so I finally watched Pacific Rim last night. It was good, it was ok, and I enjoyed it. It certainly wasn't terrible.
I just feel it really caters towards a narrow audience. that being anime fans and giant monster/robot geeks. If you don't like any of those, I'm not sure how well you'd enjoy it. and perhaps that's why the critics were so harsh on it.
it really did feel like a live action anime with over the top action and over the top characters.
ironically, I feel the weakest points were the monsters themselves. they just looked too goofy, fake, and "rubbery" to feel threatening or scary at all.
I enjoyed the jaegers and the pilots much more, and I wish the film could have spent more time exploring the dynamics among the pilots and their connection with their mechs.
The overall premise of the movie was interesting, but the execution was lacking a bit.