JK...I really liked it quite a bit! I feel very relieved to be able to say that. Lobster isn't totally dead inside after all.
So yeah, I think DC may have cracked the code here. My fiance enjoyed the movie too, and I don't think she's genuinely enjoyed a superhero film since TDKR. Basically, this movie very much plays like Captain America: TFA meets Thor. It's a mashup of a lot of superhero origin movies you've seen before. However, that brings me to...
...as much as this movie does feel inspired by the MCU, it's
very much a DC film IMO. By that I mean, there is a sense of earnestness to it all. There is plenty of wit and humor, but it's not just throw away "Stark snark". Steve Trevor is an extremely likable character- he, as well as the rest of the supporting cast are able to inject a lot of charm and humor into the movie. However, the movie still feels like it has stakes when it needs to have them. Diana is allowed to be a simple, straight beacon of hope type of character. The score is allowed to do a lot of the heavy lifting, which is another DC hallmark. The score is quite good too btw, the theme is organically incorporated and never overused. This movie actually provides, at the very least, one sheer goosebumps-inducing moment where you just can't help but smile.
The Donner influence is
very clear. And I'm not gonna lie. Gadot is...honestly, not a very good actress. However, she's still great in the movie in the same way that Christopher Reeve is great as Superman. There's a genuineness to her that comes across on screen and makes her an endearing character. Now, whether or not somebody could've done a better job...I don't know, I won't say that. I'm not gonna put her on Reeve-tier, but I'm saying that it's a very similar type of role to Superman where the actor's presence and ability to just "be" the character and exude warmth is more important than technical acting skill.
Another thing...this movie gets right what Ghostbusters got so wrong. In that movie, every male character was a useless moron or unlikable and you very felt beat over the head by that message. With this film, it's nothing like that. Steve Trevor is arguably the most likable character the DCEU has offered up yet, and there are good male supporting players who add a lot to the film. This movie nails the balance of promoting female-empowerment without ever feeling overly preachy or descending into man-bashing.
Yes, the third act does have its flaws and gets a bit bloated (name me a superhero origin film that this doesn't apply to), but it didn't ruin the film for me. I have other nitpicks, like the amount of slow-mo used- but on the plus side, all the action was very easy to follow.
Overall, I'd put this film on about the level of the original Iron Man. DC puts some points on the board here, finally. Kudos to Patty Jenkins for getting it done.