Willie Lumpkin
Trophy Husband
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2003
- Messages
- 14,085
- Reaction score
- 2,583
- Points
- 103
So, utter and complete crap that had not the slightest credible justification? *ducks*
People who live in glass houses . . .
![]()
Is that a fact or a minor opinion? *dodges*
Fact backed up by the majority of the evidence in the comics, and even side commentary by involved characters at the time.![]()
Eh, I actually give that movie a pass, simply for having Christopher motherfreaking Reeves in it! Dude brought playing superheroes into a whole new level...............and then Robert Downey Jr. came and elevated it again.
I'm of the opinion that X-men Origins is the worst comic book movie I've ever seen, followed closely by FFINO.
I thought you had seen more comic adaptations than that. There are a lot of bad comic book movies out there, and a bunch worse than Origins. I suggest you take a look at STEEL, ELEKTRA, Corman's FANTASTIC FOUR, CAPTAIN AMERICA (1979), CAPTAIN AMERICA (1990), GHOST RIDER SOV, THE SPIRIT, JONAH HEX........
In the past 10 years, this is what I feel is the Top 10 Worst CBMs.
1. Fant4stic Four
2. Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance
3. Jonah Hex
4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
5. Green Lantern
6. The Spirit
7. X-Men: Wolverine Origins
8. Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer
9. Punisher: War Zone
10. Ghost Rider
If you're talking about last year's TMNT, sorry but no, TMNT 2 and ESPECIALLY 3 are far worse than last year's turtles. Go watch it again.
I haven't seen all of this list, but these highlighted are all better than FFINO and more watchable in my opinion. Maybe GR: SOV is the least watchable of those, but the others at least can be sat through and enjoyed at some level, particularly the Corman FF and the 2 Cap movies. And these three were made ages ago, whereas FFINO was not, so it has no excuse to have almost the same production values in the final battle.
I thought you had seen more comic adaptations than that. There are a lot of bad comic book movies out there, and a bunch worse than Origins. I suggest you take a look at STEEL, ELEKTRA, Corman's FANTASTIC FOUR, CAPTAIN AMERICA (1979), CAPTAIN AMERICA (1990), GHOST RIDER SOV, THE SPIRIT, JONAH HEX........
And you have misread my post.....I was not saying those in my list were better than FFINO.....I was saying they were worse than ORIGINS because he was saying ORIGINS was worse than FFINO and put Origins as the top of his worst list.
I was assuming that your love of the Wolverine character was behind that statement. In that way, I can understand your putting it at the top of the list...but if you ever get around to watching some of the others movies, I think your standings will change.The only movie on this list that I've seen is Ghost Rider SOV, which I remember almost nothing about. The rest I plan on seeing eventually just as a fan of the genre, but I haven't gotten around to it yet.
I think the reason I personally hate Origins so much is because of the wasted potential. Wolverine is one of my favorite characters, so to see his first solo outing be so haphazardly put together and cheaply made was very disappointing. But once I brave the depths of past CBM failures we'll see if I find one I like even less than Origins.
I'm sorry you took it that way, I wasn't trying to argue, I honestly thought that you thought I was saying those movies were worse than FFINO.And you are just being argumentative. I haven't misread anything. I was just making a general observation that those films you listed were better than FFINO, that's all.