Spidey-Bat
Ours is the Fury
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2003
- Messages
- 39,480
- Reaction score
- 5
- Points
- 33
I dont need to play it to predict that it will win Game of the Year. Thats my prediction based off everything we have seen and going by the fact that the last game was as good as it was. I feel Naughty Dog will go way above and beyond what made the first game such a stand out thus nabbing it the overall best game for 2009. Now you are right, maybe the game is just going to fall flat and in no way deserve that title. I happen to think thats very unlikely and itll be the opposite. Again, i dont need to play it to predict it will be the GOTY. Period.
Sales wise yes, gameplay wise no. Again, what im saying is just going over your head. You have said its basically impossible to say a game will be worthy of GOTY before one has played it, thats just not true. I used MGS4 as an exapmple. That was a game many knew was going to be fantastic and it was due to previous versions of the game and industry reaction. Its what im doing with Uncharted 2. Get it yet?
I never said Uncharted 2 couldn't be GOTY or that you couldn't predict a game to be GOTY. I'm arguing that you can't say a game will be GOTY without playing it. You posted a few times before that Uncharted 2 would be the GOTY, not just that it would be a candidate for one.
It can top B:AA. It has a wider appeal, greater replay value, and it's the friggin Beatles.No, it wont top B:AA. MW2, i cant disagree with you really. The AIAS gave the first Modern Warfare title the overall Game of the Year, it could happen again. I still think Uncharted takes it, but thats me.
Because of Scribbblenauts' uniqueness and how its popularity exploded at E3, If any handheld is ever going to win it, it will be this.A handheld isnt going to win the AIAS Game of the Year award. Not saying it doesnt deserve it, i just dont see it happening.

t:

