The Dark Knight Rises Catwoman Discussion Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would like a little flirty banter like this( not necessarily her trying to kill him, but the push and pull dynamic is great

[YT]P5Jbttrb3u4[/YT]
 
A rooftop chase scene, with fighting, gliding, grappling, falling from skyscrapers, etc. Something like this with some added gliding provided by nolan's magic cape.

[YT]UFxDNpyvVko[/YT]
I would love that, but I just can't see it happening, mainly because of Catwoman not having the equipment Batman has. I doubt Nolan would have her using a whip to get around places like she does on there and in the comics. Maybe she could use a grappling hook as well, but even then, I can't see him having her doing some of the more interesting stunts on there. It's one thing to jump from the top of a skyscraper when you have a magic cape, but it's quite another to do that when you don't have any form of flying or gliding device on you.
 
I would love that, but I just can't see it happening, mainly because of Catwoman not having the equipment Batman has. I doubt Nolan would have her using a whip to get around places like she does on there and in the comics. Maybe she could use a grappling hook as well, but even then, I can't see him having her doing some of the more interesting stunts on there.
Not even his batman can do that. Unless they give him a new grapple gun that also pulls the line, there is no way he can be this agile while trying to put the line in his belt mechanism. Its too clunky.

But Catwoman could have the same tech if not steal it from him.
It's one thing to jump from the top of a skyscraper when you have a magic cape, but it's quite another to do that when you don't have any form of flying or gliding device on you.
And that's why i always ask for some little movie magic so that Batman will feel lighter on his feet. He moves like Kickass or you and me, ergo too realistically, and i would prefer BTAS-like boosted abilities. Faster, more agile, making longer jumps, etc.
 
Last edited:
I really don't see this at all. You can say what you want about the villains, but Batman himself certainly has a vested interest in keeping his identity secret, and yet that doesn't seem to stop him from chatting it up with criminals, cops, whoever will listen! :oldrazz: He sat down, face to face, in harsh lighting, with a man he thought wanted to kill him.

These masked characters always end up talking to one another, voices and secret identities be damned. It's part of the suspension of disbelief inherent in superhero stories. And Nolan doesn't seem concerned with shying away from that, so I highly doubt he'd change that approach when it comes to two characters whose costumed interplay is so crucial to their relationship.
Eh, I can't say I could ever get behind this, "it's part of the suspension of disbelief with superhero movies" stance. That's one flimsy argument, imo. It's one thing to sit and talk to the Joker in an interrogation room when he has urgent info you need. Or to try and talk down Two-Face when he's holding a hostage. It's a whole other thing to stop and flirt with a catburglar whose sole objective is to evade you and escape with her score. Maybe she'd spout a few things at him in the pursuit, but I doubt they'd manage much more than that.

And I'm definitely not a fan of the videos posted above. I feel like that kind of stuff is exactly where the "Catwoman's too cheesy/unrealistic for this series" arguments come from. And in those cases, they'd be right, imo.
 
Eh, I can't say I could ever get behind this, "it's part of the suspension of disbelief with superhero movies" stance. That's one flimsy argument, imo. It's one thing to sit and talk to the Joker in an interrogation room when he has urgent info you need. Or to try and talk down Two-Face when he's holding a hostage. It's a whole other thing to stop and flirt with a catburglar whose sole objective is to evade you and escape with her score. Maybe she'd spout a few things at him in the pursuit, but I doubt they'd manage much more than that.

And I'm definitely not a fan of the videos posted above. I feel like that kind of stuff is exactly where the "Catwoman's too cheesy/unrealistic for this series" arguments come from. And in those cases, they'd be right, imo.

I'm not talking long philisophical debates, but turning it into a silent film isn't the answer either. Catwoman and Batman flirt. They exchange repartee. It's really that simple.

I can't see this being an issue if we weren't talking about an actress who isn't good at American accents. That's the only reason why, all of a sudden, Batman and Catwoman don't exchange dialogue.
 
Not even his batman can do that. Unless they give him a new grapple gun that also pulls the line, there is no way he can be this agile while trying to put the line in his belt mechanism. Its too clunky.
True.
But Catwoman could have the same tech if not steal it from him. And that's why i always ask for some little movie magic so that Batman will feel lighter on his feet. He moves like Kickass or you and me, ergo too realistically, and i would prefer BTAS-like boosted abilities. Faster, more agile, making longer jumps, etc.
And there's no reason why he shouldn't be able to do all that. If he can grapple a speeding monorail without his arms being ripped off, or fall onto a car (while holding Rachel, no less) and walk away without a scratch, a few slightly exaggerated stunts shouldn't be out of the question. He doesn't have to do acrobatics like Spider-Man, but it wouldn't hurt him to move like, y'know, Batman. :o
 
I'm not talking long philisophical debates, but turning it into a silent film isn't the answer either. Catwoman and Batman flirt. They exchange repartee. It's really that simple.

I can't see this being an issue if we weren't talking about an actress who isn't good at American accents. That's the only reason why, all of a sudden, Batman and Catwoman don't exchange dialogue.
Actually, I was done with accent debate. I'm just talking in general - I expect the Batman/Catwoman encounters to be brief and minimal, probably just a couple of rooftop action sequences. After all, IF Catwoman is in, the buzz is that she won't even be a villain, and I would assume that most of Batman's screentime will likely be used to deal with his main problem - whoever the actual villain is. So I personally find it most likely that Bruce/Selina will make up the majority of Selina/Catwoman's screentime. Just based on how Nolan has handled all the meaty actor/character interaction (minus the Joker) in the past.
 
True.
And there's no reason why he shouldn't be able to do all that. If he can grapple a speeding monorail without his arms being ripped off, or fall onto a car (while holding Rachel, no less) and walk away without a scratch, a few slightly exaggerated stunts shouldn't be out of the question. He doesn't have to do acrobatics like Spider-Man, but it wouldn't hurt him to move like, y'know, Batman. :o
I agree.

As for the train thing, i think his harness has some give so that it wont snap. In Batgirl Year One, Batman cuts her rope while Robin saves her because it was a rope used for climbing and would have ripped her arms off. They later give her proper bat ropes. :cwink:
Actually, I was done with accent debate. I'm just talking in general - I expect the Batman/Catwoman encounters to be brief and minimal, probably just a couple of rooftop action sequences. After all, IF Catwoman is in, the buzz is that she won't even be a villain, and I would assume that most of Batman's screentime will likely be used to deal with his main problem - whoever the actual villain is. So I personally find it most likely that Bruce/Selina will make up the majority of Selina/Catwoman's screentime. Just based on how Nolan has handled all the meaty actor/character interaction (minus the Joker) in the past.
Catwoman with no flirting and no banter? Yeah i can see Nolan being serious and no fun enough to do that. :csad:

It will be glorious[BLACKOUT]ly boring.[/BLACKOUT]
 
Actually, I was done with accent debate. I'm just talking in general - I expect the Batman/Catwoman encounters to be brief and minimal, probably just a couple of rooftop action sequences. After all, IF Catwoman is in, the buzz is that she won't even be a villain, and I would assume that most of Batman's screentime will likely be used to deal with his main problem - whoever the actual villain is. So I personally find it most likely that Bruce/Selina will make up the majority of Selina/Catwoman's screentime. Just based on how Nolan has handled all the meaty actor/character interaction (minus the Joker) in the past.

I dunno about that, I really think screen time between alter egos has gotta be closer to 50-50.
 
I would like a little flirty banter like this( not necessarily her trying to kill him, but the push and pull dynamic is great

[YT]P5Jbttrb3u4[/YT]

OK, I've never seen this show, and don't kill me but I can't believe GA's dialogue and voice. He sounds like he could be Robin. Can that be comic-referenced? And that Batman-Catwoman chat-fight had some serious S&M undertones. I thought this show was for kids? :o
 
I'm pretty sure I want olivia wilde as catwoman more than any actress on the short list. She has a striking beauty that none of the others have, and considerable acting ability. She also has a great build for the suit, a build that only knightly could rival.
 
I would love that, but I just can't see it happening, mainly because of Catwoman not having the equipment Batman has. I doubt Nolan would have her using a whip to get around places like she does on there and in the comics. Maybe she could use a grappling hook as well, but even then, I can't see him having her doing some of the more interesting stunts on there. It's one thing to jump from the top of a skyscraper when you have a magic cape, but it's quite another to do that when you don't have any form of flying or gliding device on you.

Knowing Nolan's approach, I highly doubt he will give us a Catwoman that wears only a tight leather suit that serves absolutely no purpose like Pfeifer's suit in BR. If the batsuit in TDK is anything to go by and Catwoman is given something similar then she'll probably have state of the art tech and if she is a burglar of the finest museums in Gotham then she will definitely need it.

Instead of a sleek non-functioning catsuit with heels like in BR, I imagine a rendition of Catwoman by Nolan would have a utility belt, boots, sonar goggles, and maybe even a backpack to keep more instruments in. Of course the whip would be present too. Think the high tech Catwoman of the comics.
 
Catwoman with no flirting and no banter? Yeah i can see Nolan being serious and no fun enough to do that. :csad:
Nolan being too serious and/or not having enough fun is seriously one of the dumbest things I've read on this site.
 
OK, I've never seen this show, and don't kill me but I can't believe GA's dialogue and voice. He sounds like he could be Robin. Can that be comic-referenced? And that Batman-Catwoman chat-fight had some serious S&M undertones. I thought this show was for kids? :o
You aint seen nothing yet. Just watch this:

[YT]fAFP0IoMfsA[/YT]
 
I agree.

As for the train thing, i think his harness has some give so that it wont snap. In Batgirl Year One, Batman cuts her rope while Robin saves her because it was a rope used for climbing and would have ripped her arms off. They later give her proper bat ropes. :cwink:Catwoman with no flirting and no banter? Yeah i can see Nolan being serious and no fun enough to do that. :csad:

It will be glorious[BLACKOUT]ly boring.[/BLACKOUT]
Did you miss the part where I said I thought the flirting would mostly be between Bruce/Selina, and not absent from the film entirely?
 
I think he enjoys any opening to jab at Nolan's lacking qualities. Even if he has to force it.
 
Did you miss the part where I said I thought the flirting would mostly be between Bruce/Selina, and not absent from the film entirely?
But Bruce and Selina come second. Its always about the thrills of stealing, running from Batman, jumping off rooftops, etc. And for Batman its always the allure of a woman in a catsuit, breaking the law, seeking his attention, playing with his emotions. She isnt just another woman for Bruce. She is Catwoman, and catwoman works best with Batman.
I think he enjoys any opening to jab at Nolan's lacking qualities. Even if he has to force it.
Eh... maybe.... :awesome:
 
Last edited:
I dunno about that, I really think screen time between alter egos has gotta be closer to 50-50.
Eh, I disagree there. But this is all just pointless speculation anyway, considering we don't even know she's in the film yet. But to clarify my stance, I think Catwoman will see plenty of screen-time and Batman will see plenty of screen-time, I'm just not convinced much of that screen-time will be together, in-costumes. That is, I'm betting most of their joint screen-time will be as Bruce/Selina. So screentime-wise, I do agree that the ratio between them and their alter-egos will probably be about 50/50, it's just how much of that will be Batman/Catwoman together that I'm questioning. Also, if they ARE going with the "Catwoman's taking up the mantle of Batman while he's on the run" angle, then she may have her own subplot going on that wouldn't cross paths with Batman's 'till he's finally able to confront her later in the film. Who knows.
 
Did you miss the part where I said I thought the flirting would mostly be between Bruce/Selina, and not absent from the film entirely?

That's not the Batman/Catwoman relationship, though.

What makes their relationship unique is that it's IN COSTUME. That's where the tension comes from, the sexuality, the allure.

You're writing a movie in your head that simply isn't supported by the characters as we know them.
 
But Bruce and Selina come second. Its always about the thrills of stealing, running from Batman, jumping off rooftops, etc. And for Batman its always the allure of a woman in a catsuit, breaking the law, seeking his attention, playing with his emotions. She isnt just another woman for Bruce. She is Catwoman, and catwoman works best with Batman.Eh... maybe.... :awesome:
Sorry, that's not the Catwoman I've read. :csad:

For the record, I'm basing all of this on Brubaker's Catwoman, as those are the only Catwoman stories I've read. And in those, she actually has a mission and a passion for the people of Gotham and finds a kindred spirit in Bruce/Batman, even when they don't see eye to eye. And it's Selina just as much as it's Catwoman.

To say that what makes her unique is that their interactions are in-costume really cheapens their connection, imo.
 
Last edited:
The banter between the two in-costume, even in the comics, is incredibly lopsided. Catwoman spearheads the conversations and many times does all the talking herself. If we're talking numbers it's came off to me more of as 70-30 rather than 50-50.

Also there's only so many conversations they can have with one another. I'm not usually one to halt creativity, but you can't really work too much interesting back-and-forth dialog with a relationship that thrives on the chase.
 
And while I'm spouting unpopular opinions, I'll add that I'd like to see them both learn each others' identities (maybe Bruce through detective work, and her through some kind of "tell" from one of their in-costume encounters) before the 3rd act of the film. Once that happens, ya'll can get all the in-costume banter you want without sending my suspension-of-disbelief into overdrive. :woot:

Also there's only so many conversations they can have with one another. I'm not usually one to halt creativity, but you can't really work too much interesting back-and-forth dialog with a relationship that thrives on the chase.
See, this is what I don't get. Even if they veer closer to the BTAS version, Selina is at first dismissive toward Bruce Wayne for wasting his wealth when he could be helping. She's a very politically-driven individual, and very passionate about her ideals. Which gives Bruce/Selina plenty to talk about, as we know Bruce Wayne's playboy persona is a facade - and here's one person from his socialite world that hates it the same way he does, yet he doesn't want to give himself away. If I were a writer, that dynamic would be SO fun to play with. Maybe she's the one who pushes him toward the "Bruce Wayne: Philanthropist" image, idk. There's just so much interesting interaction and character development to be had there, imo. You know Nolan loves to have his debates about the state of Gotham and human nature - Selina would totally be the perfect vessel for him to do that with this time around.
 
Last edited:
OK, I've never seen this show

Rectify this, now!

It's an incredibly clever show disguised as a kid's cartoon. Some episodes are just simple fun, but others (especially Bat-Mite episodes!) are literally master classes in Batman mythology. Filled to the brim with in-jokes and easter eggs that only hardcore Batman fans would pick up on.
 
Sorry, that's not the Catwoman I've read. :csad:

For the record, I'm basing all of this on Brubaker's Catwoman, as those are the only Catwoman stories I've read. And in those, she actually has a mission and a passion for the people of Gotham and finds a kindred spirit in Bruce/Batman, even when they don't see eye to eye. And it's Selina just as much as it's Catwoman.

To say that what makes her unique is that their interactions are in-costume really cheapens their connection, imo.

You have to understand though that the Brubaker series features a long-established Catwoman whose history with Batman is already well-trodden ground. What we've been talking about here mostly are those "first dates," where the mystique and the moral conflicts between them is at its height.

At this point, Bats and Selina are practically like an old married couple, heh.

I wasn't aware that you were only familar with her through the solo series; that explains the disconnect.

You should check out The Long Halloween. Given Nolan's affection for the book, it might be a good place to start to get an idea of what kind of Catwoman Nolan would use.

And if you love the relationship between Bruce and Selina, read Paul Dini's Heart of Hush. Bruce's confession at the end will make you cry! (I did :o)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
201,667
Messages
22,007,801
Members
45,803
Latest member
dontbitemespid
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"