Contest Of Marvels II Discussion Thread

[JewishHobbit]

Wow, can't believe I left him off the last time. Oh well, I'm glad to have him in this one.

And Chtylock sounds interesting (though I have no idea how to pronounce his name)

 

[POWdER-man]

Spider-Man

Keep:

Black Cat
Calypso
Cardiac
Carnage
Carrion
Demogoblin
Doctor Octopus
Doppleganger
Electro
Ezekial
Fusion
Green Goblin (Norman)
Hobgoblin (Kingsley)
Hydroman
Jack O-Lantern
Kaine
Kraven the Hunter
Lady Doc Ock
Lizard
Mysterio
Puma
Rhino
Sandman
Scarlet Spider
Scorpion
Shathra
Shocker
Shriek
Spidercide
Spider-Girl
Spider-man (red & blue of course)
Tarantula
Tri-Sentinel
Venom (Brock)
Vermin
Vulture

Drop:

Chameleon
Molten Man
Green Goblin (Harry) -
Hammerhead
Hobgoblin - (Macendale)
The Rose (Fisk)
Midnight
Jackle
Tombstone
Scrier
Judas Traveler (limited psionic powers nothing really else)


Potentials:


Armada
Basilist
Joystick
Crown
Headsman
Lightmaster
Morlun
Scorcher
Scream
Shadrac
Styx
Stone
Toxin
Wraith

 

[Phaedrus45]

Oh, yeah..I agree. Drop Judas Traveler

 

[Johnny Blaze]

The Answer would be a sweet pickup for someone if he's allowed in.

 

[Trigger]

Is there really any differance between GG(Harry) and GG (Norman)?

 

[POWdER-man]

I dropped the The Answer and Chtylok from my potentials. Looking back on their bio, it stated the chtylok only appeared in a 3 part story and there is very little known about him/her...and the Answer seems like a B Character but I could see how that his powers could easily be abused since "he has the answer" to anything......

 

[JewishHobbit]

Is there really any differance between GG(Harry) and GG (Norman)?

Power-wise no... but Harry's more reluctant to hurt anyone whereas Norman is ruthless.

 

[POWdER-man]

Do you want to finalize your lists so I will have a better idea which ones you want to keep and get rid of and bring in...

 

[POWdER-man]

Power-wise no... but Harry's more reluctant to hurt anyone whereas Norman is ruthless.

Actually I thought (for strength and speed) Harry wasn't as powerful as Norman. As for cunning and inteligence I would give it easily to Norman as well. Harry had more of a battle with his inner demons, while Norman open armed accepted it.

Keep in mind I am more referring to the "classic" Norman.

 

[JewishHobbit]

Actually I thought (for strength and speed) Harry wasn't as powerful as Norman. As for cunning and inteligence I would give it easily to Norman as well. Harry had more of a battle with his inner demons, while Norman open armed accepted it.

Keep in mind I am more referring to the "classic" Norman.

After he took the formula Harry was just as much a physical threat as Norman... but the fact that he wrestles with his insanity while Norman embraces it makes Norman a more deadly character.

Keep:

Black Cat
Calypso
Cardiac
Carnage
Carrion
Demogoblin
Doctor Octopus
Doppleganger
Electro
Ezekial
Fusion II I forget his real name, but there's been two
Green Goblin (Norman)
Hobgoblin (Kingsley)
Hydroman
Jack O-Lantern
Kaine
Kraven the Hunter
Lady Doc Ock
Lizard
Mysterio
Puma
Rhino
Sandman
Scarlet Spider
Scorpion
Shathra
Shocker
Shriek
Spidercide
Spider-Girl
Spider-man (red & blue)
Tarantula
Tri-Sentinel
Venom (Brock)
Vermin
Vulture

Drop:

Chameleon
Molten Man
Green Goblin (Harry)
Hammerhead
Hobgoblin (Macendale)
The Rose (Fisk)
Midnight
Jackle
Tombstone
Scrier
Judas Traveler


Potentials:

The Answer
Armada
Basilist
Joystick If not under the Thunderbolts section
Crown
Headsman
Lightmaster
Man-Wolf
Morlun
Scorcher
Scream
Shadrac
Toxin
Wraith Need to specify as their was an X-Man named Wraith too

 

[POWdER-man]

Spider-Man

Keep:

172.Black Cat
173.Calypso
174.Cardiac
175.Carnage
176.Carrion
177.Demogoblin
178.Doctor Octopus
179.Doppleganger
180.Electro
181.Ezekial
182.Fusion
183.Green Goblin (Norman)
184.Hobgoblin (Kingsley)
185.Hydroman
186.Jack O-Lantern
187.Kaine
188.Kraven the Hunter
189.Lady Doc Ock
190.Lizard
191.Mysterio
192.Puma
193.Rhino
194.Sandman
195.Scarlet Spider
196.Scorpion
197.Shathra
198.Shocker
199.Shriek
200.Spidercide
201.Spider-Girl
202.Spiderman (red&blue)
203.Tarantula
204.Tri-sentinel
205.Venom (Brock)
206.Vermin
207.Vulture

Drop

46.Chameleon
47.Green Goblin (Harry)
48.Hammerhead
49.Hobgoblin (Macendale)
50.Judas Traveler
51.The Rose (Fisk)
52.Midnight
53.Molten Man
54.Jackel
55.Tombstone
56.Scrier

Potentials:

65.The Answer
66.Armada
67.Basilist
68.Crown
69.Headsman
70.Lightmaster
71.Man-Wolf
72.Morlun (Curious....but does he even have any weaknesses? The two times he has (supposedly) died, once he abosrbed radioactive energy and the second he was stung and bit by the transformation of SM (ugh). )
73.Scorcher
74.Scream
75.Shadrac
76.Toxin
77.Wraith

Joystick was under Thunderbolts..

 

[POWdER-man]

Thor

Absorbing Man
Baldur
Beta Ray Bill
Bloodaxe
Desak
Durok the Demolisher
Enchantress
Fandral
Fenris
Heimdall
Hogun
Kurse
Loki
Sif
Thor
Thunderstrike
Titania
Ulik
Valkyrie
Vidar
Volstagg

 

[Johnny Blaze]

Thor

Absorbing Man
Baldur
Beta Ray Bill
Bloodaxe
Desak
Durok the Demolisher
Enchantress
Fandral
Fenris
Heimdall
Hogun
Kurse
Loki
Sif
Thor
Thunderstrike
Titania
Ulik
Valkyrie
Vidar
Volstagg

It's Fandral, not Fanfral. And you should add the Gray Gargoyle to the Thor list as a possibility.

 

[POWdER-man]

Hmmm yeah typo....and Grey Gargoyle is already under the F4 section. (had him last year)

http://www.immortalthor.net/

 

[Johnny Blaze]

Hmmm yeah typo....and Grey Gargoyle is already under the F4 section. (had him last year)

http://www.immortalthor.net/

Well then...carry on.

 

[Trigger]

Thor

Absorbing Man
Baldur
Beta Ray Bill
Bloodaxe
Desak
Durok the Demolisher
Enchantress
Fandral
Fenris
Heimdall
Hogun
Kurse
Loki
Thor
Thunderstrike
Titania
Ulik
Valkyrie
Vidar

Drop

Volstagg-Everyone has that one character that just don't like. Volstagg is mine
Sif- Its been awhile since I've read anything with her in it, but does she have any special abilities? Otherwise, I see her as just being cannon fodder for the earlier rounds.

LOL, I've been in and out with the voting thing due to some responsibilities popping up at home. (babysitting newborns, getting a summer job, dumping guys )

 

[POWdER-man]

Thor

Absorbing Man
Baldur
Beta Ray Bill
Bloodaxe
Desak
Durok the Demolisher
Enchantress
Fandral
Fenris
Heimdall
Hogun
Kurse
Loki
Thor
Thunderstrike
Titania
Ulik
Valkyrie
Vidar

Drop

Volstagg-Everyone has that one character that just don't like. Volstagg is mine
Sif- Its been awhile since I've read anything with her in it, but does she have any special abilities? Otherwise, I see her as just being cannon fodder for the earlier rounds.

Powers: Sif possesses the conventional attributes of an Asgardian women ("goddess"). Like all Asgardians, she is extremely long-lived (although not immortal like the Olympians), superhumanly strong (the average Asgardian female can lift about 25 tons; Sif can lift 30 tons) immune to all diseases, and resistant to conventional injury. (Asgardian flesh and bone is about 3 times as dense as similar human tissue, contributing to all Asgardians' superhuman strength and weight.) Sif's Asgardian metabolism gives her far greater than human endurance during all physical activities. Sif has extensive training in unarmed combat as well as swordsmanship. Her natural fighting ability is only surpassed among Asgardian women by Brunnhilda the Valkyrie.
Personal Weaponry: Sif wields a special sword enchanted by Odin to enable her to "cleave" passageways between dimensions (primarily Asgard and Earth) by a special pattern of swinging motions.

LOL, I've been in and out with the voting thing due to some responsibilities popping up at home. (babysitting newborns, getting a summer job, dumping guys )

Don't worry about it... But breaking hearts.......

 

[Trigger]

Yep, I'm a heartbreaker


Thor

Absorbing Man
Baldur
Beta Ray Bill
Bloodaxe
Desak
Durok the Demolisher
Enchantress
Fandral
Fenris
Heimdall
Hogun
Kurse
Loki
Thor
Thunderstrike
Titania
Ulik
Valkyrie
Vidar
Sif

Drop

Volstagg

Okay updated my list

 

[Phaedrus45]

http://www.immortalthor.net/

 

[POWdER-man]

http://www.immortalthor.net/

Hmmm yeah typo....and Grey Gargoyle is already under the F4 section. (had him last year)

http://www.immortalthor.net/

You blind old man...

 

[POWdER-man]

Yep, I'm a heartbreaker

And I believed you when you told me it wasn't me...

 

[Phaedrus45]

You blind old man...

DOH!

It's too early over here....I even get to miss work.

Anyway, I'll get back to my picks later. There are quite a few characters to possibly put in potential; but, the question is how powerful these guys are.

 

[JewishHobbit]

I was just going to put Desak on Too Uber list... but then I thought about it and I don't think he is. He's majorly Uber against Gods... but when not up against a God he doesn't have that immunity.. he's just a tough dude right? I mean, can't the Punisher take him out with a bullet to the brain?

 

[Trigger]

And I believed you when you told me it wasn't me...

Well, you see........... *runs into a closet*

On-Topic: I believe the hobbit's right. I think Desak does have form of natural resistance to injury, but agaisnt gods he's invulnerable.

 

[Johnny Blaze]

I was just going to put Desak on Too Uber list... but then I thought about it and I don't think he is. He's majorly Uber against Gods... but when not up against a God he doesn't have that immunity.. he's just a tough dude right? I mean, can't the Punisher take him out with a bullet to the brain?

No, the Punisher isn't going to take him down with a bullet to the brain. The Punisher would get wrecked by Desak. Against gods, he's damn near unbeatable (though he was killed twice by Thor), but, against other characters without divine powers, he's a top tier bruiser and warrior with energy projection powers, and, arguably, minor telekinesis.
He should definitely be allowed in.