I have to start with “Gotham” because I’m talking to you just after the episode aired where it looks like Jeremiah’s a goner. What does this mean for your character?
A: As was revealed in (the most current) episode, he does
not die — even though he fakes his death as a little bit of a psychological play. So the next episode we’ll see what he’s up to and his grand scheme, which is really fun. Now we’re sort of getting the actual mechanisms in place that will set up the rest of the season for Jeremiah.
Q: There was a recap that made the hilarious observation that as Jeremiah was being stabbed, Selina got “extra stabby” when you started bantering with her as she was trying to kill you. That’s emblematic of the show: Dark, funny, over-the-top, super dramatic. Is that what initially drew you to the show?
A: When I was offered the role of Jerome I hadn’t really heard of it, I think it had just started airing, so I said, “Send over the script, it sounds interesting and I like Batman stuff.”
I was coming out of an audition for something else when I stopped to look at the script in the car and when I got to that last interrogation scene I was like: OK, I know exactly what this is! That scene is a Joker reference and it’s such a fun power play, that shift in dynamic where he owns the room.
And I called my agent and my manager right then and was like, “Forget about this audition I just went on, don’t worry about it — I want to do
this. This is awesome.” So I did that one episode. And I didn’t know if I was going to be back to do more.
Cameron Monaghan as the man who would become The Joker in "Gotham." (Fox)
Q: For all you knew, it could have been a one-off.
A: I’m pretty sure it originally was planned to be just a one-off. But that scene ended up going kind of viral and people really responded to it.
Q: I think that happened in part because the Joker is such an iconic character, and since “Gotham” is really the origin story of Batman and all the characters in his world, how fun to see the hint of what’s to come with the Joker.
A: Absolutely. He’s considered one of the greatest villains of the 20th and 21st centuries and for very good reason. He’s one of the most iconic antagonists in all of American fiction.
I think initially the plan for “Gotham” was to dance around that a little bit more. They were going to just have a lot of different hints of who was going to end up becoming “this” but never really getting to into it. But the fans reacted strongly and everyone desires this story. If you’re going to tell a story that’s ancillary or surrounding Batman, you kind of have to explore something with the Joker as well.
I think that’s part of the fun. It’s such a convoluted way to tell the story and I think that actually ends up kind of working for what the Joker is. The Joker’s background should be confusing and absurd and weird and ridiculous. If any of the citizens of Gotham were trying to piece together what the hell has been happening with this guy, it would be like: Wait,
what’s going on?!
Q: So first you were playing Jerome. Then it was his twin brother Jeremiah. What are the chances there’s a third brother named Jerald?
A: There’s no third brother! But there is a third
permutation of the character, I guess you could say.
Cameron Monaghan on "Gotham." (Fox)
For me, it’s a logical next step and it kind of encapsulates the different dynamics of all these different variations. Even with Jerome, he had so many levels of reinvention, and then with Jeremiah too, he’s reinvented himself a few times. And what we see in this final third version is the mixing pot of everything coming together — but now with this added spice of the insanity thrown on top of it. So I actually am interested in what people will think of this third one.
So there’s no Jerald, but I think for me personally this is the most fun I’ve had with him.