The Official Lex Luthor Casting Thread - Part 5

Status
Not open for further replies.
well he is in

The Hobbit
Star Trek 2
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy
War Horse

and BBC's Sherlock

not hard to see the support and a great actor to boot
 
I'm going to throw a name out there that most of you would probably NEVER have thought of. This person's name is Billy Zane. You are probably thinking to yourself "Who is this Billy Zane person?" Well once you see his picture, ALL debate will be over. I mean look at him! He's bald! That alone is enough to be THE perfect Lex Luthor. Come on Zack Snyder, make it happen!

Billy-Zane.jpg



:oldrazz:

Billy Zane is one of those "hes bald therefore he should be considered" type choices, however having said that I think he'd make an excellent Lex. Plays the bad guy very well, has a good voice & suits being bald.

i do like him for lex and unlike past luthor's he looks henry's age range
article-2034142-0DBA304D00000578-754_634x892.jpg

I don't think I'd like him as Lex look wise, however might make an interesting Brainiac..

I think he'd look like an alien if he was bald, he has a wierd face.. kinda reminds me of one of those 30 Days of Night vampires.. :O
 
Billy Zane is one of those "hes bald therefore he should be considered" type choices, however having said that I think he'd make a bald Lex. Plays the bald guy very well, has a bald voice & suits being bald.

Fixed. :hehe:

Moreover, Zane is bald and as we all know, Lex is bald and no actor with hair can ever portray a bald man accurately because he could not possibly understand the personal strife that comes with baldness. He would just be faking it like a hooker pretending to have an orgasm.

So in conclusion, Lex is bald, Zane is bald, it's perfect casting. Just like Brandon Routh was perfect casting as Superman; Superman has no personality, so a wooden actor who looks sort of like Christopher Reeve is ideal.
 
Zane is the perfect evil looking, bad ass actor you can get for Lex...he's just not likeable or a good actor.

I stopped liking him once he started sticking it to Kelly Brook :D
 
I hate to say it but having seen Meloni in his new devious role on True Blood, I kinda would have liked to have seen his take on Lex
 
I hate to say it but having seen Meloni in his new devious role on True Blood, I kinda would have liked to have seen his take on Lex

Yeah, me too. He's awesome on that show. Hell, Meloni, Valentina Cervi and Christopher Heyerdahl are the BEST things on that show right now. I'd rather watch a show that was solely about them.
 
I just hope they go with the supergenius/mogul version of the character, not the snarky con man version (Hackman/Spacey). Someone truly formidable.
 
Yeah, it's kind of weird that the two most well-known versions of the character (the scheming business mogul and the green-armored mad scientist) have never made it to the big screen and we kept getting stuck with real estate con man Lex.

Well, I guess Superman IV touched on some of the mad scientist aspects of the character but the less said about that movie, the better.
 
Have you guys seen the trailer for "Alex Cross?"

[YT]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMVfoEegEuw[/YT]

Matthew Fox plays the villain and he is:

1) bald, duh.

2) showing an intensity that I'm not used to seeing from him.
 
Last edited:
I was just about to post that. The movie looks sh**ty but Fox looks crazy good. I've never seen him play a psycho before but he looks like he went all in for it. He might make an interesting Lex.
 
Yeah, it's kind of weird that the two most well-known versions of the character (the scheming business mogul and the green-armored mad scientist) have never made it to the big screen and we kept getting stuck with real estate con man Lex.
.

This.

It makes it so hard for me not to hate on Singer for making it seem like there IS no other version of the character.

People remember Gene Hackman's Lex. They accept that it's a kind of cheesy villain because it's an old film. And then they watch SR thinking Kevin Spacey is a 'new', modern Lex, and it turns out he's still got the same agenda and a similar portrayal of character...

So they think that's just who he is.

People have absolutely no idea of Lex's character as the fans understand him.

Whether you're a fan of him being a scrawny scientist, a beefy businessman, a charming philanthropist with an anti alien agenda, or a jealous man in an armoured power suit; you say to the average person that you're favourite villain is Lex Luthor and they raise their eyebrows, because in their mind he's just this crazy flamboyant con man who's obsessed with owning land, and is no real threat to Superman or what he's trying to achieve, beyond whipping out some Kryptonite... In their mind, he sucks!

Lex should have power over Superman that has NOTHING to do with kryptonite.

Whether it's his intelligence or his power as an important figure in Metropolis, Lex is supposed to be a formidable opponent. Not physically (until you introduce a power suit), but he's the man constantly trying to derail Superman's agenda.

I mean, take various different versions of Lex and what have you got:

He pollutes public opinion. He tries to make Superman look bad. He is a key figure in organised crime and spends the majority of his time CAUSING a lot of the problems Superman is trying to solve. He's behind so many of the bad things that happen in Metropolis. If Clark could take him down, it would be a huge step in clearing up the corruption, greed and villainy in his city.

But it's not so easy because he's so good at what he does. He's so convincingly charming in public, and so menacingly threatening behind closed doors. All his bases are always covered, so that nothing can be traced back to him. And he even gains more and more power, to the point of becoming President! How do you win against a man like that?

I swear, the biggest reason I want MOS to big success and secure a sequel, is that I love Lex Luthor. I seriously absolutely love him as a villain, and I am so sick of him being portrayed so badly when there is SO MUCH good material there to work with.
 
Yes!

It's almost unbearable knowing we probly won't see lex cast for another 2 or 3 years.
 
Yup :(

Also unbearable thinking about what will happen to the character if they screw it up this time as well... This franchise is make or break for both Supes and Lex really.

They won't get another chance for a loooooong time if they aren't well received.
 
I think he'd look like an alien if he was bald, he has a wierd face.. kinda reminds me of one of those 30 Days of Night vampires.. :O

How dare you...That's Sherlock you're speaking of!! :o

Rowsdower said:
So in conclusion, Lex is bald, Zane is bald, it's perfect casting. Just like Brandon Routh was perfect casting as Superman; Superman has no personality, so a wooden actor who looks sort of like Christopher Reeve is ideal.

I would cast Billy Zane as Lex in my movie...And then put a wig on him.
 
This.

It makes it so hard for me not to hate on Singer for making it seem like there IS no other version of the character.

People remember Gene Hackman's Lex. They accept that it's a kind of cheesy villain because it's an old film. And then they watch SR thinking Kevin Spacey is a 'new', modern Lex, and it turns out he's still got the same agenda and a similar portrayal of character...

So they think that's just who he is.

People have absolutely no idea of Lex's character as the fans understand him.

Whether you're a fan of him being a scrawny scientist, a beefy businessman, a charming philanthropist with an anti alien agenda, or a jealous man in an armoured power suit; you say to the average person that you're favourite villain is Lex Luthor and they raise their eyebrows, because in their mind he's just this crazy flamboyant con man who's obsessed with owning land, and is no real threat to Superman or what he's trying to achieve, beyond whipping out some Kryptonite... In their mind, he sucks!

Lex should have power over Superman that has NOTHING to do with kryptonite.

Whether it's his intelligence or his power as an important figure in Metropolis, Lex is supposed to be a formidable opponent. Not physically (until you introduce a power suit), but he's the man constantly trying to derail Superman's agenda.

I mean, take various different versions of Lex and what have you got:

He pollutes public opinion. He tries to make Superman look bad. He is a key figure in organised crime and spends the majority of his time CAUSING a lot of the problems Superman is trying to solve. He's behind so many of the bad things that happen in Metropolis. If Clark could take him down, it would be a huge step in clearing up the corruption, greed and villainy in his city.

But it's not so easy because he's so good at what he does. He's so convincingly charming in public, and so menacingly threatening behind closed doors. All his bases are always covered, so that nothing can be traced back to him. And he even gains more and more power, to the point of becoming President! How do you win against a man like that?

I swear, the biggest reason I want MOS to big success and secure a sequel, is that I love Lex Luthor. I seriously absolutely love him as a villain, and I am so sick of him being portrayed so badly when there is SO MUCH good material there to work with.

Beautifully written!

THIS is precisely why Lex doesn't need to be "given a rest" on film, as many have suggested. Yes, the Donner real estate schemer version needs to be given a rest. But not the Lex we all know and love. We've never gotten that, except in the first few seasons of Smallville (a show I love to poke fun at but I will never trash their version of Luthor, which was awesome). I'm still holding out hope that Snyder has secretly cast someone great in the Luthor role and even though it will be a small part, it will be a juicy one that ultimately leads to a huge part in the sequels.
 
Whoever he is, they better make him charming, good looking and with a lotta charisma. I'm sick of Lex being treated like a fool in the Donner-verse.
 
Whoever he is, they better make him charming, good looking and with a lotta charisma. I'm sick of Lex being treated like a fool in the Donner-verse.

I agree. IMO, the best Lex Luthor portrayal was John Shea in L&C, at least in the early seasons. He was charming and very evil at the same time. The character was written and acted perfectly.
 
I don't think there is a doubt that the majority of modern day Superman fans know how they want Lex. Corporate, intelligent, and manipulatively charming. We just have to hope that the big whigs understand to give that interpretation. We have seen it on Lois and Clark with John Shea and on SV with Rosenbaum. I think the Gene Hackman type Lex is done and they know it.
 
The perfect Luthor cocktail would be 1 part Howard Hughes, 1 part Antonio Salieri with a splash of Telsa and a twist of Gordon Gekko.
 
Luthor is the villain this franchise deserves, but not the one it needs right now.


In order to rebrand Superman to the public and sell the character, they really needed a superpowered action-oriented villain for Man of Steel.
 
pft poll is closed.

I would've picked ~Corrupt Businessman~ played by Jason Isaacs but he'd have to work hard on that accent.
(Secretly suppose Idris Alba too)
 
I agree. IMO, the best Lex Luthor portrayal was John Shea in L&C, at least in the early seasons. He was charming and very evil at the same time. The character was written and acted perfectly.

Agreed so much. He's my best too :)

Second would be STAS, third Smallville.

Luthor is the villain this franchise deserves, but not the one it needs right now.


In order to rebrand Superman to the public and sell the character, they really needed a superpowered action-oriented villain for Man of Steel.

Completely agreed.

Though I'm still hoping Lexcorp is alluded to in MOS in some way. Because I want him to be a huge presence in Metropolis.
 
Last edited:
I suppose they will go the ASM way...Oscorp is there, but the main man is not shown. Of course, it doesn't seem like LexCorp would have a role as big in MOS as Oscorp does in ASM.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"