Chapter 45 - The Eclipse, Pt. 2 - Discussion Thread 12/02/08

[alexdunn]

saw that one coming.

 

[Primal Slayer]

Ok now I am ofically pissed off! Worst charecter death ever! And I totally called that over at TWOP!

 

[Andreth]

OMG
NOOO please, not Elle!

 

[The Sage]

I missed the dialogue before Sylar started slicing Elle's head open. Why did he kill her?

 

[alexdunn]

I don't get why that ending was a holy sh** moment. Am i missing something?

 

[Havok83]

I didnt get that ending. What was so shocking? Didnt Claire already know that the company placed her with HRG?

 

[The Chris]

I'm sorry, what the hell with Sylar and Elle? Felt like a huge waste of time.

 

[Matt]

Claire has never time traveled before, I'd say being teleported to the past by a strange Asian man you've never met is enough to make you say "Holy ****."

 

[Gilpesh]

I missed the dialogue before Sylar started slicing Elle's head open. Why did he kill her?

Because.





That's why anyone has been doing anything this season.

 

[gtkilla]

Yawn... Sylar has become really irrelevant to this show now.

 

[Evelisse]

Somebody should fire these writers............................oh......

 

[Havok83]

I missed the dialogue before Sylar started slicing Elle's head open. Why did he kill her?

He didnt kill her. Something stopped him before he could complete it. I dont think he trusts anyone after HRG's revelation that Arthur and Angela arent his parents and that Elle knew. He probably feels he's still manipulated by her and that they both will never change. The killing and evilness is what he knows and what he's used to, so he's back to that

 

[Andreth]

Well there goes baby Noah...

 

[alexdunn]

How many more days until Lost comes back?

 

[Morg]

Ok that was dumb, Sylar already have Ellie powers, why the hell he needs to do a brain drain?

 

[Havok83]

Yawn... Sylar has become really irrelevant to this show now.

yeah as much as I hated what was done with him this season, at least it was different and taking him in a new direction but now he's in the same exact position he's been in the first 2 seasons. Absolutely no progression and completely pointless at this point

Ok that was dumb, Sylar already have Ellie powers, why the hell he needs to do a brain drain?
__________________

It wasnt about stealing her powers. He wanted to kill her

 

[javi1024]

these past 3-4 episodes have been the best of the season. ive actually been excited each upcoming episode now. but i am really getting sick of Sylar switching sides every week.

 

[kyuubijavi1]

Ok that was dumb, Sylar already have Ellie powers, why the hell he needs to do a brain drain?

My guess is Syler is going to try and find out the truth

 

[Gilpesh]

How many more days until Lost comes back?

Couple of weeks until season four on dvd... that should hold people over until season five.

 

[Matt]

I'm sorry, what the hell with Sylar and Elle? Felt like a huge waste of time.

These past three episodes have all been a reset button. Absolutely everything is returned to the status quo. Nathan is being manipulated again. Sylar is evil again (and maybe not even a Petrelli). Everyone has their powers again. What the hell was the point of any of it? Why introduce plot lines if instead of developing and finishing them, you just decide to devote three episodes towards resetting them? Hell, I wouldn't be suprised if Papa Petrelli dies, which results in Muary and Adam somehow being ressurected...only to have Arthur cured with Claire's blood two seconds later. This show is scared to advance its plot or characters...which is really odd for a serial.

 

[chaseter]

How many more days until Lost comes back?

This isn't the Lost forum.

 

[Primal Slayer]

He didnt kill her. Something stopped him before he could complete it. I dont think he trusts anyone after HRG's revelation that Arthur and Angela arent his parents and that Elle knew. He probably feels he's still manipulated by her and that they both will never change. The killing and evilness is what he knows and what he's used to, so he's back to that

Well he got pretty far on her forehead...and she just laid there doing nothing! There better be something to redem the end and Elle next episode because that just totally pissed me off about Elles charecterization in that scene and the whole Sylar/Elle arch.

 

[Gilpesh]

these past 3-4 episodes have been the best of the season. ive actually been excited each upcoming episode now. but i am really getting sick of Sylar switching sides every week.

And this season has been the s**tiest season ever...

 

[The Sage]

Somebody should fire these writers............................oh......

No kidding. The more episodes, the more the releases make sense.

He didnt kill her. Something stopped him before he could complete it. I dont think he trusts anyone after HRG's revelation that Arthur and Angela arent his parents and that Elle knew. He probably feels he's still manipulated by her and that they both will never change. The killing and evilness is what he knows and what he's used to, so he's back to that

So he's letting the hunger control him again?

 

[chaseter]

These past three episodes have all been a reset button. Absolutely everything is returned to the status quo. Nathan is being manipulated again. Sylar is evil again (and maybe not even a Petrelli). Everyone has their powers again. What the hell was the point of any of it? Why introduce plot lines if instead of developing and finishing them, you just decide to devote three episodes towards resetting them? Hell, I wouldn't be suprised if Papa Petrelli dies, which results in Muary and Adam somehow being ressurected...only to have Arthur cured with Claire's blood two seconds later. This show is scared to advance its plot or characters...which is really odd for a serial.

It is odd but fans are complaining that the development that they were getting in Season 2 and the beginning of this Season was wretched like Sylar for instance. Now it seems they are going back on what they were building on by tearing it down and starting over again to please the naysayers which is hurting the show even more.