Chapter 46 - "Our Father" - Discussion Thread 12/08/2008

[Ion Kenshin]

great ending...cant believe next week is the finale

 

[chaseter]

Clearly. The Haitian could barely contain Arthur... how could he contain two people of that power?

Also, can anyone explain to me how Arthur went back in time to catch Hiro and take the Catalyst? Obviously he stole Hiro's power and could go back, but how did he get there?

When he stole Peter's powers...Peter could time travel from being near Hiro

 

[The_Beav]

They finally get to Peter's infamous scar!

 

[Whoa]

great ending...cant believe last next week is the finale

Last episode of 08

Back end of Jan

 

[Primal Slayer]

Can't Arthur just heal now that the Haitian is gone?

I think Peter kills Nathan next episode thus a "special" killing a senator will send the government to hunt them down and Tracy heading that movement.

We didn't actually see Elle die so I wonder if she is actually gone for good.

...as if burning her body didnt make her dead enough...she aint coming back.

 

[The_Beav]

great ending...cant believe next week is the finale

They said final episode for the year, they did not say season finale. Probably have a long break though.

 

[mfbtl]

I wonder why Sylar didn't take the Haitian's powers? Wouldn't they come in handy?

 

[Andreth]

Ausiello and Beeman confirmed she's not coming back

 

[Radagast_Prime]

Clearly. The Haitian could barely contain Arthur... how could he contain two people of that power?

Also, can anyone explain to me how Arthur went back in time to catch Hiro and take the Catalyst? Obviously he stole Hiro's power and could go back, but how did he get there?

Well he stole Peter's powers and Peter had Hiro's so he just went there.

 

[chaseter]

argh...wth? Arthur could've done back and taken the catalyst for himself at any time. big nasty plot hole right there.

What would be the point for Arthur to do that He is a bad guy. It isn't a plot hole, it is what Arthur, a villian, did.

 

[Primal Slayer]

I wonder why Sylar didn't take the Haitian's powers? Wouldn't they come in handy?

Not really. Telekinesis holds them at bay long enough for him to slice and dice.

 

[chaseter]

...as if burning her body didnt make her dead enough...she aint coming back.

It still doesn't make sense because Sylar already had her power and he didn't cut open her head...he just streaked across the front. Something just doesn't add up to it. This show is pretty brutal...I don't see why we couldn't see her body burning.

 

[Golgo-13]

The Haitian was to busy focusing on Arthur to stop Sylar from using his powers.

Yeah, that's what i got from the scene too.

I hate that Hiro is always getting stuck in time,etc.....

At least we know now how Peter got his scar..

 

[Shemtov]

Thank god Sylar isnt a Petrelli and thank god Arthur is dead

he isnt ATHURs son....but he could be angela's.

 

[Evelisse]

Which begs the question why waste the season sending henchmen to go after claire when as soon as he took Peters powers it should have been taken care of.

Time travel is such a messy power.

 

[Ion Kenshin]

They said final episode for the year, they did not say season finale. Probably have a long break though.

great ending...cant believe next week is the finale

thanks for clearing that up i was confused for a moment

 

[Gilpesh]

What would be the point for Arthur to do that He is a bad guy. It isn't a plot hole, it is what Arthur, a villian, did.

Um... as in, he could have just done that the second he got Peter's powers. But for no reason, sat on his ass for a bunch of episodes then randomly did it when it was convenient for the writers...

 

[bunk]

When he stole Peter's powers...Peter could time travel from being near Hiro

Well he stole Peter's powers and Peter had Hiro's so he just went there.

Which of you is wrong?

 

[Primal Slayer]

What would be the point for Arthur to do that He is a bad guy. It isn't a plot hole, it is what Arthur, a villian, did.

It doesnt make sense for him to wait till Hiro took the catylst in himself to take it from Hiro when he could ahve taken it come Claire anytime he wanted unless he actually cared about his grand-daughter. Or he could have taken it from Hiros mom if he wanted.

 

[Ion Kenshin]

Yeah, that's what i got from the scene too.

I hate that Hiro is always getting stuck in time,etc.....

At least we know now how Peter got his scar..

that cut he had was along the side of his face not across the front

 

[chaseter]

Shut up! You might show off how bad the writing has gotten....

I really request that you stop trolling. You don't contribute at all to any of the conversations and you just add little snarky comments. You sound like a broken record and it has gotten extremely annoying.

 

[chaseter]

It doesnt make sense for him to wait till Hiro took the catylst in himself to take it from Hiro when he could ahve taken it come Claire anytime he wanted unless he actually cared about his grand-daughter. Or he could have taken it from Hiros mom if he wanted.

Well technically Claire was never the catalyst

 

[Eros]

Um... as in, he could have just done that the second he got Peter's powers. But for no reason, sat on his ass for a bunch of episodes then randomly did it when it was convenient for the writers...

The only people I beleive that new about the the catlyst was Kaito and Angela in the beginning. I beleive Arthur just found about the thing a few episodes ago.

 

[Gilpesh]

I really request that you stop trolling. You don't contribute at all to any of the conversations and you just add little snarky comments. You sound like a broken record and it has gotten extremely annoying.

I really request you stop blowing the writers of Heroes.

 

[Primal Slayer]

It still doesn't make sense because Sylar already had her power and he didn't cut open her head...he just streaked across the front. Something just doesn't add up to it. This show is pretty brutal...I don't see why we couldn't see her body burning.

He sliced her head all the way just didnt bother to open it up and peak inside (can you imagine what her brain looks like?). Plus add that blood lossage to the her leg (which magically became bloodier between episodes) and she is dead.