The Dark Knight Rises TDKR SPOILERS (read at your own risk) - Part 2

[Schlosser85]

There are few people who look sillier than those who judge a movie they haven't seen.

 

[thelostwayne]

garretthethief could you answer this one, please

Spoiler

What did Bruce and Talia, do to escape from the prison? why is the jump impossible? and how they did it?

 

[garretthethief]

about the chanting:

Spoiler

it means rise.the prisoners in the pit use the chant whenever someone attempt to climb out of the pit.

the courtroom scene:

Spoiler

scarecrow was there as the judge, giving out sentences. death or exile, which is being forced to walk on thin ice.

 

[Bat]

Yes I was here when it was Spider-man hype. Whatever, when I see a guy calling people "newbs" and they have a join date of 2011. I have to laugh. If you changed screen names then fine.

Very good. You can have a cookie now. That would be over 10 years I've been around here.

I can have an opinion on who these characters are, and I can have that opinion because it was in a different medium before. Sure there are going to be changes.

Again here we are talking about the ending not the whole film. I'm still seeing the film regardless.

Of course you can have an opinion. Just don't needlessly bash the ending when you have no idea how it plays out on screen. You don't, even if you like to think you do. Spewing it out as fact is when it gets annoying.

 

[Commodore]

Let's all complain the film sucks and demand refunds because we don't like what we're hearing and whine like two year olds instead of waiting two more days to see it.

The only whining two year old I see in this thread is you. You have to resort to hyperbole to make your point because you don't have a point. Stop complaining about people complaining. Anyone on here who has a qualm about the film has a right to express his/her opinion.

If it spoils the film for you to hear that not everyone is thrilled about it and not everyone considers TDKR a masterpiece then please be merciful and go elsewhere like you promised us you would.

This thread is for spoilers discussion; you aren't adding anything to the conversation when you say "Oh, you haven't seen it yet. You can't judge it." If you want to defend an aspect of the film that someone is criticizing, go ahead, but we've heard enough to start making our opinions. If seeing the film changes our minds, that's fine. Your belly-aching isn't going to.

 

[Bat]

The only whining two year old I see in this thread is you. You have to resort to hyperbole to make your point because you don't have a point. Stop complaining about people complaining. Anyone on here who has a qualm about the film has a right to express his/her opinion.

If it spoils the film for you to hear that not everyone is thrilled about it and not everyone considers TDKR a masterpiece then please be merciful and go elsewhere like you promised us you would.

This thread is for spoilers discussion; you aren't adding anything to the conversation when you say "Oh, you haven't seen it yet. You can't judge it." If you want to defend an aspect of the film that someone is criticizing, go ahead, but we've heard enough to start making our opinions. If seeing the film changes our minds, that's fine. Your belly-aching isn't going to.

Basically you are just whining. This isn't the whining thread. It's the spoilers thread. We don't care about your opinion on something you haven't seen.

Take it to the general discussion if you want to ***** further. Thanks.

 

[HopeOfTheFuture]

the courtroom scene:

Spoiler

scarecrow was there as the judge, giving out sentences. death or exile, which is being forced to walk on thin ice.

Thanks, can you tell me what

Spoiler

Bane is doing there? And does he kill Scarecrow like someone said a while ago?

 

[Spuzz]

Um here's one noob saying please shut tup guys. Take it to PMs or something

 

[Commodore]

Basically you are just whining. This isn't the whining thread. It's the spoilers thread. We don't care about your opinion on something you haven't seen.
Take it to the general discussion if you want to ***** further. Thanks.

I'm not whining about anything. Go back and read my posts (if you're capable of doing so). The only thing I have griped about is the [BLACKOUT]"Robin" reveal[/BLACKOUT], and that's probably not something that my opinion will change about upon seeing the film, since my complaint is that it's just shoehorning the character in there, just namedropping. An easter egg. It doesn't even make sense: [blackout]Robin is a moniker, not his given name. If the films introduced a character named "Oswald Penguin Cobblepot" none of us would be pleased either.[/blackout] And in every post that I've complained about it, I've said "maybe my mind will change when I see the film."

If you want to spend two pages griping about what people are saying, then at least make sure that you're arguing about something that's actually being said by the people you're targeting.

I don't care about your opinion. Since you won't leave like you promised a few pages back, I will simply ignore you. I'd suggest the rest of the people here who actually want to have a conversation about the film do the same, since you don't have anything to bring to the table.

Um here's one noob saying please shut tup guys. Take it to PMs or something

I'm sorry that I stooped to his level to respond to him, but this guy has been trying to cause trouble for several pages now. First he says that anyone who dares to find a flaw in the film is a noob, then he starts attacking me and Tony Stark individually.

 

[garretthethief]

thelostwayne, i consider it is a great moment of cinematic carthasis regarding bruce, the bald child and the pit so i do not want to spoil it here.

HopeOfTheFuture bane in the courtroom

Spoiler

is just a spectator. and no he did not kill scarecow unless i am mistaken.

 

[Commodore]

HopeOfTheFuture bane in the courtroom

Spoiler

is just a spectator. and no he did not kill scarecow unless i am mistaken.

Spoiler

Is he just a spectator in the sense that Scarecrow and other prisoners are in charge of the kangaroo court, or is he in charge but just standing in the background? It's unclear just how much of a despot Bane after the takeover of Gotham.

 

[Bat]

I'm sorry that I stooped to his level to respond to him, but this guy has been trying to cause trouble for several pages now. First he says that anyone who dares to find a flaw in the film is a noob, then he starts attacking me and Tony Stark individually.

 

[HopeOfTheFuture]

HopeOfTheFuture bane in the courtroom

Spoiler

is just a spectator. and no he did not kill scarecow unless i am mistaken.

Thanks Garreth

thelostwayne, i consider it is a great moment of cinematic carthasis regarding bruce, the bald child and the pit so i do not want to spoil it here.

Damn, now you really got me curious. I need to know! ;-)

 

[stormshadow]

Can anybody please post just a list of spoilers! At the beginning of this thread or a sticky somewhere. Who dies, the ending, leg breaks, back breaks, anything. Some of us just need a complete list, with no opinions, no questions, not attacks.

Thank you

I pretty much have most of it figured out, but it would be great if someone would be kind enough to list this. The thread has gotten out of hand with the pissing contest. Getting hard to thumb through for info. Thanks in advance.

 

[KnighttimeRises]

hey garretthethief, in your opinion do you think the bat voice was better? and was Bale in better shape than the previous Batman movie?

 

[garretthethief]

KnighttimeRises i think the bat voice is somewhere between begins and dark knight. fwiw i do not have a problem with the bat voice in tdk, even though sometimes it is a bit over the top. bale is bigger here than tdk, though i was sitting on the side and quite close to the liemax screen so i am not certain about this.

 

[Commodore]

Works fine for me... Try this post link then: http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?p=23853165&highlight=#post23853165

Stormshadow and others who want spoilers lists, that link above should take you to one of user 3-D's compilations of Name that movie's posts.

 

[garretthethief]

Commodore bane in the courtroom

Spoiler

just a spectator in the background

 

[KnighttimeRises]

thanks garretthethief. So the voice in TDKR isn't as over the top as TDK? If thats the case then I'm happy. One more question, are the fight scenes between Batman and Bane short or are is it a good length of a fight? And was the fights awesome?

 

[garretthethief]

KnighttimeRises the first fight between bane and batman

Spoiler

it is absolutely brutal. i would describe it as jaw-dropping.

the second time they fight

Spoiler

it is shorter and not as wow but i think it is because to trick us into thinking batman got the upper hand and

to lead to the betrayal of

Spoiler

miranda tate.

but please keep your expectation in check, or else i m afraid you will end up like me

 

[HopeOfTheFuture]

I found these spoilers pics, scans of the trilogy artbook. I couldn't find any rule if it was allowed to post these (if not, please remove the pics)

Spoiler

Young Talia

Courtroom / Scarecrow

Batman destroys Bane's mask

 

[getheftystrong]

hi garetthethief, were there any other fight scenes of Batman besides the Bane one and is it true that theres barely any Batman compared to the other films? Also did Bale sound over the top like TDK or toned down? Those will only be my questions

 

[garretthethief]

were there any other fight scenes of Batman besides the Bane one - yeah bane's thug
did Bale sound over the top like TDK or toned down - toned down
is it true that theres barely any Batman compared to the other films? - it's hard to answer as i could not count the minutes batman on screen.
but yeah it feels like less than begins.

 

[getheftystrong]

I dont know if you remember this garretthetheif but when Batman yells

Spoiler

at Bane about the detonator, how does he sound? is it over the top?

 

[garretthethief]

getheftystrong did he yell? i don't remember this part very well. i can answer you after i watch it again tomorrow 19th 12 afternoon hong kong time.