Most definitely.
I know it must seem like it from the outside looking in at this thread, but it really isn't just about his physical appearance
The reason that he is so entrancing is his charisma. He is the epitome of class in every interview, has a subtle, intelligent sense of humour and has a raw sexual magnetism that he can crank up (as seen in the Tudors), to the point of having a bit of 'bad boy' about him as well.
Routh has none of that. He's an attractive man, sure. You could never call him ugly, and I know I thought he was beautiful when he was first call and all the way through SR.
But I was a lot younger then. I'm not into that kind of thing anymore. I'm into manly sexy beasts!