nogster
Civilian
- Joined
- Apr 3, 2004
- Messages
- 512
- Reaction score
- 4
- Points
- 38
That's because you aren't good at reading films. Directors are very intelligent and use symbolism and meaningful subtext to enhance the surface narrative. Chris Nolan does this. In every film. He's no Tarkovsky, Kubrick, or Lynch, but he does work in this manner. It's very disheartening to see that folks actually believe that TDKR is nothing more than an action-driven Batman movie, void of poetry or ambiguity, and that any powerful connections to archetypes and mythology have gone right over their heads.
Disagree all you want, but that's exactly what we have in The Dark Knight Rises. I mean, you're saying none of this is there, yet as soon as the title was released we all KNEW exactly where this thing was headed because of the very allegory/myth that we connect a word like "rises" to. And we were right. And to say it was a typical hero sacrifice is wrong also. Those typical hero sacrifices are based on powerful archetypes, as is the Christ figure/savior. Those are very old, very simple, and very powerful myths that resonate with us and that is exactly why we see this recurring in hero stories. The hero goes on a journey(Bruce leaves Gotham, trains, sets out to destroy injustice), he is aided by a donor (Lucious Fox/Ra's Al Ghul) and endures great suffering, pain, sometimes even death to absolve his countrymen of their sins. Ahhh...why am I wasting my time?
I'm not in any way being arrogant. I'm just pointing out what Nolan did. I'm a filmmaker, I understand how filmmakers work, I'm adept at reading film. That does not make me special or better than anyone else by any means, it just means that I specialize in a particular area. Having said that, I probably tend to shove that down people's throats without realizing it because its frustrating to see folks oversimplify films that aspire to do more than just entertain, whether the film is actually well-made or not.
Also, I have been a jerk in my last several posts, especially to The Guard, and I hope he'll accept my apology. There's no reason to take a stranger's opinions on a film so seriously.
Yes you are wasting you time.
Batman as yet another metaphor for Jesus?
Please......
TDKR uses the "phoenix" mythology. That much is obvious. But why the Christian variant in particular on this?
So anyone who doesnt believe your opinion is poor at reading films
Claiming this to be the truth is incredibly arrogant.