Supergirl Earth-38 Version of Arrowverse Superheroes

[Spider-Fan83]

So would that mean on Earth-1 there is an Alexandra Luthor and a Leonardo Luthor? A Maxine Lord, Henrietta Henshaw, Charles Grant, Louis Lane, Penny White, Wendy Schott, Jasmine Olsen, Mike Sawyer, even an Alexander Danvers.

yes, I thought of that as a possibility too when I had the idea(even if
I suggested it half jokingly)... it'd be interesting

Charles...that's it... I was trying to think of names of everyone's doppelganger wasn't sure what the male equivalent Cat (Catherine) would be

 

[zenith16]

yes, I thought of that as a possibility too when I had the idea(even if
I suggested it half jokingly)... it'd be interesting

Charles...that's it... I was trying to think of names of everyone's doppelganger wasn't sure what the male equivalent Cat (Catherine) would be

lol no that's not the male equivalent Charles isn't Catherine. the male equivalent of Charlotte is or and charlie for Charlene


there'a henry and it's short for hank and female version of Henrietta is Hetty.

Hyde would be hydie

hmm come to think about it. I don't think I've ever heard the male equivalent of Catherine cat. there a cad and a castor cas for Cassidy

many ways for casey/ kasey for both sex's
cat

 

[Spider-Fan83]

^ perhaps we're over thinking it a bit...

maybe Catherine would just be shortened to Thorin (ironically meaning thunder) I guess that'd make him a Thunder Cat..ha.. so, he might go by Lion or Tiger in stead of Cat

Thorin Jone {Tiger} Grant, founder of TigerCo... and his catch phrase can be "they're Grrrant" lol

 

[zenith16]

^ perhaps we're over thinking it a bit...

maybe Catherine would just be shortened to Thorin (ironically meaning thunder) I guess that'd make him a Thunder Cat..ha.. so, he might go by Lion or Tiger in stead of Cat

Thorin Jone {Tiger} Grant, found of TigerCo

lol thunder Thunder thunder Cat's Hoooooooooooooooo . Don't worry I
ll look into it. I don't think any one has before

 

[zenith16]

maybe Catherine would just be shortened to Thorin (ironically meaning thunder) I guess that'd make him a Thunder Cat..ha.. so, he might go by Lion or Tiger in stead of Cat
l

ok so I looked and the best place to find it was on answer.com

the male equivalent to Catherine is Catalan

and the short version is still cat there's this black male actor called Cat Williams too hmm I re ask my sister his full name . but yeah that the male

equivalent for Catherine it's Catalan


yeah I know people will find it weird I went that far to find out but now i know some things I didn't .

I even re looked up Scott which is mostly male to most people. But the female equivalent is Scottie . and the boy version variant is Scotty with a Y at the end.

So that it for now.

 

[Spider-Fan83]

not to further take this thread off topic...

but, just for fun I started putting together a gender swap cast list
(started out trying to come up with somewhat realistic picks but, some/most are more just kinda funny)

Arrow{Olivia Queen}- Olivia Wilde

Speedy{Theodore Queen}- Charlie Mcdermott

Digs{Joan Diggle}-idk, maybe Serena Williams lol

(might as well throw in, Venus Williams as Ms Terrific lol)

and just to not seem bias... it works both ways
Canary{Caesar Lance}- Cam Gigandet

Flash{Barrette Allen} - Leven Rambin

Harriet Wells- Jane Lynch


Francisco Ramon - Natalie Morales

Bruce Snow - Michael Angarano

 

[zenith16]

lol yeah .

 

[Spider-Fan83]

the legends...

Atom - Gemma Arterton


Firestorm
professor Stein - Tamsin Greig/

/Jaxs-China Anne Mcclain


HeatWave-Gwendoline Christie


Steel-Maitland Ward

 

[Kelly]

I think right now National City is pretty packed with heroes....I don't mind the crossover here and there, but other than that, I'm happy with the way it is.

 

[zenith16]

I think right now National City is pretty packed with heroes....I don't mind the crossover here and there, but other than that, I'm happy with the way it is.

oh kelly this isn't any thing to worry about in that way. He's playing around with a theory of reverse sex or what called gender bender swaps characters of the earth one known ones from whwere barrys from and they aren't likely to be any where near national cit or ever visit the place, if they ever did show up they likely meet her out side that city, if they are of earth 38 . It's panicking over nothing and not to be taken too seriously




Cause it's not likely the writers of the show to do9 it and if they are really good in the first place if did happen to let the spot light be taken from kara. Seriously if they are good or great writers it won't happen no mater who they put in.

 

[Nick Morton]

None of Barry's friends exist on Supergirls Earth as said in the very first crossover

 

[Kelly]

oh kelly this isn't any thing to worry about in that way. He's playing around with a theory of reverse sex or what called gender bender swaps characters of the earth one known ones from whwere barrys from and they aren't likely to be any where near national cit or ever visit the place, if they ever did show up they likely meet her out side that city, if they are of earth 38 . It's panicking over nothing and not to be taken too seriously




Cause it's not likely the writers of the show to do9 it and if they are really good in the first place if did happen to let the spot light be taken from kara. Seriously if they are good or great writers it won't happen no mater who they put in.

Wow, you got all of that out of my post?

1. Obviously what they are writing in their posts is just fun make believe....
2. My post was simply to state my opinion on whether or not there would be Earth-38 versions of Arrowverse Superheroes which is the title of the thread. I wasn't actually quoting anyone from the few previous posts before mine.
3. AND I think it was me that has said several times her and other places that there would be no problem with Superman, etc taking spotlight from Kara because Melissa has charisma enough to keep that from happening.

My point was more of a "crowded" dilemma, not a spotlight dilemma.

 

[zenith16]

Wow, you got all of that out of my post?

1. Obviously what they are writing in their posts is just fun make believe....
2. My post was simply to state my opinion on whether or not there would be Earth-38 versions of Arrowverse Superheroes which is the title of the thread. I wasn't actually quoting anyone from the few previous posts before mine.
3. AND I think it was me that has said several times her and other places that there would be no problem with Superman, etc taking spotlight from Kara because Melissa has charisma enough to keep that from happening.

My point was more of a "crowded" dilemma, not a spotlight dilemma.

oh my apology's for misinterpreting it was wrong of me. but when you think about if we are going with they are alternate count parts and some being gender bender versions if we're going with what spider fan 83 thinks.

they don't all have to be at the same time. to make less crowded, they can be a one off character visit of meet up like the villain of the week instead these ones aren't villains coming hurt her and her friends and un like their counter part they are living an alternative life style. they don't have the same career as any of the one's they don't answer the same names as showcased with jay Garrick just having maiden name from Henry Allen's family three.

Jay Garrick of earth looks look like Henry Allen Barry's father(that's if he's not a distant relative and seeing they have the same genes?... But the writers seem refuse to go there and leave all vague ).

but doesn't answer that name Allen cause he wasn't born with it . or it could be like it was for the flash of small ville where almost all of the known flash's real names were just an alias for the former young con artist turned hero Bart Alan which small Ville Clark met and worked with in the small ville version of he justice league since .


ad most importantly un like the villain ofthe week they'll be ven less of chance to see them again other then once on kara's earth. that'smotly up to the writers there.

it's just about possibility & nothing more then that. they shouldn't out live their welcome and the show of flash made even more possible with jay Garrick which would explain why barry couldn't find them .

just simply have be one time deal thing if ever.

They simply a may not are just plainly aren't answering those names at all cause they may not have been born with them and may not, & are just plainly not living in the city's of star or central or kara's earth .

And it's possible they could be doing hero work incognito too like the small ville JSA did til they revealed them selves to Clark .


it hard not to think this way with what the show the flash presented just Jay guyrrick which there were alot of question to be asked from us fans . and left so many possibility.

That Barry doing what he did by looking for the very same names as he knows them on his earth is mistake on his part . were not doing it to argue it's that the writers set up parameters which set the stage to throw him off if he went that rout and he's made mistakes before .

Especially if they are like jay from earth 3.

 

[Ghost_Rider]

I think they should lay off the doppleganger concept for a while.

The chances of the same sperm fertilizing the same egg on a completely different earth, with a discernibly different history, is just beyond silly. I get these shows are inherently silly and cheesy, but they can only do this concept so long before it becomes a parody of itself.

It kind of already reached that point when they decided the search the multiverse for different Harrison Wells, all played by Cavanaugh. The scene was played up for 'laughs' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWsZanxxXgk

I could believe a 'Barry Allen' exists on Earth 2 and the other earths, but they shouldn't all look like Gustin.

 

[zenith16]

I think they should lay off the doppleganger concept for a while.

The chances of the same sperm fertilizing the same egg on a completely different earth, with a discernibly different history, is just beyond silly. I get these shows are inherently silly and cheesy, but they can only do this concept so long before it becomes a parody of itself.

It kind of already reached that point when they decided the search the multiverse for different Harrison Wells, all played by Cavanaugh. The scene was played up for 'laughs' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWsZanxxXgk

I could believe a 'Barry Allen' exists on Earth 2 and the other earths, but they shouldn't all look like Gustin.

well it's based onthe bubble univser theory there was this physicist Dr >>Michio Kaku<< that showed up on the discovery channel Canada very often. about his theory of the multi verse.


It's a real thing of sorts and he's not the only one that dabbled in this theory
since then all of sci= fi has taken to this theory of the multiverse or the extended verse the omni verse (<<marvel) and ran with it . it's been in star trek from time of Kirk in 1960s to the next Generation and most Gene Rodden barry shows and more

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_inflation


also
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiverse

 

[Ghost_Rider]

Star Trek TOS had the Mirror Universe, and that's about it.

TNG had the episode "Parallels" and it was received as one of the worst episodes of the series, due to it's silly concept of the multiverse and dopplegangers. Brannon Bragas been interviewed about it a lot.

 

[zenith16]

Star Trek TOS had the Mirror Universe, and that's about it.

TNG had the episode "Parallels" and it was received as one of the worst episodes of the series, due to it's silly concept of the multiverse and dopplegangers. Brannon Bragas been interviewed about it a lot.

star trek had other spin offs which did the same regardless.


Doctor who has done it few times now.

Yet there was gene Rodden barrys "earth final conflict" which did it . and went past 5 seasons

with aliens trying to take over earth. but instead of the over done hostile take by military force they used subversion and tried to do with being friend b\here was civil war among the alien them selves cause some were trully sincere and they doing this sharing their tech for normal every common day use things. they still ventured in to the multiverse.

and the gene Rodden barrys Andromeda ascendant which had it . it went past 5 seasons

Lol Sam Rami''s Hercules and Xena explored it too .


Babylon 5 which praised for it work for stayed to it script which was planned to run for 5 years straight had it . star gate SG1 did it and so did it spin off's and they aren't part of the Gene Rodden barry brand.


Two show of late 90's to early 2000's and mid 2000's had it one called Sliders staring Jerry O'Connell and his baby brother and there was show fringe wit josha jackson which fallowed after it. Both of which were devoted to the multiverse theory.


Don't get me started on the animated series that doing til this day, that do this in north america often . All of which each these things don't care about the awards or praise.


Every time some one comes back with a new version of the other limits tv series

 

[divan]

I could believe a 'Barry Allen' exists on Earth 2 and the other earths, but they shouldn't all look like Gustin.

I actually think this could be pretty fun in fact. Give another actor a chance to do his or her interpretation of this character. Compare and cotnrast.

And Kelly, I never meant they have to be incorporated into the cast of Supergirl or anything like that, I agree it's her show. I just felt they could work as "guest stars" from time to time. I said "Earth 38" versions for a couple of reasons - The first is taking "advantage" of the fact that Supergirl is her own thing, her own Earth and airing concurrently to the other shows (otherwise they could make them come from anywhere) and the second is that, unlike the "main" shows it seems to have a more classic, comic-book-like approach to its world and superheroes (Arrow, Flash and Legends seem more "CW version" if that makes sense).

 

[Kelly]

I actually think this could be pretty fun in fact. Give another actor a chance to do his or her interpretation of this character. Compare and cotnrast.

And Kelly, I never meant they have to be incorporated into the cast of Supergirl or anything like that, I agree it's her show. I just felt they could work as "guest stars" from time to time. I said "Earth 38" versions for a couple of reasons - The first is taking "advantage" of the fact that Supergirl is her own thing, her own Earth and airing concurrently to the other shows (otherwise they could make them come from anywhere) and the second is that, unlike the "main" shows it seems to have a more classic, comic-book-like approach to its world and superheroes (Arrow, Flash and Legends seem more "CW version" if that makes sense).

Fans are kinda weird with other actors playing the role of their fav, and when that fav happens to be played by a very popular choice for that popular show. We will see some of number (and most probably not even comicbook fans, rather fans of Glee ) are going to scream bloody hell and the actors will go on twitter and love all over each other's interpretation of the character, blah, blah, blah.....but that is not the reality of the comic fanboy and girl....it just isn't.

NOW, do that on shows that are on the same network? Hell, fans with TOTALLY DIFFERENT CHARACTERS, AND I MEAN TOTALLY like Supergirl and Jessica Jones went nuts once Jessica Jones aired. I love both series, but good lord some of the fans were rabid simply because it was two female heroes. The actresses did an excellent job of calming it down on twitter, I can say that....but fans are just strange. Just wait until Ms. Marvel comes out, we will see backlash there as well, the thing that will help is that both actresses are very respectful, both are very complimentary of each other, so I think that will go a long way to handle that situation, but there will be one. NOT FROM ME, I enjoy the work of both actresses and can't wait for the Ms. Marvel movie. NOW, a Supergirl movie without Melissa???????? I'll have to get back to ya on that one. hahahaha

As far as the last portion of your post, yeah I can agree with that....

And as far as "her show" I am not one that really worries about that, the writers have held true to that, and as I have stated before, IMO, even Superman did not take away anything from Melissa's portrayal of Supergirl. So to me, that isn't a worry at all.

One of the things that have kind of pushed me away from Arrow and LoT (LoT I was just never able to get in to) was the number of players in the game. First season of Arrow was great, second season I was still wanting to stick with it, but after that, just too many cooks in the kitchen. And though I can see the need for the help, so to speak, and have gotten back into Arrow this season because I'm looking at it in that way, I don't see the "need" for it on Supergirl.

I totally get that some fans want to see their favorite comic book character on TV so bringing them in is very cool to them, I get that....hell Superman was a slam dunk, goal, and TD rolled up into one, but IMO, it was something that "needed" to be done. They are family, we should at least see him a few times each season. Maggie Sawyer has been a really nice addition to the show, and so has Miss Martian....but neither is playing a HUGE ROLE at the moment, they are very nice complimentary characters to other characters on the show besides Supergirl. Mon-el is that complimentary character to Kara....so at the moment, I just don't see a need to bring in any others. I WOULD MUCH RATHER THEM, focus on great, solidly written villains. IMO, that is this season's weak point.

And please divan, don't get me wrong, your thoughts and suggestions are the same as many fans out there, they aren't WRONG.... hahahaha, I, myself, would much rather the showrunners, writers, etc....concentrate the money, and time on better villains rather than bringing in other heroes....that's all.

 

[Spider-Fan83]

as much as i was just playing around with that concept (never actually excepted or wanted something like that to happen pre-say)

but, its all kinda irrelevant as even if the doppelgangers do exist on her earth (or any other) the odd of them developing the same powers/ skill sets and/or taking up the same mantle as a hero, or teaming up or even knowing one another (other then the ones related, I guess) are pretty low

they would all be living very different life (we saw just in flashpoint, how a slight change to the timeline could completely alters the chain of evens that lead them to there current lives) so those exact same events happening on a different earth are not likely

I guess, given that it would be very different circumstances, I probably shouldn't have got with the current cast, or at least also included some of the original character as they could still be alive/around such as Laurel, Tommy, Roy, Ronnie... an the Legends were probably a redundancy as that exact team of characters would never be brought together under the same set of circumstances on any other earth

 

[zenith16]

as much as i was just playing around with that concept (never actually excepted or wanted something like that to happen pre-say)

but, its all kinda irrelevant as even if the doppelgangers do exist on her earth (or any other) the odd of them developing the same powers/ skill sets and/or taking up the same mantle as a hero, or teaming up or even knowing one another (other then the ones related, I guess) are pretty low

they would all be living very different life (we saw just in flashpoint, how a slight change to the timeline could completely alters the chain of evens that lead them to there current lives) so those exact same events happening on a different earth are not likely

I guess, given that it would be very different circumstances, I probably shouldn't have got with the current cast, or at least also included some of the original character as they could still be alive/around such as Laurel, Tommy, Roy, Ronnie... an the Legends were probably a redundancy as that exact team of characters would never be brought together under the same set of circumstances on any other earth

yep that why I kept saying that it's like they aren't answering the same names and aren't likely living in the same towns at all or even togethers we're likely to see them solo character if it were a thing at all .

they might not be together on teams at all . but it's also like they all aren't known to ether. but it's possibility too.

But they sure as likely aren't living in the same places and minght not have grown up the same way. and very likely the legends aren't even name in earth 38 and they aren't using that ship the wave rider at all. but a javelin instead

the whole point the multiverse and the omni verse thhich is the extend version is alot and anything and every thing can have happened . But it's in a million or more numerous versions . This was all just play full speculation and nothing more.

the writer of the show also should always be working on the villain to make them more entertaining for the show. this why never over think about as problem . super is still one of the newer shows. they still have time . to show case this .