The Rank and Rate Man of Steel thread

[BH/HHH]

I keep asking people this so I thought heck ill just make a thread for it. So what would you rate Man of Steel out of 10 and where would you rank it amongst your best CBM movies?

 

[sf2]

I have make one. But people just too occupied with the review.

 

[Mace Dolex]

I'll post after I see it, I have the 7pm showing so I'm a few hours away.

 

[jacobed]

9/10

TDK
TDKR
Mos
BB
Xmen Fc
Thor

 

[Spelunking Man]

7/10 compared to tdk. this is the best superman movie ever written.

In terms of character, he is not charming, he is not witty. Otherwise, I would give the movie better score.

When I say the best superman movie ever written because I still dislike richard donner's movie plot where superman can turn back time. That is lame.

 

[KingKane88]

In line for the 7pm showing, I cant believe the number of Superman shirts here, this is wild!!!


Edit: Theater is packed

 

[sf2]

Mod, pls close the thread i created. here is neater and without the complaints on the way i put the rating.

I give a solid 9.

i think the critic are really harsh on Superman!!! The critic had me worried a little. Thought it would be like The Immortal movie.

ya, the destruction may be a little bit tedious. but No movie is perfect. You might wish for the romance to be a little more... the saving a little more.... the destruction a little less... but the whole story is solid... very well delivered, almost epic!!!

The best superman film. Period.

 

[Ultimatehero]

Full review coming tomorrow. In short -- you will believe a man can fly. 10/10

 

[smsvmos]

Im with you on this. I give it a 9.5/10 because I think some of the execution was a bit off but it still deliverd the goods. In the complet movie I was in the edge of my seat and everyone in the theater was also the same way.

We need Superman: The Last Son of Krypton to come out in 2015 and rush (LoL)

 

[sf2]

Im with you on this. I give it a 9.5/10 because I think some of the execution was a bit off but it still deliverd the goods. In the complet movie I was in the edge of my seat and everyone in the theater was also the same way.

We need Superman: The Last Son of Krypton to come out in 2015 and rush (LoL)

oops. there is no 9.5 option! Dilemma you have put yourself into.

i think MOS hits all the right spots gently and subtly. you gotta digest and think a little bit. it doesn't do the 'typical hero saving innocent' crowd-pleasing scenes like in Ironman / STM

 

[smsvmos]

oops. there is no 9.5 option! Dilemma you have put yourself into.

i think MOS hits all the right spots gently and subtly. you gotta digest and think a little bit. it doesn't do the 'typical hero saving innocent' crowd-pleasing scenes like in Ironman / STM

I just would have rearranged the movie differently. All scenes are perfect, story is Perfect. I would have put the Krypton scene when Clark asked Jor-El of who he was. But that's just me

 

[sf2]

I just would have rearranged the movie differently. All scenes are perfect, story is Perfect. I would have put the Krypton scene when Clark asked Jor-El of who he was. But that's just me

indeed all scenes are perfect. just wish some of the scenes Zack can punch it harder and the tedious "piling machine destruction" is a little too much. lol.

and here is my wish lists.

the pa kent
i wish Clark would emotional break down in front of Lois when he talked about his father death. he should have blamed himself for not saving his father and being too selfish and too afraid. then to see Lois consoled him and there is where the affection grow.

the first introduction
i wish after the first flight they would have done it like Ironman. you know inserting some "the crowd pleasing saving scenes" over the whole world.

the piling machine and its destruction to cut half.

 

[Arc-Light]

Good....but not as good as Avengers or tDK...but a solid 8..

 

[smsvmos]

This is how I would have played it out

My Man of Steel Cut:

Spoiler

- Movie starts where Comic book Prequel ends
- Clark in fishing boat scene
- Clark saves ppl from Oil rig
- Clark gets knocked out by debris from oil rig and falls into the ocean.
- Clark goes into flashback sequence when he was a kid
- Clark wakes up and goes to a nearby town
- Clark sees a school bus in the town and goes into a flashback
- We see the Kent's and early teen Clark
- Teen Clark saves school bus
- Pa Kent has a talk with Teen Clark
- Pa Kent tells the truth to teen Clark about where he is from and how they found him (Maybe a flashback of how they found him?) Flashback ends.
- Clark goes in the quest to find the Fortress of Solitude (Kryptonian Ship)
- Clark find the key in the Kryptonian ship and activates Jor-El's Message
- Jor -El tells him of what happened in Krypton
- Flashback of Krypton
- Lara gives birth to Kal-El
- Jor-El and Lara place new born Kal-El into the ship
- Jor-El reunites with the Kryptonin Counsel about Kryptons destruction
- Zod enters with his rebellion army to take over the counsel
- Zod takes Jor-El into custody but he escapes
- Jor-El takes the Codex and goes to his chambers
- Jor-El and Lara place new born Kal-El into the ship
- Jor- El activates the ship to send baby Kal-El to earth.
- Zod arrives to stop Jor-El and arrest him for the stilling the codex
- Jor-El and Zod fight
- Kal-El's ship takes off
- Zod is sentenced to the Black Zero
- Destruction of Krypton takes place (end of flashback)
- Clark suites up
- A Beacon is detected by the military and Lois goes with them
- Lois finds Clark on the ship and he saves her from the wound inflicted by the guard robot
- Fortress Ship takes off and lands in another part of earth
- Superman first flight
- Superman goes back to Smallville
- Lois goes after the identity of the mysterious guy (Clark)
- Lois tracks him to Smallville and talks to Martha
- Martha tells her that Clark works in the graveyard of Smallville
- Clark tells Lois of his father
- Flashback of Clark and Pa Kent
- The Tornado sequence
- Pa Kent dies
- Lois goes back to metropolis and shelves the story
- Zod's message to earth and Kal-El
- Zod' ship lands on earth
- Clark says goodbye to Martha
- The military surround Zod's ship
- Superman presents himself for the first time as demanded by Zod
- Lois talks to Superman
- Zod sends a pod to take Superman and they also take Lois.
- they are taken to the Black Zero to meet Zod
- Kal gives Lois the codex key
- In the dream sequence Zod reveals his true intentions
- Flash back of how Zod and crew got free from the phantom zone
- Zod tells Kal-El of his plan to activate the Kryptonian Clone Codex to re-populate the earth. In order to activate the Codex Zod need the key to the ship
- Kal-El refuses to help
- Kal wakes up
- Lois activates the key in Zod's ship
- Jor-El tells Lois what she has to do
- Zod goes to the kent farm to find the key
- Lois escapes on a Kryptonian pod
- Superman escapes Black Zero and saves Lois from crashing
- Zod arrives on the kent farm
- Ma kent refuses to help them
- Faora tries to kill Ma Kent
- Superman saves Ma Kent
- Superman fight the Kryptonians in Smallville
- The military attack both the Kryptonians and Superman
- The military take Superman into custody
- The military interrogate Superman
- Zod arrives in Metropolis and also deploys the other ship for Terraforming
- The military engage Zod's ship
- Zod goes to the fortress and activates the genesis chamber
- Superman teams up with the military to stop the ships from terraforming
- Superman goes head on into the ray to try and stop it.
- Superman destroys the ship
- The military activates the Phantom Zone
- Superman takes down the Fortress and the Genesis chamber
- Superman saves Lois from falling to death
- Zod’s Ship is sent Into the black hole
- Superman fights Zod
- Superman kills Zod
- Superman goes back to Smallville
- Clark with the help of Lois gets the job at the Daily Planet.
- The End

That's how I would have done it

As u can see all the scenes are there but just in a different sequence of order.

 

[GreenKToo]

8/10. the way it was edited holds me at an 8.

 

[antonydelfini]

DC/Marvel Superhero Movies Ranking:

Avengers 9/10
TDK 9/10
X-Men First Class 8/10
Iron Man 3 8/10
Man of Steel 8/10
The Amazing Spider-Man 8/10
Batman Begins 8/10
Iron Man 8/10
Spider-Man = Spider-Man 2 8/10
Superman the Movie 8/10

 

[Dispatch Ninja]

9/10

BB
Mos
Iron man
Tdkr
Tdk
The avengers

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

Solid 9/10.

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

Better than Avengers and on par with the first Iron Man is my best comparative model

 

[WoodyROM]

9/10

MOS
BB
TDK
Iron man
TDKR
The Avengers


This movie was amazing. Blows away any other CBM for me. Was it perfect, no. But it could never be. I do greatly look forward to the sequel to see a more fleshed out Superman story, but it hit all the right notes for me in the origin story.

 

[sf2]

High 5!!!

 

[Sup3rman81]

This movie blows Avengers out of the water.

MoS 10/10
TDK 9.5 /10
Iron Man 9 /10
TDKR 8/10
Avengers 7/10

 

[\S/JcDc\S/]

1. MOS/TDK. 2. Iron Man 3. Spidey II 4. BB. 5. TDKR 6. Xmen First Class (yep I said it) 7. Thor. 8. Avengers 9. Captain America

 

[ElDuderino]

MOS
TDK
Avengers
BB
XM:FC
IM
TDKR

 

[Ozymandias]

Having seen it twice now, I'd rank it:

1. The Dark Knight
2. Man of Steel
3. Avengers
4. Batman Begins
5. The Dark Knight Rises