BvS BvS Rottentomatoes score - how important will it be, and what do you hope for? - Part 1

[Flint Marko]

Let them have it, Flint...let them have it

Yeah, I posted that before I looked at the tomato meter and started reading the reviews... I'm just speechless.
Is it possible for this to go anywhere near the fresh territory? Captain America started out in the 30's and went up to the 70's. So it's unlikely, but you never know....

 

[DarthSkywalker]

10 fresh, 17 rotten. A top critic fresh one as well.

 

[db85usa]

I see 29 reviews right now on RT. More fresh ratings coming in.

 

[InJustice]

Holy ****. Is this real life? What is everyone hating about it? Whats the common complaint.

Looks like fundamental stuff like run time (some felt it needed more time), narrative issues, and such.

 

[king666]

You don't f up Batman, Superman and WW. You just don't.

 

[Plaidchuck]

You're one of those guys on here that I hate when they basically go "I was right all along, look at the reviews", you might think that but there are tons of other people who think otherwise. You don't hold the truth.

Nah I never said I held the truth. I just wanted this movie to do passingly well critically along with BO returns. But you can't deny Snyder has a bad critical track record

 

[Matt]

I had some fun opening rotten tomatoes on 3 different browsers with all 3 at 5 positive, 15 negative, which is 25% positive so far.

Firefox: 29%
Chrome: 0%
IE: 20%.

Its showing me 27 critics, 5 positive and 15 negative for 34 %.


Go home Rotten Tomatoes, you're drunk!

 

[Travesty]

What is this, some kind of suicide squad?

 

[Pokkle]

I wasn't expecting this at all, I didn't believe in the bad buzz and I was trying to avoid spoilers : O
I still going to see the movie anyways, Batman vs Superman is too important for me.

 

[LEVITIKUZ]

I just want a DC film universe as good as Marvel's.

Good news is people praise the cast at least so keep them. It's likely Snyder's fault.

 

[Marz69]

I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FLIP WHAT THESE "CRITICS" SAY.

The ones that hate it were going to hate it regardless. Guys, we knew this.

Go, enjoy the superman vs. batman we were waiting for, and piss on these naysayers.

I'm pumped for it. I'm NOT looking at RT or the internet until I SEE it.

I have no doubt that I will like the movie. But the RT is brutal.

 

[Kobra]

You're basically saying "because people don't like what I like, there's a conspiracy afoot."

No, i'm basically saying: "Because corruption is real, it wouldn't shock me if i learned it's well present in a business that deals with billions of dollars"

 

[Mr. Forest]

Yeah, 37%!

 

[Karried]

JJ understands Star Wars. Snyder doesn't seem to understand Superman.

I saw TFA and thought it was trash.

I haven't even fully watched the Star Wars series and came in to watch the original trilogy then the premier of TFA.

After the movie I couldn't help but think why people love TFA/SW so much, it wasn't even all that and critics really loved TFA? I thought it was a garbage copy paste of one of the 90s Star Wars movie.

Action was eh, Light Saber battle with Rey was eh and dumb cheesy one liners made me get goose bumps thats how cringy they were.

 

[ThaIllest_89]

So far, I've seen positives from Rolling Stones, Variety, and others. But, we'll see. Either way, whether good or bad, I already bought my ticket, so I'm there regardless.

 

[DarthSkywalker]

What aspect of the movie are the critics criticising?

Calling it joyless, saying Superman isn't a fully formed character, that the script takes itself far too seriously and that it is very long.

 

[jmc]

You don't f up Batman, Superman and WW. You just don't.

Apparently you can.

 

[BatsDC]

I DON'T GIVE A FLYING FLIP WHAT THESE "CRITICS" SAY.

The ones that hate it were going to hate it regardless. Guys, we knew this.

Go, enjoy superman vs. batman we were waiting for, and piss on these naysayers.

I'm pumped for it. I'm NOT looking at RT or the internet until I SEE it.

Yes, all these professional film critics are childish fanboys who were going to hate the movie no matter what.

These are critics, not fans.

 

[OutOfBoose]

What aspect of the movie are the critics criticising?

They say - CGI fest, not fun, stupid, plot doesn't work, big let down in every sense...

 

[Flint Marko]

Alright the score is jumping, it's going to keep moving before we know around where it's finally going to settle. How are the reviews that aren't on RT looking?

 

[harryoscop]

I see 29 reviews right now on RT. More fresh ratings coming in.

t:

 

[Dispatch Ninja]

Maybe it'll be the opposite of man of steel, start off low and end up high.

 

[dhandler01]

Its showing me 27 critics, 5 positive and 15 negative for 34 %.


Go home Rotten Tomatoes, you're drunk!

Yeah I was laughing as I refreshed and the numbers kept changing in weird ways

 

[Karelia]

10 fresh and 17 rotten.

I'm still excited.

 

[DarthSkywalker]

I saw TFA and thought it was trash.

I haven't even fully watched the Star Wars series and came in to watch the original trilogy then the premier of TFA.

After the movie I couldn't help but think why people love TFA/SW so much, it wasn't even all that and critics really loved TFA? I thought it was a garbage copy paste of one of the 90s Star Wars movie.

Action was eh, Light Saber battle with Rey was eh and dumb cheesy one liners maybe get goose bumps thats how cringy they were.

That is your right. But the critics and masses certainly enjoyed it to the tune of making it the third highest grossing film of all time, with a very good RT score.

If BvS had the same reception, no one here would be complaining.