So I just came back from seeing it...
Pros:
Everyone did a great job in the acting department, particularly Michael Keaton. That man stood out among the rest. Keaton needs to be in more mainstream movies. I enjoyed that Padilha didn't try to copy Verhoeven's satire and instead, made a satire of political talk shows. I also liked how the plot tried to be different instead of a carbon copy of the original. They didn't try to capture the idea of a ghost in the machine in the same way. I'll give the film points for that.
Cons:
We'll never know how much the whole studio interference ordeal that Padilha alluded to greatly influenced the final product, but this film was mediocre. A mediocre film is a waste of my money. If it's a waste of my money, then I feel cheated. It's a disturbing trend that we are seeing lately. More and more of these remakes are simply mediocre. There was nothing particularly refreshing or profound about this film that made it necessarily remade. This was
Total Recall (2012) all over again.
If I had to rate it out of 10, it easily gets a 5. It wasn't stellar nor was it abysmal. It's just lurking in between somewhere.
Rating: 5/10