This was a post i put up on the CBR Boards regarding the recent ALonso in CHarge interview with LOEB /ALONSO
(
http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=43393 )
and I wanted to share it here:
I really wanted to chime in on this NOVA situation..I just have a lot of thoughts on what I've read here and in the article.
First,
-LOEB is being flat out dishonest
DnA were not wrapping up NOVA. The book was still in the 25k range and we had several unfinished plot points (Garthaan Saal/Tarcel/ Namorita)
The book was never announced as canceled, and instead was put on hiatus..no doubt contingent on sales of Thanos Imperitve.
It's easy to see the "rock stars" had designs on the property and basically ambushed it by mandate..let's be real.
- These guys have no clue what they are doing
NOVA was rebooted to this Peter Parker Archetype several times, with no success. In fact this archetype is actual a punchline for bad contemporary character creation. The fact I am seeing High school Nova complete with a bully and skateboard in hand makes my stomach roll...especially with the vision of what LOEB has cranked out in the last few years. His stuff has been "cataclysmically" bad..not just bad. (The Ultimate U has still not recovered)
Rider was in a GREAT place following Annihilation I...he was a character who I had the privilege of following and seeing grow. He was a peter parker, but he grew into a complex young man who went through some horrifying and hardening life experiences in the form of combat and war...he found identifying with life back on earth tough and had a new perspective on the cost of freedom.The result was a man of dignity who became a leader and special hero with fantastic powers and sense of duty.
He was an awesome microcosm for the plight of what many young men are going through right now coming back from Iraq and Afganistan.
I think there are a lot of readers these days who can identify with that..and basically that was the tip of the iceberg on what we wanted or thought was "to come".
-Let's dive deeper into how little and how much Marvel screwed up RIchard Rider...
The very obvious thing that people are touching on is that Rider was never Promo'd like this, never got a legit shot on the Avengers (the Brubaker stint was an insult) or in mainline crossovers. I totally agree with that...but it goes further.
After Annihilation I..marvel basically became obsessed with creating new properties in the cosmic world instead of shoring up what they had...and in this, basically watered down all the momentum they built.
-Letting Giffen sign an exclusive to DC showed the priority Marvel had. Bad move. (more on Giffen later)
-In Annihilation Conquest , Nova was an afterthought..and the series focused on propping up Phyla and garbage like that Wraith character.
-This was basically the same for other marvel cosmic events up until Imperative. (which IMO was DnAs masterpiece)
-After Annihilation I...NOVA should have been a factor in major Marvel Universe event books and A list titles like the Avengers. (let alone a cartoon character and splash adds on IGN for his ongoing..which of course he never got).
Despite all this, both NOVA and GOTG actually came out with solid sales..and this could have been built upon but as the characters lost relevance (even witin the cosmic verse) readers lost interest.
I will fully admit that NOVA lost some steam in the end and needed a boost...but in the usual ways..not in anything dramatic. And for the life of me I don't see how the hiatus helped anything.
I do tend to think DnA are not regarded highly by the Marvel "Powers that be"...basically i assume they attribute the creative initial success to Giffen now in hindsight..and I personally thought Giffen nailed Nova a bit better, but I can't say this with all resolve...as no one really knows how DnA's hands were tied with what could be done and what they were mandated to do.
I still think letting GIFFEN bounce was a huge mistake.
SO ultimately it really makes me mad that guys like Alonso state that hardcore Nova fans are "small" in size, becuase it's mainly there fault this is so.
..and even still a good series launch starts , at its core, with a solid base of fans "to count on"...you play UP to these people (me).... not crap on them.
In alot of ways, as a hardcore Nova fan i would be OK with some legacy stuff if done right. Despite all the above, I'm still tossing in my head if I'm going to support this book.
Marvel (comics) is so darn directionless these days. They also hold supreme grudges against there own properties and characters (see New Warriors)..part of me feel if this book fails we will never see another shot at NOVA in a long time...and maybe... just maybe It could pave the way for a Rider return within the book (ala Hal Jordan) and have a interesting new role.
So i think I will check out issue #1..but I'm doing so with the utmost reservations....but then again i remember it's LOEB here and my skin crawls.