• Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

Storm Vs Thor

Thor V Storm

  • Thor

  • Storm


Results are only viewable after voting.
Answering a question with a question:
How does Storm "See" weather?

Answer:
As Patterns of Energy. She manipulates stuff MENTALLY,... "SEE"S the weather mentally I can show page after page of her pinpoint accuracy of a weather effect w/o her looking directly at it.
.
The hate is getting too deep here where folk who have read her for decades have to step in to defend her because some of you nancies want to quantify her below canon to win your arguement.

V.:dry:

Yes, Storm can "see" the weather as you described, however that doesn't expalin or justify how she would have the cognitive ability, reaction time and reflexes to dodge something traveling at the speed of light. She has the limitations of highly skilled humans, nothing more.

All of this aside, Thor's control of the weather is based on magic, as is some of the "lightning" he strikes with.

Do YOU believe Storm could take Thor?
 
Yes, Storm can "see" the weather as you described, however that doesn't expalin or justify how she would have the cognitive ability, reaction time and reflexes to dodge something traveling at the speed of light. She has the limitations of highly skilled humans, nothing more.

All of this aside, Thor's control of the weather is based on magic, as is some of the "lightning" he strikes with.

Do YOU believe Storm could take Thor?

Only to the movies, but only if she were paying......and naked.
 
Yes, Storm can "see" the weather as you described, however that doesn't expalin or justify how she would have the cognitive ability, reaction time and reflexes to dodge something traveling at the speed of light. She has the limitations of highly skilled humans, nothing more.

All of this aside, Thor's control of the weather is based on magic, as is some of the "lightning" he strikes with.

Do YOU believe Storm could take Thor?

Let me get this straight:

Character has been around SINCE the 80's Using her powers to fly faster than a human being could control such,(In space piloting one of the Acanti at HYPERLIGHT Speeds)... generate and fire lightning at speeds faster than her opponent to even see it coming ,.. Pages of her deflecting ENERGY in most forms being thrown at her up to and including the phoenix -

*Pause*
Yet we can't explain or Justify how her energy sensing / manipulation could be "fast enough to do something about incoming lightning?

BECAUSE U YAHOO'S Believe that that part of her mutation operates at the same speed you do algebra on a calculator?

(Chuckle)

With that kind of logic MOST of the Xmen can't use their powers,... Nightcrawler couldn't telport,... Iceman couldn't create an Ice Anything instantly, The telepaths and Telekinetics would be reduced to doing things as fast as mundanes do,.. negating their powers.

Nope - You can't reduce Storm to how fast YOU think she can do something - against what SHE ALREADY HAS SHOWN just to win an arguement.

On your question about the Versus?

Only One place where storm whups Thor.

Near the center of the Galaxy.

There the amount of power she has available to manipulate exceeds the amount of energy that Thor has available as the God of Thunder.

points:
1. It's Canon that Storm has Manipulated STARS,... (Not A Star,.. but Clusters.)
2. It's Canon that she has absorbed and discharged enough stellar energy from glacatic center to destroy a Starship.
3. Thor has NEVER been shown to manipulate Any energy effects off planet, nor does he absorb or redirect energy outside of the stuff with the Hammer.
4. Thor has Limits that are inherent in him as far as energy manipulation. Storms limits are not in manip but in CONTROL.

This means:
That on EARTH or anywhere else short of Galactic Center where Ororo doesn't have access to more ENERGY than Thor trucks around with naturally,... Thor wins.

Galactic Center - She Beats his Azz.

Period.

No real dispute on this unless you want to ignore (counting on Fingers) 25+ years of X-men History.


V.
 
Or if she had the ultimate nullifer, or the infinity guantlet or galactus as a pet or if she had prep time.... Aren't we trying a little hard to show ways she might beat Thor? Is it possible for her to win? Sure. Would she win? No chance in hell.
 
Oh, X-Men cannon has more contridictions in it then the bible. In order to be a "believer" you have to pick and choose.
 
I'm sure the possibility exists for Willie Lumpkin to beat Thor. That doesn't mean it's going to happen.
 
Or if she had the ultimate nullifer, or the infinity guantlet or galactus as a pet or if she had prep time.... Aren't we trying a little hard to show ways she might beat Thor? Is it possible for her to win? Sure. Would she win? No chance in hell.

SMH @ the haters.

U asked,.. I gave you the ONLY WAY she's going to beat him with them being limited to what they run with.

I said nothing about tools,.. nothing about Prep time.

It amazes me that Those of you who don't know or didn't read could be as bad as Dacman on this topic.

I'm done. This is about as bad as that silliness where the whiners were complaining that Thor beats Superman hands down because he has a "magic Hammer"


Jeez.
 
SMH @ the haters.

U asked,.. I gave you the ONLY WAY she's going to beat him with them being limited to what they run with.

I said nothing about tools,.. nothing about Prep time.

It amazes me that Those of you who don't know or didn't read could be as bad as Dacman on this topic.

I'm done. This is about as bad as that silliness where the whiners were complaining that Thor beats Superman hands down because he has a "magic Hammer"


Jeez.

How about: "Who cares?"
 
SMH @ the haters.

U asked,.. I gave you the ONLY WAY she's going to beat him with them being limited to what they run with.

I said nothing about tools,.. nothing about Prep time.

It amazes me that Those of you who don't know or didn't read could be as bad as Dacman on this topic.

I'm done. This is about as bad as that silliness where the whiners were complaining that Thor beats Superman hands down because he has a "magic Hammer"


Jeez.


I can think of a few other ways it could be done, but again all I was saying is if you have to go that implausable then it's not gonna happen. It amazes me people only read what they want out of a post rather than what's actually said.

Magic hammers rock. Superman would get schooled by squirrel girl.

Who says jeez anymore?
 
Oh, X-Men cannon has more contridictions in it then the bible. In order to be a "believer" you have to pick and choose.

Please don't go there,... Thor has been here longer,.. and I remember some true garbage in there,.... unless you can give an example of where her abilities contradict themselves - you need to quit.
 
good arguement "highjacker of threads".
Obviously you have enough concern to move fingers over keyboard to say that when you can't refute an arguement.

What argument? I couldn't care less who'd win in a fictional internet fight.

And it's "argument". There's no "e". :up:
 
Please don't go there,... Thor has been here longer,.. and I remember some true garbage in there,.... unless you can give an example of where her abilities contradict themselves - you need to quit.

Didn't you just get done telling us how you were done? What was that like thirty seconds ago? I'm at work, I'm not gonna give you page by page examples but I've been reading X-Men long enough to be utterly confused by their amazing power fluctuations. Not little ones or revamps, I'm talking iceman is the most powerful man on the earth revamps. I'm talking no one has any clue how invulnerable colossus is revamps. But at the same time I've seen mutants completely limited to what their human bodies can handle (see Joesph's death). I've seen storm do some amazing things and I've seen her schooled by people she shouldn't have to get up to beat. If you don't see this you're pretty blind....
 
I'm finished you guys win.
Suddenly Storm is slow enough to get hit by lightning from Thor,... There are NO conditions where she could beat him with her abilities cuz he's a GAWWWDDD.

.
Tsk.

(moving on.)
 
I'm finished you guys win.
Suddenly Storm is slow enough to get hit by lightning from Thor,... There are NO conditions where she could beat him with her abilities cuz he's a GAWWWDDD.

.
Tsk.

(moving on.)

The fact that you got yourself worked up by this speaks VOLUMES.
 
I'm finished you guys win.
Suddenly Storm is slow enough to get hit by lightning from Thor,... There are NO conditions where she could beat him with her abilities cuz he's a GAWWWDDD.

.
Tsk.

(moving on.)

acknowledging defeat is an admirable quality. But you really don't read what's written by anyone else do you?

Previous Post:

"I can think of a few other ways it could be done, but again all I was saying is if you have to go that implausable then it's not gonna happen. It amazes me people only read what they want out of a post rather than what's actually said."
 
Okayyyyy, we know V's feelings on the matter. I'm curious who the others are that voted for Storm...and their rationale. (V...if you didn't vote for Storm, my bad for lumping you in the group.)
 
Sure, Gaea is Thor's mother. But Storm, too, is close with the Earth Mother. Even as a child she was able to summon the Goddess of Earth at will:

http://www.uncannyxmen.net/images/spotlight/storm06.jpg

Later, as an adult she was trapped in the Adversary's replica of earth, and she sensed that in that world the Mother Earth didn't exist. It was strongly implied that she could have assumed this vacant position at will (and for a moment she actually considered doing so). This is not something any weather-manipulating mutant could do, and indicates that Storm is linked with the Earth on a mystical/spiritual level as well as through her mutant abilities.

Indeed, she has been able to ask the weather do her bidding when she has been too exhausted to use her mutant powers for it:

http://www.adherents.com/lit/comics/image/Storm_04.jpg

Notice the text "Mother Nature lifts her hand, in defense of a favored daughter". In a sense, Gaea indeed is Storm's mother as she is the "mother" of all life on earth.
 
Sure, Gaea is Thor's mother. But Storm, too, is close with the Earth Mother. Even as a child she was able so summon the Goddess of Earth at will:



Later, as an adult she was trapped in the Adversary's replica of earth, and she sensed that in that world the Mother Earth didn't exist. It was strongly implied that she could have assumed this vacant position at will (and for a moment she actually considered doing so). This is not something any weather-manipulating mutant could do, and indicates that Storm is linked with the Earth on a mystical/spiritual level as well as through her mutant abilities.

Indeed, she has been able to ask the weather do her bidding when she has been too exhausted to use her mutant powers for it:



Notice the text "Mother Nature lifts her hand, in defense of a favored daughter". In a sense, Gaea indeed is Storm's mother as she is the "mother" of all life on earth.

Reading just a tad too much into that comment in my opinion. It's well known that that the localized weather reacts to her emotions and mood. It's more likely it was a manifestation of her emotional state. (I do agree with the last comment that in a manner of speaking all life has ties to Gaea.
 
Apparently hippies have those powers too.

Indeed, hippies like Thor.

Edit: By the way, I removed the images from my previous post and replaced them with links, because I wasn't hosting the pics myself. Could you, funeman, please remove the pics in your quote as well (assuming it is considered "hotlinking")?
 
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"