GOTHAM 1990 -
Sgt O'Hara finds the scene. A warehouse, the family fell foul of the mob, all dead. O'Hara walks sadly into the empty space. He is about to call it in when he sees a boy, trauma in his eyes, sitting on the high ledge above.
O HARA -Its John isn't it. I know you must be scared John. Come down here and I'll look after you.
John has a knife in his hand. He already has small hesitant cuts in the shape of a smile on his face. He raises it to finish the job.
O HARA - I know your feeling crazy right now. But I'll look after you. This is one of those moments where you have a choice to change the world. Either cut your smile with that razor, and grow up to be crazy forever, or come with me and I will adopt you. Direct that rage for good.
GOTHAM 2O YEARS LATER
BLAKE VOICEOVER -So I went with him. He put me in the seat of his car that night and took me on his beat in Gotham's broadway. And that was when the second greatest thing of our night happened.
(Scene of O'Hara cuffing Joe Chill).
He stopped the Wayne family's mugger and saved their lives. Forever after, the family were so grateful that they put loads of money and resources into the GCPD. Between the Waynes and my Dad the chief, Gotham became a place of peace and safety.
(Camera shows a clean gleaming Gotham, with a Wayne Foundation symbol shining from the roof of Police HQ).
BLAKE - And me? I grew up to be a cop too, just like my Dad was when he met me. I always was angry at hypocrisy and the way people hide their true natures, but my Dad raised me to direct that urge in good ways.
(Blake walking down the alley in proudly in uniform.)
BLAKE - Sometimes I have weird dreams though. Like it could have gone another way. I imagine myself showing Gotham what is really is, in crazy terrible ways.
(Blake shines flashlight in Dark Building, and sees Wormhole)
"what the hell...I knew the mad scientist was seen here but..."
(He falls in)
(Cut to Blake looking around confused in Batman Gotham)
"what...I created this nightmare!"
BLAKE - In this reality, I let my craziness and my urge to bring out Gotham's dark nature take me over. I cut my smile and jumped out the window - my Dad spent all night running round trying to find me, he never got to his beat and didn't save the Waynes. Without them Gotham fell into poverty and hopelessness. Their boy became Gotham's dark avenger and me..his craziest Enemy.
But now I got a chance to put things right.
2012