The Amazing Spider-Man The Amazing Spider-Man: Box Office Thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Spidey Making the web in the sewers - AMAZING
Spidey taking on the police - AMAZING
Spidey saving the boy on the Bridge - AMAZING
Spidey final swing - AMAZING

I get that you didn't like the movie and you are of course entitled to you opinion but your opinion is an opinion it isn't fact.
:up:

Stan Lee's cameo - AMAZING (probably the best one he's ever had)
Peter and Gwen's chemistry - AMAZING
Rhys Ifans performance - AMAZING

Completely different scenarios from the other two. TASM has a set date for may 2014. There was/is no set date on the table for TDK or the avengers before either film was released as is the scenario for TASM.

As already mentioned to meet this date filming needs to begin in january so webb does not have the luxury to ponder and wait like nolan did and whedon does.

Unfortunately it is not Webb just pondering or waiting. We have to see what Fox decides to do.

I would think that the movie has to start filming in October/November and not January though.
 
Nope.

Which got better reviews?
Reviews mean nothing in the end. Its all opinion. If he feels that TASM is better than BB, then so be it. Its his opinion and he is entitled to it. I personally enjoyed TASM more than BB, though I think BB is a much better film.

Obviously BB has better reviews with 85% on RT, but I'm not going to use that to determine which movie is better.
 
Just like Nolan? After TDK came out, his response to questions about a sequel was something to the effect of, "Do 3rd installments ever turn out well? Yeah, I thought so. There's your answer."

Whedon's also talking about what a huge, exhausting undertaking the first Avengers was and how he also has other things he wants to do. It's typical director speak to deny plans until they've done their contract negotiations and signed on the dotted line. Doesn't mean they don't actually have plans.

Now, for the record, I'm not saying Webb is definitely returning. I personally think that could go either way at this point, especially with him still having a standing contract at Fox. I'm just saying his silence on the issue is in no way proof that he's not returning.

Why don't you include the whole quote from Nolan? He was only iffy on a third movie because he didn't yet have a full plan. Nolan didn't have a firm idea for a 3rd movie until 2010 as he had other projects going as well so he couldn't devote all his time quite yet. Nolan wanted to use Heath in the third film and when Heath died I think he lost a little steam. A more apt comparison would be TDK....Nolan stated he didn't know if he would return. Webb isn't saying anything. If they want ASM2 out in 2 years...production has to start before the year is out.

With all the rumors flying around...I think he's out. Sony better choose their next director wisely and whoever it is...I hope they put their foot down and tell the execs to f off.
 
Reviews mean nothing in the end. Its all opinion. If he feels that TASM is better than BB, then so be it. Its his opinion and he is entitled to it. I personally enjoyed TASM more than BB, though I think BB is a much better film.

Obviously BB has better reviews with 85% on RT, but I'm not going to use that to determine which movie is better.
And it's my opinion that he challenged. Nobody was even talking about BB so if he wants to throw BB in the mix now...I'm gonna use some unbiased source.
 
Why don't you include the whole quote from Nolan? He was only iffy on a third movie because he didn't yet have a full plan. Nolan didn't have a firm idea for a 3rd movie until 2010 as he had other projects going as well so he couldn't devote all his time quite yet. Nolan wanted to use Heath in the third film and when Heath died I think he lost a little steam. A more apt comparison would be TDK....Nolan stated he didn't know if he would return. Webb isn't saying anything. If they want ASM2 out in 2 years...production has to start before the year is out.

With all the rumors flying around...I think he's out. Sony better choose their next director wisely and whoever it is...I hope they put their foot down and tell the execs to f off.
Webb said that he does want to return. And Production will have to start before the year is out, correct. Probably by October/November.
 
When did he say that? Before or after the movie came out?
 
I just hope that Sony is looking for other directors just in case, instead of waiting until they find out if he is staying or leaving.
 
Who are these "most people" you assume to? The posters in the Spidey boards?
Brad Jones aka Cinema Snob liked it more than Avengers and TDKR
Doug Walker liked more than TDKR, i guess based in his review
People i know liked TASM more than TDKR

I just hope that Sony is looking for other directors just in case, instead of waiting until they find out if he is staying or leaving
I hope that they do announce any news the next months
 
Last edited:
Didn't Roger Ebert give TASM a higher rating than The Avengers?
 
The keyword here is most people. Not a few people.

So let's check out Rotten Tomatoes and see what they say.

The Dark Knight Rises - 87% Positive, Average Rating 8/10
The Amazing Spider-Man - 73% Positive, Average Rating 6.7/10

Rotten Tomatoes User Reviews

The Dark Knight Rises - 92% Positive, Average Rating 4.5/5
The Amazing Spider-Man - 81% Positive, Average Rating 4/5

How about Metacritic?

The Dark Knight Rises - 78/100
The Amazing Spider-Man - 66/100

Let's check the opinion of this very board using the Best Superhero Movie of the Summer Poll in the Misc Films Folder.

The Amazing Spider-Man - 3.92%
The Avengers - 41.67%
The Dark Knight Rises - 54.51%

IMDB User Ratings?

The Dark Knight Rises 8.9/10
The Amazing Spider-Man 7.6/10

Based on the evidence the assertion that most people think that The Amazing Spider-Man is better than The Dark Knight Rises is a blatant falsehood.
 
Last edited:
Based on the evidence the assertion that most people think that The Amazing Spider-Man is better than The Dark Knight Rises is a blatant falsehood.
True , but TASM is an origin film and a reboot and people still had Spiderman 1,2 and even 3 in their minds i hope TASM 2 is more accepted from the GA
 
True , but TASM is an origin film and a reboot and people still had Spiderman 1,2 and even 3 in their minds i hope TASM 2 is more accepted from the GA
TASM had a lot going against it, and its no surprise that it was in third place. And just because "most people" think the movie isn't that great doesn't mean its actually a bad movie. Just a bunch of opinions.
 
Nope.

Which got better reviews?


Definately prefer ASM to BB. BB is tedious in the 3rd act, absolutely TEDIOUS and this is coming from someone who prefers slow burn. There's slow burn and then there's comatose.
 
The third act is tedious? You must be insane. The movie kicks into high gear and doesn't let up after Bruce becomes Bats.
 
Batman Begins was refreshing after Batman & Robin. But if I was stuck on an island and could only choose one of the two, I'd go with TASM.
 
Hmmm, interesting. I would probably choose ASM too, altough BB is the better movie.
 
To me it seems that the general consensus for The Amazing Spider-man is that it has been somewhat underwhelming... in every aspect.

And we can use all the excuses in the book... it won't change nothing.
 
To me it seems that the general consensus for The Amazing Spider-man is that it has been somewhat underwhelming... in every aspect.

images
 
To me it seems that the general consensus for The Amazing Spider-man is that it has been somewhat underwhelming... in every aspect.

And we can use all the excuses in the book... it won't change nothing.
What "excuses?" If someone feels that the movie is NOT underwhelming, then nothing can change THAT.
 
Yeah I know...

The Amazing Spider-Man just came and went. Without making so much as a dent on the genre or adding anything siginificant to the Spider-man franchise on the whole.

Lets hope the sequel improves.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,268
Messages
22,076,844
Members
45,876
Latest member
Crazygamer3011
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"