The Dark Knight Rises The TDKR General Discussion & Speculation Thread - - Part 19

[DoomsdayApex]

Another legit poster, Gill, said Catwoman will have a cowl. She didn't. So I am sad.

But he's apparently correct 90% of time according to everybody here. I'm sure he got this one wrong but Gill is still a reliable source.

 

[Tacit Ronin]

There was no chemistry with Bale and Katie. There wasn't any chemistry with Maggie either but she had chemistry with Eckhart.

 

[kvz5]

I agree with this. Holmes isn't the best actress but her performance as Rachel was more consistent and genuine in Begins. I believed they were friends and the chemistry between them felt more natural as well.

Overall though Maggie is the better actress but Rachel in TDK wasn't one of her stronger performances.

Exactly. It's not even a debate that Maggie is a better actress but Katie just made Rachel more relatable in Begins for me. I believed her as Bruce's childhood sweetheart. There was that genuine naivety in her.

 

[DoomsdayApex]

I hope it's true about what he said about Selina being the best written character in the script next to Bruce.

Me too.

 

[Tacit Ronin]

Maybe Catwoman has a cowl when she is stripping but not when she is out on the street. That would suck.

 

[kvz5]

Just wondering why he'd just drop in here and lay down all the knowledge out of nowhere. Idk I just have seen s lot of posters who were supposedly a knowing be very wrong about things in this movie so far.

At this point, it's just best to take everything with a grain of salt. I think there's a lot of deliberate misinformation happening/trickling down the WB chain.

 

[DoomsdayApex]

Just wondering why he'd just drop in here and lay down all the knowledge out of nowhere. Idk I just have seen s lot of posters who were supposedly a knowing be very wrong about things in this movie so far.

You'll have to ask him why, but he laid down alot of material for us to soak up.

Some may not enjoy it (ex. Nuffsaid) while others will jump with glee (assuming the info is true).

 

[regwec]

Maggie played the part in a very warm and likeable way. She isn't a beautiful woman in the purely physical sense, but she is a fine actress who is able to convey a playful femininity and be very appealing.

 

[Tacit Ronin]

You'll have to ask him why, but he laid down alot of material for us to soak up.

Some may not enjoy it (ex. Nuffsaid) while others will jump with glee (assuming the info is true).

....what? I enjoy it immensly.

 

[Alex Logan]

http://spiderjewel.tumblr.com/post/12581169255/sign-my-petition-to-get-katie-holmes-back-for-dark

Apparently according to her only the Maggie version of Rachel died. Either that or she thinks Maggie Gyllenhal is dead. wtf

Yeah, I read that. I'm not really sure what to say about it either.

 

[Yurka]

But he's apparently correct 90% of time according to everybody here. I'm sure he got this one wrong but Gill is still a reliable source.

She may still have one, it's just based on the set pics we've seen, she doesn't have one in those scenes. There is a toonnnnnn of stuff we haven't seen yet, or even heard about that was filmed.

 

[DoomsdayApex]

....what? I enjoy it immensly.

No, I meant the part where he mentioned The Avengers flick. You hated that part from his release.

 

[DoomsdayApex]

She may still have one, it's just based on the set pics we've seen, she doesn't have one in those scenes. There is a toonnnnnn of stuff we haven't seen yet, or even heard about that was filmed.

True, it's still possible for Catwoman to get one. We, as fans, have witnessed nothing compared to what was filmed in the shadows.

 

[craigdbfan]

Exactly. It's not even a debate that Maggie is a better actress but Katie just made Rachel more relatable in Begins for me. I believed her as Bruce's childhood sweetheart. There was that genuine naivety in her.

Absolutely.

At this point, it's just best to take everything with a grain of salt. I think there's a lot of deliberate misinformation happening/trickling down the WB chain.

 

[Boom]

Yeah, I read that. I'm not really sure what to say about it either.

That's almost as moronic as the "Heath Ledger is still Alive" blog.

 

[Blue Sugar]

About the cowl thing. Neither Gill or Rag's source outright confirmed there would be a cowl. The only words used (when we had only seen the promo-pic) were stuff like incomplete and more to come.

And what came was glasses dressed as cat-ears!

 

[DoomsdayApex]

At this point, it's just best to take everything with a grain of salt. I think there's a lot of deliberate misinformation happening/trickling down the WB chain.

He did state that WB is on a misdirection mission and they've succeed so...

 

[batbax]

Maggie played the part in a very warm and likeable way. She isn't a beautiful woman in the purely physical sense, but she is a fine actress who is able to convey a playful femininity and be very appealing.

I agree. The only part where I think still having Katie in the role would've been better is when Rachel dies, it would've had more impact due to continuity reasons o think.

 

[ThePhantasm]

About the cowl thing. Neither Gill or Rag's source outright confirmed there would be a cowl. The only words used (when we had only seen the promo-pic) were stuff like incomplete and more to come.

And what came was glasses dressed as cat-ears!

Right. As far as I remember Gill NEVER mentioned a cowl.

 

[Anita18]

She may still have one, it's just based on the set pics we've seen, she doesn't have one in those scenes. There is a toonnnnnn of stuff we haven't seen yet, or even heard about that was filmed.

Right. I suspect we'll see for sure when they start to do the promotional stuff. Catwoman having a cowl isn't gonna be something that they save for the movie, like Two-Face in TDK.

 

[Alex Logan]

That's almost as moronic as the "Heath Ledger is still Alive" blog.

OMG... that takes the cake. Let me guess, Heath didn't die, the Joker did?

 

[dark_b]

Another legit poster, Gill, said Catwoman will have a cowl. She didn't. So I am sad.

didnt Gill writte that there is more to the suit? i think he meant that when the googles are up thy look like ears.did he writte cowl?

 

[Boom]

OMG... that takes the cake. Let me guess, Heath didn't die, the Joker did?

No. Both were alive and well. He was convinced that Ledger would show up at the Oscars that year.

But the most pathetic thing was seeing him proclaim that there was no body in the body bag when they removed Ledger from his apartment - arguing that the ankles were too thin to be a real person's .

 

[DoomsdayApex]

Right. As far as I remember Gill NEVER mentioned a cowl.

Now that I think back, yea, he never confirmed that there would be a cowl. He said there was more to the suit but that's all, I think.

 

[kvz5]

I think Gill said it's comparable to when Bruce had the ski mask on.