Independence Day 2?

Status
Not open for further replies.
They recast Mae Whitman's role when she's still in the game and was just the lead of a semi-successful movie?

Yeah, I'm gonna hard pass.
Yeah, it's odd.

Oh well, I think ID42 is going to blow anyway so who cares?
 

tumblr_mn664ntu5X1qa4qkqo1_250.gif
 
Is she really funny or something?
 
Gurl, don't even

tumblr_mqn2t2X4h71qzgecuo2_500.png
 
Yeah this is weird, especially since they seem to be bringing back everyone else not named Will Smith (including Brent Spiner, who DIED in the first one). Mae's still acting, she does live-action acting as well as voice acting, and she's freaking Katara from ATLA. So this recast makes little sense to me, and by the sounds of it, she wasn't even CONSIDERED for the role.

God I hope that it's not a case of some Hollywood guy thinking that she's not "conventionally attractive" enough, because that'd just be sad and pathetic.
 
It would have made sense if Mae wasn't acting anymore, but she's still acting. That casting made zero sense.

I understand why they recast Vivica's son.
 
Last edited:
Mae Whitman played her bit-part in ID4 almost 20 years ago. Recasting a role after that much time has passed isn't exactly unheard of regardless of the actor or actresses age. For all we know Mae didn't want to be involved in this film. I'm certainly not going to boycott the film because of this. Frankly I just don't care about Mae's career prospects. If her agent wasn't able to campaign her for the role or she didn't care enough to fight for it that's on them.

Beside Maika is pretty and a good actress so it's a win in my book.
 
I would have never known Whitman was in ID4 if you guys weren't discussing it.
 
It's Hollywood. They wouldn't cast Mae Whitman as Liam Hemsworth's leading lady unless it's a "She's All That" type of movie. It's sad but true.
 
Yeah, it's odd.

Oh well, I think ID42 is going to blow anyway so who cares?

This. Don't see it cause you think it's going to suck not that they recast the President's 6 year old daughter... who cares? She was a tiny role.
 
Again, does Mae Whitman need ID4 2? I mean, it's ID4.

Did she want to be in it in the first place? Yeah who cares.
 
God I hope that it's not a case of some Hollywood guy thinking that she's not "conventionally attractive" enough, because that'd just be sad and pathetic.

Im pretty sure that's EXACTLY what happened.
 
Mae's a duff. That's why Hollywood use her.
 
Yeah, I like Mae Whitman but were not talking about an A-lister here (a la a Jen Lawrence or an Emma Stone) who could write their own ticket, were talking about a working actress, who would kill to play the female lead in a huge summer blockbuster. Aside from the payday, it would have tremendously helped her career.
 
Because as we know from reading message boards ID4 was a massively unsuccessful film that everyone hated. :whatever:

Wrong.

No I didn't say it wasn't not a successful movie. Most likely this role is just the typical 'girlfriend role'. With Makia, she just started but even then, this is not a Katniss type role. Not that I know of. It'll befit the guy who's playing Will Smith's son though.

For Mae, she doesn't really need it. I'd say she should go down the Amy Schumer route, and do her own thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
202,291
Messages
22,081,157
Members
45,881
Latest member
lucindaschatz
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"