The Good Citizens of Metropolis: The Casting Thread

Filling out a bit of the Daily Planet bullpen…

Steve Lombard - Anders Holm
Ron Troupe - Malcolm Barrett

With Troupe as the straight man to Lombard’s comic relief.

honestly in for someone like cooke as lois lane.hope that happens. I said butler for superman for sole reason I assume WB are interested but yea I think Gunn will go for lesser known actor I reckon.

Id imagine however they will get a big name for Lex though. But id honestly prefer him to be on the younger side...just not a eisenbergian nu-tech *****ebag interpretation
 
My updated cast so far, subject to change.

David Corenswet/Superman
Monica Barbaro/Lois Lane
Gaten Matarazzo/Jimmy Olsen
Jimmy Smits/Perry White
Jimmi Simpson/Lex Luthor
Sofia Boutella/Mercy Graves
Connie Britton/Martha Kent
Bryan Cranston/Jonathan Kent
Jesse Plemmons/Parasite (Rudy jones)
Toby kebbel/Manchester Black
Aubrey Plaza/Live Wire
Cillian Murphey/Brainiac
Eric Bana/Jor-el
liv tyler/Lara
McKenna Grace/Supergirl
Ron Pearlman/Mongul (facial mocap/voice)
Christopher Judge/Darkseid
Jason Mamoa/Lobo
Abubakar Salim/Martian Manhunter
Winston Duke/Henry Irons
 
If Henry Cavill eventually goes bald he could play Lex Luthor. :o
 
My updated cast so far, subject to change.

David Corenswet/Superman
Monica Barbaro/Lois Lane
Gaten Matarazzo/Jimmy Olsen
Jimmy Smits/Perry White
Jimmi Simpson/Lex Luthor
Sofia Boutella/Mercy Graves
Connie Britton/Martha Kent
Bryan Cranston/Jonathan Kent
Jesse Plemmons/Parasite (Rudy jones)
Toby kebbel/Manchester Black
Aubrey Plaza/Live Wire
Cillian Murphey/Brainiac
Eric Bana/Jor-el
liv tyler/Lara
McKenna Grace/Supergirl
Ron Pearlman/Mongul (facial mocap/voice)
Christopher Judge/Darkseid
Jason Mamoa/Lobo
Abubakar Salim/Martian Manhunter
Winston Duke/Henry Irons

I’m inclined almost say switch Cranston and Smits.

And I like casting a lesser known for Lex. It’s not like Hiddleston was a leading man when he stepped in as Loki. Jimmi Simpson’s a great pick and in the same line of thinking I have for Billy Magnussen as Lex.
 
Nah, Smits is one of my top picks for Perry as well. I can see him in that role VERY clearly. I have a hard time picturing Cranston in either role, however. He was a fave for Lex for so long, it just feels wrong lol.
 
No to a Lex that will be 70 years old.
I said “was” lol. I agree we need a younger Lex now. My current pick is Oliver Jackson-Cohen. I want a Lex w/ leading man qualities. Basically someone who could be just as good a candidate for Bruce Wayne.
 
I think Walter White was a role written to Cranston's strengths and he kinda has sucked in everything afterwards too.
 
Lex

matthew-rhys-the-amercians.jpg
 
There are so many good actors out there that would be great for lex.
Brad Pitt
Michael Fassbender
Matthew mcconaughey
Eric Bana
Jason Isaacs
Karl Urban
 
There are so many good actors out there that would be great for lex.
Brad Pitt
Michael Fassbender
Matthew mcconaughey
Eric Bana
Jason Isaacs
Karl Urban

I’m still waiting to see if Fassbender is reintroduced in the MCU after Secret Wars. He (and McAvoy for that matter) is in a weird place right now. If if he’s kept in that role, than that’ll be a major character and he shouldn’t double as Luthor.

Jason Isaacs was my fancast for years lol. His time might be past though.

Karl Urban could be fun, good pick there.

I kind of like Brad Pitt for Mongul lol. Throw him an a mocap suit and let him ham it up but still be dramatic/menacing when the story needs him to be.
 
I’m still waiting to see if Fassbender is reintroduced in the MCU after Secret Wars. He (and McAvoy for that matter) is in a weird place right now. If if he’s kept in that role, than that’ll be a major character and he shouldn’t double as Luthor.
There’s no way in hell McAvoy and Fassbender are continuing on.
 
There’s no way in hell McAvoy and Fassbender are continuing on.

I’m not hoping for it, but I could see Secret Wars blending realities and such. Even if it’s not the same Magneto, Fassbender could still play the role. Same with McAvoy.

Let’s say the next X-Men movie is 2027 at earliest. Both actors will be late 40s and it’ll be nearly a decade since the bad taste of Dark Phoenix.

Not saying it’s a definite or my preference, I could just see it happening.
 
Though I doubt this is what Gunn had in mind when he said Cavill could return as a different character, I think Cavill would make for an exciting Brainiac.

I like the idea of Brainiac being the ultimate alpha, like Lex taken to its scary conclusion, capitalistic success embodied in a being, the synthetic body kind of looking like creepy plastic surgery. Not only does Cavill kinda have that robotic soulless thing down pat (like his MI villain, and his evil Supes), Brainiac with the face of a former Supes would further sell the idea that Vril Dox was once a hero, a great contributor to Colu as its most brilliant scientist, before he was overtaken by ambition, losing his soul, immortalizing himself in a perfect synthetic Giga Cavill body, and setting his sights to space (X) to continue growing his assets.
 
Last edited:
Cranston is a part of my old fan cast. Originally I had Kyle chandler but he didn't seem "pa Kent" enough. I also am trying to get the Kent's slightly younger than some of the other more popular choices. Kevin Costner was a perfect choice that was wasted imo.
 
I have a totally original, imaginative, most non-Billy Zane choice for Lex... Javier Bardem!!! :o
 
Mister Myxlplyx - Tom Hiddleston

I am thinking about a re-interpretation of Myxy as a mix of comic book Myxy and Q from Star Trek: The Next Generation. I think that could be a fun live action version of the character.

Toyman -Brad Dourif, or a similar type of actor.

I am thinking it would be fun to mix the Superman The Animated Series version of Toyman (with the creepy doll face) with Chucky from Child's Play. Just a demented crazy killer with a horror movie vibe.
 
Wes Bentley would be another that would be a great Lex.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"