blueserenity
Civilian
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2011
- Messages
- 483
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 11
I agree that DoFP isn't at all what I envisaged for the First Class franchise.
However, the set-up is there in as much as we have two time periods already - the 60s of First Class and the 90s/00s of the previous trilogy, so the notion of connecting them isn't a big leap.
Also, it will serve to reset the franchise and sort out continuity issues, giving First Class more freedom with who it introduces without us worrying about how it fits in with the other films.
In addition, bringing back some old faces will attract new attention to the franchise and give it a lift. Much as i don't really want to see Jackman pop up again, especially in an extended role, it does make sense from a marketing/promotion/visibility point of view.
It now all rests on how this idea is executed. It could all be a hot mess, especially considering how the Phoenix Saga was handled. That story never had its required breathing space and development at all. One long film might be fine for DoFP, although ideally a two-parter would be better.
This is the studio's chance to win back fans and win back viewers. If they blow it, that could be it.
I think it's too late to reset stuff or to try and cram in something to explain continuity errors. The easiest way to handle this is to just keep going with what XMFC started: doing whatever it needs to to tell a good story, old movies be damned. As CB and CBM fans it's hard for us to step back and see it but I think combining the two timelines would be a giant clusterfrig for most people. I actually think it would screw up the continuity even more. If XOW Emma is XMFC Emma and is that because of time travel, we have to go through the headache of assessing every character, X1-3 and XMFC, to determine whether they're a product of time travel (12 yo Scott in 1962, 30 yo Scott in 2000) or whether they were unaffected by the events. That's a lot of work for something that could just be rectified with Vaughn announcing that XMFC is absolutely its own thing (which it should be anyway).
Personally time travel and its repercussions give me a massive headache even when done well, because there are too many whatifs and possible fixits to even fathom. I also resent it because in using time travel, you're taking away repercussions. Raven dies? No problem, we'll just go back and prevent that from happening. Charles loses his legs via stray bullet? Gotcha covered, he's going to be walking till his old age! Bad guy wins? Not in this reality, bub! I know that's not quite how it works in DoFP but if they really are using this film as a way to explain away inconsistencies, one of the things they'd do would be to take away Charles' paralysis. Which ruins the severity of what happened, and whose fault it was, a move that will affect the characters for the rest of their lives and gives them way more depth than had Charles had his spine crushed by a rock-bearing alien.
Like I've said before, this is feeling more and more like a retcon film, which is a bad, bad idea. Hopefully the director has enough integrity to stick to what he presented in XMFC and not have it wiped away in order to match up neatly to the old trilogy. The old trilogy should have absolutely no bearings on XMFC2 at all. It was fun at the time, but now they've got to let go and move on to this fresher team and fresher take.


