• Xenforo is upgrading us to version 2.3.7 on Thursday Aug 14, 2025 at 01:00 AM BST. This upgrade includes several security fixes among other improvements. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here

The Dark Knight Nicholson on Ledger playing the Joker

Heath Ledger is a better actor than Jack Nicholson.

Not by a long shot.

Ledger has so much to demonstrate first. I understand that a character and a movie that you have merely seen inside of your head might look very good, but results in films, acting and in everything else are concrete, not a voice and some pictures.
 
Not by a long shot.

Ledger has so much to demonstrate first. I understand that a character and a movie that you have merely seen inside of your head might look very good, but results in films, acting and in everything else are concrete, not a voice and some pictures.

*touche.
 
how can you say he becomes completely different characters when you've only seen one of his films? What else did you see him in? 10 Things I hate About You?

I really hope Ledger knocks the role out of the park. I think he is a gifted actor, but I really believe many people here are complimenting Ledger on what they want him to do with the character as opposed to what he is going to do. We literally have NO idea how he is approaching the Joker outside of a few quotes, two sound bites and a handful of random pictures. We know he is serious in his approach, thats it.

I think people get confused with the celebrity of Nicholson and his performances. Jake Gites from Chinatown is no way similar to Melvin in As Good as It Gets. He is one of the greatest performers of our time and just because you get your pants in a knot in your excitement for how great you hope The Dark Knight will be doesn't give you a free pass to dismiss an actor who invests more in a role than nearly anyone else including Ledger.

Thank you! someone talking sense and acting with thier head and not their heart Nicholson is an all time great he is recognised up with all the greats in cinema dinero,pachino,hopkins, alec guinness, dustin hoffman etc. i dont think any younger actor today will ever be so celebrated Ledger is a good actor but today the amount of good/great actors is better then ever IMO is Ledger really that good or better compared to Denzel washington,russel crowe, gary oldman, sean penn, edward norton, matt damon, johnny depp, etc? I really dont think so his body of work is frankly poor he is 28/29 but in todays cinema most actors have an impressive resume by that age brokeback, candy and lords of dogtown are the same roles mentioned over and over but they are just okay performances and dogtown was crap completely overacted imo if ledger approaches his joker this way we are sunk imo dont get me wrong i do think ledger will be good even great but to think this is a given is really stupid ledger will never approach jacks greatness he is just a plain better actor and came from a time when cineman entered the modern age of acting actors as celebrated will never come along again IMO.
 
I'm not going to put down Nicholson's performance as the Joker, but Burton and Nolan have two very different interpretations of Batman. Not only that, it would feel really weird to have the old Joker coming back in a new Batman Franchise with a different actor for Batman.
 
Wow wow wow, you guys are getting into some heated discussion.
 
I'm not going to put down Nicholson's performance as the Joker, but Burton and Nolan have two very different interpretations of Batman. Not only that, it would feel really weird to have the old Joker coming back in a new Batman Franchise with a different actor for Batman.

Of course Nolans take is a more serious affair and im looking foward to it i just dont like people bashing as great an actor as jack because he didnt say exactly what they want if bale tomorrow said he doesnt really like batman and he is only doing it for exposure and a big check it would be interesting to hear the responce.:woot:
 
If he's gonna get flamed out the wazoo for saying that, let's see what people think of this:

Heath Ledger is a better actor than Jack Nicholson.

There. I said it. That's my honest belief, and I think that when both of their careers are over, history were shine in Ledger's favor. Sure, comparing the two in such a way may seem like heresy now, since Jack is so old and respected, and we've only seen a very small portion of Ledger's serious acting, but let's look at it critically:

Everything Jack does is distinctly Jack. He does well with his roles, but every role he does is basically a variation on himself. He is incapable of seperating himself from the character. When you see Nicholson perform, you basically know what you're getting.

Ledger? Ledger becomes the character. His performance in Brokeback Mountain was utterly convincing (and heartbreaking), and there was nothing about his performance (short of the fact that you could look at his face and know it was him) to suggest that it was Heath Ledger. In that movie, he is the character. From the looks of it, it'll be the same way with I'm Not There and The Dark Knight. All three of those performances will be totally distinct; completely different characters, different people. And he's still young. He's only 28. It's only going to get better from here.

That's right. He's only 28, which means he has a ways to go before ever being compared to Nicholson.
 
I'm not going to put down Nicholson's performance as the Joker, but Burton and Nolan have two very different interpretations of Batman. Not only that, it would feel really weird to have the old Joker coming back in a new Batman Franchise with a different actor for Batman.

a voice of reason!
 
i don't know why people are comparing ledger and Nicholson career-wise now.

Jack Nicholson plays himself as of late, but he's been in so many classics. He's a legend. Heath is a different type of actor, going in a different direction. The only crossroads is The Joker.
 
i don't know why people are comparing ledger and Nicholson career-wise now.

Jack Nicholson plays himself as of late, but he's been in so many classics. He's a legend. Heath is a different type of actor, going in a different direction. The only crossroads is The Joker.

QFT
 
I had to do research for 'QFT' aka 'quote for truth'. I don't know what that meant!

haha.
 
ya i pretended tok now what qft meant a long time ago.. sigh good times
 
i don't know why people are comparing ledger and Nicholson career-wise now.

Jack Nicholson plays himself as of late, but he's been in so many classics. He's a legend.

Wonder how many of these kiddos have seen Chinatown? Which in my opinion is Jack's best role, the one time he's not "CRAZY JACK!"

As for Heath, I'm still liking what I'm seeing from Ledger so far, I'm at the point now where I think he's going to do one of two things: be a total flop as a result of over acting or get an Oscar nod for his performance.
 
Ya chinatown is by far one of my favorite roles of his. I love it when Roman Polanski calls him Kitty cat.
 
Heh, amusing to see Nicholson so pissed at him not being the Joker in TDK.

Of course, he would have never been a consideration because this is a new film series and one of it's aims is to do Batman differently from what has come before. Plus he is way too old, plus it would confuse the hell out of everyone and make all but hardcore Batman fans think that ALL Batman films are just one massive series like James Bond instead of two seperate franchises.

The reasons are endless. In light of this, it is pretty weird that Nicholson is pissed, really.

I do think it's a shame he never got to play Joker again, but if it was going to happen it should have been in B&R since the planned Batman5 got canned.
 
Talking in an accent different than your own doesn't mean you have any more range or talent than anyone else. I could talk in a different accent and make it believeable.
 
Talking in an accent different than your own doesn't mean you have any more range or talent than anyone else. I could talk in a different accent and make it believeable.

I agree. If one can't convincingly do an accent, then one shouldn't even be acting.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,960
Messages
22,042,931
Members
45,842
Latest member
JoeSoap
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"