Dark Phoenix X-Men: Dark Phoenix News and Speculation Thread - Part 8

[Charzhin0]

Confirmation of genosha

 

[Marvel united]

Confirmation of genosha

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

 

[Marvel united]

I don’t think it was absent at all, the whole thing with the Vulture was a prime example. All he had to do was go to the dance, be with his friends, be with the girl he likes, stay out of this crazy man’s way and he had zero hesitation still tracking Vulture (and actually saves his life) after a very serious and real threat. He didn’t go after Vulture for Stark, he went after Vulture because it was the right thing to do. And yeah he looked up to Stark because he idolized him, but he wanted to join the Avengers because for awhile he thought he could be part of something bigger and “do more”, but by the end of the story, he realizes it’s being a “friendly neighborhood Spider-man” can make a big difference.

You are right about the other stories you mentioned, and Kraven’s Last Hunt was a great Spider-man story and such a great character piece of Kraven.

This. And Spider-Man has ALWAYS wanted to be a bigtime suprerhero. This goes all the way back to the Lee/Ditko days where he wanted to be recognized like the Fantastic Four were.

 

[Lip]

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

Not necessarily true. They can still do it. Besides, their take on Genosha could be very different.

Despite seeing the sentinels recently, I think they might appear in the first movie. The sentinels could help establish how humans and the government feels and react to the existence of mutants, it could help establish the team itself and then a fight scene as a bonus. Avengers vs Chitauri style.

 

[SumT]

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

wasted and forced in, not just a great storyline, but an ICONIC storyline that didnt have Genosha on first place and that never needed Magneto. But here we are again. Thank u Kinberg for more Magneto getting screentime over other beloved x-men that you simply dont want us to enjoy.

 

[magneto23]

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

How can it be swiped away when they don't have it yet? And its just a location. Who knows what the actual story line is going to be.

 

[Erik Lensherr]

 

[Erik Lensherr]

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

troll

 

[fobi]

Confirmation of genosha

Where? Was there actually DP news somewhere in between the beating of this dead horse?

 

[GuestStar2004]

I wouldn't be shocked if marvel didn't touch ideas that already been done unless its MCU-efied to the point where the concept of it is totally different and likely more to suit the MCU then the source material.

Like Spidey whose part in homecoming was to acknowledge first and formost his part in the MCU and uncle tony with his iron spider-man suit and his own AI garvis and the villains getting their gadgets from something that happened in a previous avengers movie

 

[JP]

Genosha was confirmed 2 weeks ago in the EW spread lol

 

[Ordet]

seriously, dont you guys notice a troll when its in front of all of us?

and yeah, as psy said, dont understand why some of you keep entertaining him.

Only Robert D. Jr is the A-list of Marvel, yeah

I don't know how work in your bizarro world, but in real world, troll is the one who think, like you, that character like Jane Foster are main and reccurent in the franchising like Iron Man.

 

[Marvel united]

How can it be swiped away when they don't have it yet? And its just a location. Who knows what the actual story line is going to be.

They're doing the Mutant Paradise story, which is unfortunate because it's one of my favorite arcs for Magneto. It's a shame to see Kinberg using up so many resources in the last FoX-Men movie.

wasted and forced in, not just a great storyline, but an ICONIC storyline that didnt have Genosha on first place and that never needed Magneto. But here we are again. Thank u Kinberg for more Magneto getting screentime over other beloved x-men that you simply dont want us to enjoy.

Kinberg is just mashing together different unrelated things. Dark Phoenix might be as disjointed as FFINO

 

[Mr. Peanut]

It makes perfect sense, in the context of the films, for Magneto to be doing the whole Genosha thing at this point in his life. And like it or not he's one of the core main characters of this universe, so it makes sense to involve him and hopefully give him some final resolution.

And if Feige does decide to hold off on using Genosha as a result of this...why the hell does that matter so much? Marvel has SO MUCH content at their disposal that we'll be dead of old age before they can use it all. And just think logistically. You really think they'll go from mutants not existing in the MCU to mutants suddenly having their own country in the MCU?
No. That makes no sense. So Genosha's probably not even on the table any time soon.

How about you guys just trust that Feige has a good plan for the X-men that will result in movies you'll enjoy, and just forget the Foxverse exists? I think that would be better for your blood pressure.

 

[1627523]

it makes perfect sense, in the context of the films, for magneto to be doing the whole genosha thing at this point in his life. And like it or not he's one of the core main characters of this universe, so it makes sense to involve him and hopefully give him some final resolution.

And if feige does decide to hold off on using genosha as a result of this...why the hell does that matter so much? Marvel has so much content at their disposal that we'll be dead of old age before they can use it all. And just think logistically. You really think they'll go from mutants not existing in the mcu to mutants suddenly having their own country in the mcu?
No. That makes no sense. So genosha's probably not even on the table any time soon.

How about you guys just trust that feige has a good plan for the x-men that will result in movies you'll enjoy, and just forget the foxverse exists? I think that would be better for your blood pressure.

this. Freaking this. It already makes sense to introduce Genosha at this point. Its really the next step for Magneto character and we get to see a part of the x-men lore that hasnt been explored yet which is exciting to me,but i dont believe it will be the main focus of the movie because the Dark pheonix is the no.1 priority

 

[psylockolussus]

Only comicsmovie fans think they are great movie director.
Then if you think you have more decoding means than people who studied cinema...

How condescending.

I went to film school.

 

[rebellion]

How condescending.

I went to film school.

and still finds apocalypse to be 3rd best cbm villain of all time.

yeah, well... not every school is great.

 

[Ordet]

How condescending.

I went to film school.

I have a university degree in cinema, but that's not the point. You don't have to listen to me for this.

I was referring to professional critics, i was asking you to show me the evidence of your thesis: articles, rankings where i can read that Jenkins, Whedon and Russo are among Scott, Scorsese, Eastwood, Spielberg, Kitano, Refn (mentioning only the living and most famous ones)

 

[Abudefduf]

He can't provide you any evidence of that because there's none. No one with an ounce of common sense would waste their time comparing random directors with auteurs who have literally shaped the history of cinema (except for Refn, he hasn't shaped ****).

You're never going to get legendary filmmakers like the ones you mentioned to direct comic book movies. So you can either settle for peasants like Gunn, Jenkins, the Russos & Co. like the rest of us, or spend the rest of your life waiting for Spielberg to make a Guardians of the Galaxy movie.

 

[rebellion]

I have a university degree in cinema, but that's not the point. You don't have to listen to me for this.

I was referring to professional critics, i was asking you to show me the evidence of your thesis: articles, rankings where i can read that Jenkins, Whedon and Russo are among Scott, Scorsese, Eastwood, Spielberg, Kitano, Refn (mentioning only the living and most famous ones)

so now it's beside the point. when you're the one who brought it up.

also, why should i care what professional critics say? why should anyone care about where a director is ranked. like thats a guarantee for a good film. maybe it is, for a cinema snob.

aronofsky is often singled out as one of the greats. have you seen his treatment for batman year one? he was totally wrong for the material.

 

[AVEITWITHJAMON]

It makes perfect sense, in the context of the films, for Magneto to be doing the whole Genosha thing at this point in his life. And like it or not he's one of the core main characters of this universe, so it makes sense to involve him and hopefully give him some final resolution.

And if Feige does decide to hold off on using Genosha as a result of this...why the hell does that matter so much? Marvel has SO MUCH content at their disposal that we'll be dead of old age before they can use it all. And just think logistically. You really think they'll go from mutants not existing in the MCU to mutants suddenly having their own country in the MCU?
No. That makes no sense. So Genosha's probably not even on the table any time soon.

How about you guys just trust that Feige has a good plan for the X-men that will result in movies you'll enjoy, and just forget the Foxverse exists? I think that would be better for your blood pressure.

Absolutely great post, well done for using logic also.

 

[Zant]

Another amazing storyline swiped away from the MCU X-Men to be wasted in this movie

The MCU could do Mutant massacre.....oh wait that may be too dark for them and I am not ready for a comedic take on that.

They could do MOJO world. Mojo just screams MCU. Josh Gad could play MOJO.

 

[psylockolussus]

WelCivil War was pretty good and it wasn't a comedy show... You know there's an MCU X-Men thread in the Marvel films section, you should post those comments of yours there and let's see what response would you get there.

 

[Ryan1210]

Really? So they're gonna close this section after Gambit?

Man I hope we'll have a separate board lol.

 

[SumT]

WelCivil War was pretty good and it wasn't a comedy show... You know there's an MCU X-Men thread in the Marvel films section, you should post those comments of yours there and let's see what response would you get there.

Marvel haters are on the rise, it seems.

And should we start saying "Fox non-XMen fanatics" from this point too or what? t: