I assume when you talk about Peter being "Durrrr science!" you are refering to the school field trip in the first Rami film? Cause Peter pretty much does the same thing on TASM when he awnsers Conners question. Plus I felt that Peter's science fact speak in Rami's film was kinda natural. Who hasn't thrown out random trivia when we are surrounded by our friends in a party or other situation to try and impress our friends and try and fit in with them and everyone else? I have.
Not that I didn't like the Raimi films (Spider-man 2's probably my favourite superhero movie to date maybe tied with TDK) or Peter's portrayal in them (though I suppose I found it a
bit too Clark Kent-ish), but in those films, what did they really do to show his aptitude besides him verbally saying smart stuff? Even in his fights I don't recall him using his head as much, besides punching and stuff. That's what I felt TAS did well, showed without telling. Like when Peter devised the web to sense vibrations and the Lizard's location. That was smart. I'm not saying Peter in TAS DIDN'T also vocalize his intelligence, or that telling is necessarily a bad thing. What I'm saying is that the props and set-pieces ADDED to it. Almost like Easter Eggs. I like how he had Feynman on his desktop but they never once mentioned who he was for instance.