I voted it above average...I do have some things about the film that really annoy me...but I also really enjoyed it. so, i'm kinda half and half...I thought it was a great comic film...but it bothered me that they strayed far from the comic.
Things that bothered me:
1) Doom without a mask...he should have stayed in costume the entire film.
2) The Thing and Mr. Fantastic didn't really have any fight scenes...no reason to really use their powers besides a dance scene (which was funny actually

3) Galactus is a cloud..........and no he won't be in the 3rd. It'll probably be Molemen...so yes..Galactus was just a cloud.
4) If the Silver Surfer could destroy Galactus anytime he wanted to...why did he wait until he willingly let Galactus destroy countless other worlds?
that's about it...but like I said...despite those annoyances...I actually really liked it. And yes...I really liked the first film too...I found this one to be better in a lot of ways.