danoyse
Snikt. Stab. Repeat.
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Messages
- 27,117
- Reaction score
- 4
- Points
- 33
I'll never understand why some people wanted Freddy or Jason in this movie, it's such a dumb idea. The whole thing with Pennywise is that he's scary because he's a real life monster. It works in the book because the kids are comparing their encounters with It to the old movie monsters, where you could tell it looked fake. This doesn't work with Freddy because you can't really make him look scarier. Plus, it would completely take me out of the movie if he or any other 80's movie monster were to make an appearance. This is Pennywise's movie, he doesn't need help from other, more well known, movie monsters.
Yeah, I kinda agree. As good as IT appearing as Freddy Krueger sounds on paper, I can't really see it working in the actual film. Without the greater context that the book has the benefit of, I think it would have come off more as a hokey shoutout and, like you say, would have achieved nothing more than taking the viewer out of the film.
I love NOES, but I'm personally glad they didn't go forward with that idea.
Yes, it worked well on paper in the It novel, but that book is also 1100 pages. You spend months with these kids and their day-to-day lives that even when yo cut the book into two movies, you don't have time to explore. You don't see them going to see I Was a Teenage Werewolf (or NOES5 in the movie's case) or experiencing the threat of "the clown" at different points and seasons, based on what movies they've just watched.
For af film, you have to streamline to two hours and need to make who Pennywise is clear and immediate. They succeeded at doing just that.
Agreed. And I say this as a child of the 80s who was fled to the movie theater arcade to play video games for at least 20 minutes during NOES3.
First of all, I think it would have taken everyone out of the movie. It wouldn't be about Pennywise, but the Freddy cameo.
I think Pennywise's forms needed to be something that will psychologically frighten the kids. It had to exploit a fear that was already there, and the fear it exploited had to be bigger than a movie monster that kids grow out of being scared of.
There was also a prank they were playing on people where a kid dressed in a yellow slicker was asking random adults if they'd grab his paper boat from the sewer, and of course someone dressed as Pennywise jumped out and chased them. I tell you, that's a good way to get your ass kicked.