Black Narcissus
8 | 24
- Joined
- May 2, 2012
- Messages
- 35,578
- Reaction score
- 14,376
- Points
- 103
He doesn't offset the natural balance because he exists in a world with supervillains and killers who operate on the same scale he does. There IS a story where he tries to solve world hunger and it kinda blows up in his face, though. It's called Superman: Peace on Earth by Paul Dini and Alex Ross. I don't love the resolution, but I do appreciate the exploration in terms of character.
As for your first question, Superman is a large scale fireman. Do you expect firemen to take on the sins of everyone they save? Supes will never regret saving anyone because saving a life is always the right thing to do in the moment. No one has the right to single-handedly decide who "deserves" saving. What that person chooses to then do with their 2nd chance at life is entirely on them. That's free will, warts and all.
What I like about Peace on Earth is, it does something I wish more stories did: it makes Superman step out of the fireman role and into the activist role. He realizes the former is simply not enough, that there's too much suffering he couldn't stay indifferent to, and there's much more he can do than just be a first responder. I love how controversial it would be irl to see Superman take up an active cause, take sides in an issue. Gives him a chance to show moral courage and make enemies that aren't supervillains. Great material for stories, so I hope a movie goes there some again.
Nemeres said it better here for me. That firemen example is a cop out for me, but we both know where I stand on this. Perhaps I’m more cynical pov in my real world view in a sense. A real life Supes would be a dictator/Homelander type imo. Frank Miller was right.

"What would Superman be like in our world" is an irrelevant question. The point of fantasy is, what could we be in his world? We all know our world ain't like that. That's obvious. The idea is if enough people imagine what the world could be, they could change it for the better. It's called "aspirational."