control room before Justice does, since the corridors to move through are huge, and Justice is a lot faster. Heck, even if Prodigy gets to the control room earlier, he's going to have to hack into the systems and then actually use the technology there to his advantage. Except there isn't actually any real tech that would help him.
That is ONE corridor, and it is for visitors. the inards of the building are very narrow, as seen later on in that same issue where they are down near the Sentry's cell. But you chose not to display pictures of that. You also assume that whoever built this prison is a moron who never planned to have people with healing-factors incarcerated or people with teleportation abilities, or mystical abilities. You're right, prisons are always built by short sighted people... NOT.


I'm not saying it blocks gas. I'm saying it can be avoided. He has the advantage of speed and power. He can break through a few walls.
But you did say it could block the gas as you said it would protect him from the defenses with a forceifield. and if it blocks gas, then it would sufficate a person to wrap them up or force them down. In fact it would suffocate him to place himself in a force field if it blocked gas. He has no super-speed, and he only has the advantage of power until Prodigy finds the way to take it away from him.


Let's even say that for a second, Justice's reputation as a hero and his affiliation with groups like the Avengers are nulled: He can still get to the control room faster. Using telekinesis he can accelerate to great speeds while flying.
Again, he "Accelerates to great speeds" then he's going to hit walls. Speedsters have enhanced reaction times and reflexes to allow themselves to operate at those speeds and not hit stuff. His reputation is worth dick because, at this point the Avengers were dissassembled at there were no formal Avengers that he'd ever been a part of and no person here to aknowledge that he'd been an Avenger and help him.



A) We really don't know how long it took him, and it still had glitches.
B) I'm also going to remind you that you can't actually use this argument, as it is against the rules.
Why can't I use this argument? Unless you are going to argue that he built the whole thing post-M-Day, I can argue that he was building it well before he M-Day. and even if he did manage to build it post M-Day, that only doubles my arguments about his brains. and on another matter, so what if it had glitches?! I'd like to see you build and program a regular pc from scrounged parts that works half as well as his Danger Room did.


Practically instant. A second or two for the hard stuff. The creation of a telekinetic wall is pretty much instant, since it takes little to no time to concieve and is there where he wants it immediately. They really don't need the gesturing. It's a visual thing that not all telekinetics do. Justice among them half the time.
I've read stuff with plenty of telekinetics, including Justice. EVERY ONE OF THEM except the uber-powered like Phoenix, gestures and moves their arms or such to indicate the action they are going to do. it's as instant as moving any other part of their pdy. so if he attacks with tendrils, or bolts, or fists, or force field (Which he probably will as he will know nothing about Prodigy), then he will miss as Prodigy has better reaction time than Justice. Not to mention that by the time it gets this close Prodigy will have found a way to use the prison's defenses against him and nullify those powers.



You're the one who said it would cut him off from air. I responded by saying that even then, people go unconscious first. Secondly, Justice can use his telekinetics to see if someone is lying, and by effect, if they're even conscious. Besides, once he's forced to the ground, Justice can just pick him up with his telekinetics.
No, you said the force fields would protect him from gas attacks, wich means they would cut off air supplies. and further more as at this point Prodigy would know everything Justice knows, he would know what signs Justice looks for to detect lies or conciousness. He could fake truth or unconsciousness easily.


I know what gesturing is. I also know that telekinetics really don't need to do iit, and Justice doesn't either.
Yes he does. only the most powerful of telekinetics does not gesture. and in any case, it is no more instant than the move ment of a body part. and as I said before, Prodigy has better reaction time.


It's just that is having trouble understanding. Not everything can be avoided by seeing it coming. You state that Prodigy will make sure he is in a position that he can avoid something like blanketing, seizing or the like, but he can't. It's a physical impossibility.
One, I said that he will be in a position where Justice can't use blanketing or seizing or the like. Two, Justice won't take this tactic immediately as it is more taxing and difficult. so Prodigy will have the chance to get away first.



Now, I'm really pretty much done with this debate. I've given all of the evidence needed for Justice to win this, and have shown that Prodigy really has little chance to win this (unless Justice suddenly became a moron). Great debate, but we're going around in circles so much, it hurts.
Prodigy has a great chance to win given the environment suits him better. and as far as Justice becoming a moron...well he did sign up with the SHRA despite the fact that they are mocking his old mates, but whatever. It was a good debate, thanks for the challenge. Prodigy can win.

WINNER=PRODIGY
 
FINAL COMMENTS: Justice vs Prodigy
So he'll be running into walls then? You make it sound like he has super-speed. The best he can do is go at a running speed. he doesn't have the reaction time necessary to maintain high speeds in a confined environment.
Running speed? Are you kidding me? It's not a confined environment.

Which means that Prodigy knows exactly how good Justice is and exactly how to lie to him.
It's his power. It's basically a lie detector. You can't work around it. That's not Justice sensing if you're lying. That's his powers doing so. I doubt Justice himself knows exactly how that works, but it works.

Good idea, he should wear himself out before he gets to Prodigy. Using telekinetics exerts energy. He isnt' the Phoenix, using his powers drains him, if slowly, it drains him. So for that little idea to work, he would need a constant forcefield. Or he would need to erect an instantaneous forcefield when he detected that he'd tripped automatic systems, which would not block the gas... or it might.
There was a time that stuff like that really exerted Justice's power levels. Now he can do it for a long long time. You're seriously underestimating Justice here. He's one of the most powerful telekinetics around. He doesn't tire so easily.

But you chose not to display pictures of that.
Funny, look up picture 4 there. That's just before they meet the Sentry.

Why can't I use this argument? Unless you are going to argue that he built the whole thing post-M-Day, I can argue that he was building it well before he M-Day.
Doesn't matter. It was shown after M-Day. No use of comics after HoM for Prodigy. That's the rules, boyo. I didn't make them.

That was it folks, good night.

WINNER=JUSTICE
 
Nick Fury vs Empath - Rebuttal

I am not sure Shield will know too much given this is a Spanish mutant. But given his name I think Fury could figure out that he is dealing with someone who affects people's emotions.

SHIELD's mandate is international espionage, especially since they are/were under the United Nations. If the information is out there, especially on super powered individuals, then SHIELD, and by extension Fury, should know about him. But, if nothing else, Empath's name implies mental powers.

Regarding whether Fury is in charge of Shield at the time of the battle is something the bosses have to state. However, he was no longer in charge for a period that started just before the civil war books. He was hoever in charge just before Planet Hulk.

We'll need to get this cleared up. If he's in charge of SHIELD, no problem. If not, I would think that his safe houses would have comparable information and technological access.

In any case, I do not remember of any device that would protect Fury from Empath's powers. Fury cannot just invent it for this match.

Empath's powers would allow him to sense Fury from anywhere in the Raft and he could wipe out Fury's mind very quickly. If you wish to base your whole startegy on a deus ex machina sort of device then it should be described and referenced here. Fury is not Batman.

But characters like Fury are all about the deus ex machina. That's how they survive, and how they do their jobs so well. He may not be Batman, but he's pretty close to being Marvel's version of him (where prep-time is concerned).

As for blocking telepathy with technology. It can be done. The following pic shows Iron Man doing it on the fly (you can read Tony saying how he's doing it in the bottom cells).

http://i10.tinypic.com/43xaii9.jpg

(The page with the pic is here, just search for the word telepathic: http://www.statueforum.com/showthread.php?t=41355&page=2)

If Tony can do it, SHIELD can do it. SHIELD even had it's own Psi-Division of telepaths. With telepaths in the organization, they wouldn't pass up the opportunity to study their powers and work on ways of bringing telepaths down.

And on the MarvelDatabase page about SHIELD, it states:
Equipment: Various including: Beta-cloth, kevlar body armor, jetpacks, teleporter, psi-blocker, Hover Discs.

So SHIELD does have psi-blocking technologies.


On a side note, if Fury did get such a device, lets not forget that Empath is an active member of a team that fights in the field and as such has fighting skills which would be at least on par with someone used to controlling things from HQ.

Good point. If it comes down to a physical fight, then Empath can't be counted out. But Fury wouldn't go into the fight empty handed. He's not above killing (or seriously crippling) and would bring guns or other weapons with him into a fight.

But I don't think a physical fight is guaranteed. Fury will have access to the Raft's schematics. From a control room he can turn the prison against Empath. Or just flood the place with a gas to knock Empath out.


Nick Fury wins
 
Clea vs Valkyrie

I don't think prep-time will help either character, although her powers may give Clea the ability to learn things about Valkyrie.


Valkyrie is no slouch. Far from it. She's an incredible fighter with tons of experience. Her spear is magical and her sword is unbreakable.

But Clea is no slouch either. She was trained by Dr. Strange himself, and she is now the Sorceress Supreme of the Dark Dimension. Not only does this mean that she an accomplished and skilled magic user, but she is very powerful.


As good as Valkyrie, Clea is going to over power her. She can blind her with illumination spells, or smash her with bolts of energy (these tend to be her specialty. Or she can lure Valkyrie into a cell, teleport out, and slam/seal the door on her. And because the cell is lined with adamantium (which Clea doesn't have to know about), Valkyrie is trapped.

Or Clea can use a host of other spells like teleporting Valkyrie away so she doesn't have to harm her (causing Valkyrie to lose by being removed from the battlefield). put her to sleep, freeze her in place (not with cold, just paralyze her), or use any other of a number of spells powerful magic users have access to.

Valkyrie is good, but she got a bad draw this round.

Clea wins
 
Just lost my whole response to this debate :( :cmad:

So I am just putting my summary because I can not be bothered to write the whole thing again.

SHIELD's mandate is international espionage, especially since they are/were under the United Nations. If the information is out there, especially on super powered individuals, then SHIELD, and by extension Fury, should know about him. But, if nothing else, Empath's name implies mental powers.

Information from his name he will get, other information is possible but not certain.


But characters like Fury are all about the deus ex machina. That's how they survive, and how they do their jobs so well. He may not be Batman, but he's pretty close to being Marvel's version of him (where prep-time is concerned).

As for blocking telepathy with technology. It can be done. The following pic shows Iron Man doing it on the fly (you can read Tony saying how he's doing it in the bottom cells).

http://i10.tinypic.com/43xaii9.jpg

(The page with the pic is here, just search for the word telepathic: http://www.statueforum.com/showthread.php?t=41355&page=2)

If Tony can do it, SHIELD can do it. SHIELD even had it's own Psi-Division of telepaths. With telepaths in the organization, they wouldn't pass up the opportunity to study their powers and work on ways of bringing telepaths down.

And on the MarvelDatabase page about SHIELD, it states:
Equipment: Various including: Beta-cloth, kevlar body armor, jetpacks, teleporter, psi-blocker, Hover Discs.

So SHIELD does have psi-blocking technologies.

Fury is not an inventor. He is a manager. He is best at controlling others.

Here he is on his own and would have to find devices that had already been made. However, there are a couple problems with the devices:

1. We do not know how effective they are because if Shield operatives were as effective as the equipment would suggest they would not need Super Heros to bail them out every time.

2. A brain is a big place. And the neural connections that control emotions are not the same that collect information. A psi-blocker may be effective against telepathic communications, or mental blasts and yet be completely ineffective against something affecting your emotions. Lets not forget if you have something which is defacto making you feel good (such as an overriding emotion of love) you are not going to fight it.


Good point. If it comes down to a physical fight, then Empath can't be counted out. But Fury wouldn't go into the fight empty handed. He's not above killing (or seriously crippling) and would bring guns or other weapons with him into a fight.

But I don't think a physical fight is guaranteed. Fury will have access to the Raft's schematics. From a control room he can turn the prison against Empath. Or just flood the place with a gas to knock Empath out.

First of all, if Fury could block all of Empath's powers (which is a very big if) and empath thought he could, then he would come equipped as well. As a field operative, Empath is trainned to fight and defend himself against armed individuals.

Second, Empath would have plans of the Raft as well and would not be easily tricked. He does have superiour intelligence after all.


Empath wins
 
Clea vs Valkyrie

I don't think prep-time will help either character, although her powers may give Clea the ability to learn things about Valkyrie.


Valkyrie is no slouch. Far from it. She's an incredible fighter with tons of experience. Her spear is magical and her sword is unbreakable.

But Clea is no slouch either. She was trained by Dr. Strange himself, and she is now the Sorceress Supreme of the Dark Dimension. Not only does this mean that she an accomplished and skilled magic user, but she is very powerful.


As good as Valkyrie, Clea is going to over power her. She can blind her with illumination spells, or smash her with bolts of energy (these tend to be her specialty. Or she can lure Valkyrie into a cell, teleport out, and slam/seal the door on her. And because the cell is lined with adamantium (which Clea doesn't have to know about), Valkyrie is trapped.

Or Clea can use a host of other spells like teleporting Valkyrie away so she doesn't have to harm her (causing Valkyrie to lose by being removed from the battlefield). put her to sleep, freeze her in place (not with cold, just paralyze her), or use any other of a number of spells powerful magic users have access to.

Valkyrie is good, but she got a bad draw this round.

This is a very cut and dry battle, so I see no point in doing a long protracted debate.

I will just mention that Valkyrie is an experienced warrior who has fought against Gods using magic (Loki) and alongside others who did (Strange and on a rare occassion Clea).

Her sword and spear will cut through anything and she is an expert in using them. She also knows Clea very well and would use the extent of her abilities here.

One ability I did not mention and am not sure she can use would be her ability to appear invisible to all when she is collecting spirits (which was her primary function). If she can use it, she will.

She will obviously try to avoid Clea's spells and will attempt to take her out as quickly and quietly as she can.

Valkyrie wins
 
This is a very cut and dry battle, so I see no point in doing a long protracted debate.

Agreed.

I will just mention that Valkyrie is an experienced warrior who has fought against Gods using magic (Loki) and alongside others who did (Strange and on a rare occassion Clea).

So they both have experience fighting together. But now Clea has more power and skill.

Her sword and spear will cut through anything and she is an expert in using them. She also knows Clea very well and would use the extent of her abilities here.

Many things that can 'cut through anything' have a problem with adamantium. And while Valkyrie is trapped somewhere cutting through the wall, Clea can continue casting spells to attack her from a safe place behind the wall.

One ability I did not mention and am not sure she can use would be her ability to appear invisible to all when she is collecting spirits (which was her primary function). If she can use it, she will.

That's a good ability. But it is also one Clea can duplicate. She could make herself invisible and hard to detect.

She will obviously try to avoid Clea's spells and will attempt to take her out as quickly and quietly as she can.

Avoiding spells is never easy, especially against a Sorceress Supreme. Clea could probably attack Valkyrie from anywhere within the base, safely out of the way of danger. Or Clea can decide to avoid hurting someone she's fought with and teleport Valkyrie away, maybe to the Dark Dimension.

Valkyrie is a great fighter, but she's outmatched in this fight.


Clea wins
 
So I am just putting my summary because I can not be bothered to write the whole thing again.

Information from his name he will get, other information is possible but not certain.

Fury is not an inventor. He is a manager. He is best at controlling others.

Here he is on his own and would have to find devices that had already been made. However, there are a couple problems with the devices:

1. We do not know how effective they are because if Shield operatives were as effective as the equipment would suggest they would not need Super Heros to bail them out every time.

2. A brain is a big place. And the neural connections that control emotions are not the same that collect information. A psi-blocker may be effective against telepathic communications, or mental blasts and yet be completely ineffective against something affecting your emotions. Lets not forget if you have something which is defacto making you feel good (such as an overriding emotion of love) you are not going to fight it.

First of all, if Fury could block all of Empath's powers (which is a very big if) and empath thought he could, then he would come equipped as well. As a field operative, Empath is trainned to fight and defend himself against armed individuals.

Second, Empath would have plans of the Raft as well and would not be easily tricked. He does have superiour intelligence after all.

I'll just summarize as well since we're down to a few key points.

Telepathy, including mind control, can be blocked. If any organization has this technology, it's SHIELD. And if anyone has access to SHIELD technology, it's Fury. And unlike other cases where a character has access to technology, but not the knowledge about it or ability to use it, Nick has neither problem. He can access databases looking for relevant tech, and on how to use it (as it is, he probably authorized the construction of such technology).

With Empath's telepathy out of the way, the battle is between to very experienced and well-trained agents. But in this area, Nick should have the advantage with years more experience and the willingness to do whatever it takes to win, including cheap shots, 'cheating', and killing his opponent if he needs to.

Nick Fury wins
 
Agreed.



So they both have experience fighting together. But now Clea has more power and skill.



Many things that can 'cut through anything' have a problem with adamantium. And while Valkyrie is trapped somewhere cutting through the wall, Clea can continue casting spells to attack her from a safe place behind the wall.



That's a good ability. But it is also one Clea can duplicate. She could make herself invisible and hard to detect.



Avoiding spells is never easy, especially against a Sorceress Supreme. Clea could probably attack Valkyrie from anywhere within the base, safely out of the way of danger. Or Clea can decide to avoid hurting someone she's fought with and teleport Valkyrie away, maybe to the Dark Dimension.

Valkyrie is a great fighter, but she's outmatched in this fight.

Just to be clear in a straight up physical battle Brunhilde takes this hands down. However, this battle will be a question of valkyrie avoiding Clea's spells and taking her unawares or from close enough not giving the time for Clea to do a spell (Valkyrie has superhuman sped). If she cannot do this she would lose. However, if she can, she wins and therin lies the voters choice.

Valkyrie does have eons of years of experience and has fought foes fom many dimensions.


valkyrie wins
 
I'll just summarize as well since we're down to a few key points.

Telepathy, including mind control, can be blocked. If any organization has this technology, it's SHIELD. And if anyone has access to SHIELD technology, it's Fury. And unlike other cases where a character has access to technology, but not the knowledge about it or ability to use it, Nick has neither problem. He can access databases looking for relevant tech, and on how to use it (as it is, he probably authorized the construction of such technology).

With Empath's telepathy out of the way, the battle is between to very experienced and well-trained agents. But in this area, Nick should have the advantage with years more experience and the willingness to do whatever it takes to win, including cheap shots, 'cheating', and killing his opponent if he needs to.

In a straight up physical battle, it is a coin toss. But the blocking of Empath's empathetic powrs is questionable as I have explained in a previous post. This is not staright forward telepathy and the brain is complicated enough to warrant a question as to the effectiveness of any device that was used against straight up telepathy.

It is for voters to decide.

Empath wins
 
Many battles I don't read until the day of voting. Remember, if JH or I need to make a decision about something, please PM us; so, we can give the information in time.

About Nick Fury's access to SHIELD; yes, he's still not associated with SHIELD. This happened with Bendis' Secret War, and would be the same in this contest. But, I will say, I believe I've seen Fury still having access to SHIELD files and various secret bases. I'm pretty positive with prep-time, he'd know of a secret base of operations to get information from...it's just very likely he wouldn't have total access to SHIELD information or many of it's weapons.
 
*Diablo - (Midnight might want Titania to advance; but, I see Diablo totally taking this match. If I had a choice between both characters, I'd take Diablo in a heartbeat.)

*Empath - (Hard, hard decision. I'm thinking Empath would take it...barely.)

*Justice - (Great debate, but Justice would take this easily.)

*Clea - (These magic users have a total advantage in prep-time. It's almost that we should just eliminate them next season.)
 
Diablo (Will probably do better in later rounds)
Nick Fury
Justice (almost went with Prodigy on the debate)
Clea
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,296
Messages
22,082,052
Members
45,881
Latest member
lucindaschatz
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"