I admit the plot was terrible, the characters may not have been too memorable either, and yeah, the presentation wasn't all that amazing either. The environments did look cheap most of the time. Which is probably the price you pay for 60fps. But I guess I gave it a pass, because I knew of the circumstances surrounding the game. It was close to not getting made at all, and Platinum salvaged what they could.
And with what time they had, they crafted a game that had amazing gameplay, and didn't take itself too seriously. The game was simply meant to be fun. And it did its job well.
A game like DmC might have had a overall smoother production, better visuals and presentation, even solid gameplay, but I felt Ninja Theory and Capcom were too far up their own asses. Taking the piss out of their fans, going all dark and edgy, the game taking itself too seriously.
The way you feel about MGR, I feel about DmC.