ChickenScratch
Superhero
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2004
- Messages
- 5,208
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 31
Eh, I wouldn't say fighters only ever use what they deem "practical" in fights. Cage or otherwise. Some guys just like to look cool, and in the case of UFC there are guys in there like Lyoto Machida and Anderson Silva that do completely orthodox and generally unrecommended techniques for fighting(such as spin kick, which are probably the most telegraphed a strike you can come up with and thus dangerous because they can be easily defended against if one is looking for it and you have to turn your back, you damn well better be fast or have your opponent stunned or distracted to set up for it... the Bat could do that, sure, but when he's in the middle of a goon dog pile it becomes a whole different ball game and quite frankly, in BB and TDK he's literally jumping into dog piles of goons and taking them out in the most energy efficient and effective manner for the situation), but so many of the rest of the UFC roster are training primarily BJJ or wrestling and striking becomes an addendum in their training they aren't expecting it. I mean, Silva knocked out Vitor Belfort with a front kick to the chin. That's not a normal application of that kick, it's usually a stunner. But for whatever reason he told people that Steven Seagal taught it to him despite it being a Muay Thai kick that Silva has surely been training since he was a kid. I've seen Cung Le use spinning back kicks for knockouts in Strikeforce, but again... no one in that arena is expecting that and it's a favorite of Cung's. It's not necessarily one of the most effective weapons in the martial artist's arsenal because it is so clearly telegraphed. And it's not particularly effective in close quarters either. The majority of knockouts in MMA come from fists or ground and pound. Even from experienced kickers. Why? Because that's the most effective means.
The BB and TDK fights aren't perfect, but to argue that they are boring just because you can't see what's going on because you can't pick it apart with an eye for martial detail isn't the fault of the movie.
I wouldn't call a spinning back kick impractical. I wouldn't even call it telegraphed if done right. I've landed it many times in training, tournaments and real fights. It's all about the individual's speed, mechanics, setting it up and effectively disguising it if done in the proper linear fashion (rather than the more circular approach many use).
Movie fights are movie fights. I never expect much from staged combat, I accept them for what they are.





t:

), but I never considered that one a featured fight. The fight part of it is so swift... it's barely a few seconds of fisticuffs, the rest is breaking glass, gunfire, explosions and a skyhook. The penthouse fight, the finale fight, and the opening fight all look great to me.