I could use some advice. I'll try to be as concise as I can.
During the summer and when we're on break, I see 2 of my friends from HS. We'll do stuff at night like go to a diner, get ice cream go bowling, or just drive around. Sometimes they'll text a few girls we went to HS with asking to come out with us. Over the summer, this one girl replied, "Aw, sorry, I can't. Don't tell me [Spidey-Bat] is there too!" This caught my attention since my friend didn't mention me in the text. She also referred to me by the nicknames of my first and last name. It may have been b/c it was a text but only my family uses my first name's nickname and I've only had 1 teacher use my last name's nickname. They said they thought she had a boyfriend at the time so I didn't really have a reason to act on it. She goes to a college not far from where we live. I'm out of state but still nearby.
I kinda liked her back in high school but never had the courage or confidence to date anyone back then. Last week I saw her post on my friend's status on Facebook and friended her. A couple days later she liked my status update. Then on Friday, she liked my status from Tuesday and commented on it. I found this encouraging, so I replied to her comment on Saturday and liked her status on Sunday. But I've not heard back from her at all.
I've had conflicting advice from a couple of my friends. One, one of the guys who knows her, says she's probably playing games with me now and I have to go along. However, what he suggested sounded kind of bad to me. He thinks I need to make her feel possessive of me and friend girls from high school or my college on Facebook. I'm not someone who friends every person they meet. I only friend someone if I know them or knew them well and want to get back in touch. He also thinks I need to wait a bit and drag it out.
My other friend (doesn't know her) is older and what he said made more sense but he's not had as much luck as my aforementioned friend. He thinks I should try chatting with her on Facebook. My only concern is that I'm pretty awful at having a conversation with people since I either don't shut up about something or have nothing to say. He thinks I should this soon, as early as tonight or tomorrow.
Of course, both think the other's advice is bad and I shouldn't do it.
What my 2 friends and I are planning is having the four of us go out when we're on break next month. Then I'll ask her out just the 2 of us to get a drink or coffee.
I don't like admitting this, but this is the first time I've really had interest in dating someone. High school I was shallow about who I wanted to date. In college, I don't drink and all people really do here is go to the dumpy college bars and get wasted so it's been more challenging to meet people I'd like to go out with.