Chapter 45 - The Eclipse, Pt. 2 - Discussion Thread 12/02/08

Just doesn't make sense that he would. The way Adam was described in season 2 was to be Linderman's mentor. Since Arthur was Linderman's bestest friendest foreverest, one could assume that Adam was Arthur's mentor too. Why kill someone who can be so valuable?
 
I almost forgot about Adam. He was my favorite character. Alot of potential. But he has to stay dead??:csad:
 
Just doesn't make sense that he would. The way Adam was described in season 2 was to be Linderman's mentor. Since Arthur was Linderman's bestest friendest foreverest, one could assume that Adam was Arthur's mentor too. Why kill someone who can be so valuable?

First I greatly disliked season 2, and frankly I don't know okay Matt. Maybe Arthur resented the mentor role Adam had with his buddy Linderman. Maybe something happened between the three of them, or hell maybe Arthur is just a dick head.
 
Everytime unobvious questions go unanswered in the show...I always feel like they will go overlooked forever.
 
First I greatly disliked season 2, and frankly I don't know okay Matt. Maybe Arthur resented the mentor role Adam had with his buddy Linderman. Maybe something happened between the three of them, or hell maybe Arthur is just a dick head.

And people call Sylar from season one, one dimensional...

Everytime unobvious questions go unanswered in the show...I always feel like they will go overlooked forever.

Caitlin who?
 
again my dvr is screwing up and being stupid and because i have to wait for my sis to watch this show i end missing last minutes of this show ....what happened after hiro and claire traveled back in time...the last thing i saw was baby claire being handed over to noah.......please fill me in
 
seriously?? so that was the cliffhanger nothing happened ....no dialouge besides that?
 
And people call Sylar from season one, one dimensional...



Caitlin who?

What do you think happpened to Caitlin:huh:,I mean she got stuck in a future that no longer exists.
 
sounds good i will just wait for the recap or watch it online at some point....next week no waiting for the sister.....:hehe:
 
What do you think happpened to Caitlin:huh:,I mean she got stuck in a future that no longer exists.

Yes... Heroes should be forgiven whenever it just quits telling stories... Leob and Alexander should be hired back to continue their wonderful work.
 
I don't even care about Caitlin as she was useless. I just want to know who Angela was talking to about Pandora's Box.
 
I'm still so upset about Elle
I was hoping there could be some twist, but looks like that promo pic wasn't lying...
:(
 
I don't even care about Caitlin as she was useless. I just want to know who Angela was talking to about Pandora's Box.

You know what could have earned the writers some credit back... if they wrote a scene when Peter was in the future and running from Pinehearst... he bumped into Caitlin, who he then asked for help... and she didn't know him.

Bam, season two question/loose end closed.
 
You know what could have earned the writers some credit back... if they wrote a scene when Peter was in the future and running from Pinehearst... he bumped into Caitlin, who he then asked for help... and she didn't know him.

Bam, season two question/loose end closed.

Simple and effective. :)
 
Wasn't the eclipse supposed to be explained in these episodes?
 
No next episode. Alot is supposed to be explained next episode.
 
So, basically, the whole deal with the eclipse was to basically show not only who these characters were and what they could be but also give them insight to themselves. Peter realizes he doesn't need powers to be a hero. Nathan concludes that the world can be a better place if the "right" people had abilities and that his father is right. Claire comes to value her abilities and that her dad can't always be there for her. Hiro realizes, with the help of the creator of Robot Chicken at the comic store no less, that he is an inspiration to others. Daphne realizes, with Matt's help, she doesn't have to run away from her past. Suresh realizes that his chance of having a normal life (and with Maya no less) is gone the moment he injected himself with the formula. And Sylar not only begins to understand that he's been lied to about being a Petrelli (God, I hope so) but that, deep down, he's a killer by nature.

Even so, this whole business with the eclipse was pure filler. Granted, it was basically a macguffin for the characters to understand themselves but that's all it was, a macguffin. Also, considering how there's been total solar eclipses before, why is it that Arthur and Angela never knew about it effecting their powers before now? Wouldn't have they seen this happen first hand in the past?

Not that there wasn't some good stuff here. Hiro rescuing Claire's family from Sylar and Elle was all kinds of win and a reminder of the show's past greatness. Likewise, I kind of dug the whole metafictional subplot in the comic store with Seth Green and Brecken Meyer and how they're treated like sages by the "characters" from the 9th Wonders comic. And to have Sylar kill Elle by the end--well I certainly thought she was the mother of Sylar's baby but I guess that definitely out the window now. And of course, HRG finally gets to be the badass we all remember him to be this season.
 
Yeah, real smart Heroes writers. Kill off Adam and Elle and write off Monica, the three new Heroes of season two anyone could actually stand. God, why do I still watch this show?!
 
I won’t miss Elle; she was just a gimmick that was played out too long.
 
I won’t miss Elle; she was just a gimmick that was played out too long.
A gimmick? Yeah, cause casting Kristen Bell was a gimmick. No one except die hard geeks knew who she was before Heroes. A gimmick would have been casting someone like Britney Spears or any other household name as Elle. :o
 
A gimmick? Yeah, cause casting Kristen Bell was a gimmick. No one except die hard geeks knew who she was before Heroes. A gimmick would have been casting someone like Britney Spears or any other household name as Elle. :o

Since the begining it's always seemed like they cast Bell and then created Elle for her, instead of the other way round.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Staff online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
202,304
Messages
22,082,723
Members
45,883
Latest member
Gbiopobing
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"