DarthSkywalker
🦉Your Most Aggro Pal (he/him)
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2004
- Messages
- 133,403
- Reaction score
- 81,285
- Points
- 203
And Mirror, Mirror doesn't resemble anything else before it? It doesn't look like a balloon parody of Alice in Wonderland : Snow White Edition?
This "genuine" attempt you speak of maybe only works in a sense that it's a live-action adaptation of the story. But then again, Mirror, Mirror is supposed to be............a comedy. Perhaps The Princess Diaries with 10X the budget and special effects, I suppose, is what ppl want.
Whereas with Huntsman, we have a adaptation of an originally dark story being made into a dark film. I'm not quite sure what films you're thinking of when you blame it for 'ripping off" but this fits more with what I want to see than what we've always seen with Snow White.
Maybe ppl don't take the story of Snow White seriously enough to think it can have any merit or worth being anything other than a light fantasy. Ugh.
Alice in Wonderland?

What is wrong with comedy and "light fantasy"? Some of the best and most poignant films belong to those two categories.
This Huntsman movies doesn't look dark in the least bit imo. Finding an gray filter and and having your actors make "serious" faces on the screen doesn't make something dark. The film looks typical. A combination of pretty much everything that has come after Gladiator/LOTR ( see King Arthur and Robin Hood), the fascination of "reinventing" things by making them "dark and gritty" (When most haven't a clue what those word mean), and yes, Twilight.
There are plenty of different kinds of "dark" films, but this doesn't fit any from the look of it. Dark is Drive. Dark is the final 20 minutes of OoTP. Dark is No Country for Old Men. Dark is Hanna. Dark is Game of Thrones. This doesn't look dark, this looks typical.
BTW, I don't want to sound like I'm completely against the other film. Mirror, Mirror is actually a fantastic title for it, and one I wouldn't have thought of myself. And I like the actress playing Snow White. But other than that, I want to see Snow White get down and dirty for once (that sounds filthy, I know). And seeing as she doesn't want to be the typical damsel in distress anymore, I like that newer ballsy approach to the fairytale.
It's the very irony of her character; a young beautiful girl who's supposed to be sweet and lovely and fragile, like snow, has no choice but to learn (from the man sent to kill her, ironically) how to toughen up and fight. Kill. Survive.
Why, so she can be just like all the other young beautiful girls who have kicked butt since Buffy? Do you not see the irony of making that Snow White movie now?
That story hasn't been ironic in over a decade. It is the most obvious approach you can take. Oh, the fragile pretty little girl isn't so fragile after all? No way!
You have just turned Snow White into this past decades Buffy, Beatrix Kiddo, Jen Yu, Guinevere, Hanna, Aeon Flux, Lara Croft, Maid Marian, Elizabeth Swan, Hit Girl, so on and so forth.
Last edited:




t: