Superman Returns Suit, Muscle.. is Brandon the problem?

[Super Kal]

Why would I take my argument of Routh not looking like Superman to the community boards?

aw crap... I've gone and done it again


i mixed two threads up... darnit!

 

[Saph]

Thank You Dr. Saph...but as usual..you are wrong

So, what you're saying is, my opinions are wrong.

And the sad part is, if I said you were wrong, you'd get in a mood about it and try and make me look like the bad guy.

 

[Venom71]

So, what you're saying is, my opinions are wrong.

And the sad part is, if I said you were wrong, you'd get in a mood about it and try and make me look like the bad guy.

No if you said I was wrong I would simply state
Me Wrong..Never...which I never am

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

Why? Why are people not allowed to comment on the way he looks in the suit if their comments are negative? Do we not have enough to base an opinion on? I dont see anyone complaining about the "Routh IS Superman", "Routh looks great! Based on this picture, I have decided I love the suit." comments or about anyone who is head over heels in love with the suit and build.

and I was reffering to your statement about "If Routh doesnt look like Superman... niether does Reeve" which has nothing to do with your above quote, and it just doesnt make any sense.

YEP everyone should have the right to express themself's in a peacefull way that doesn't start any beef's in here... There just opinions afterall...

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

Damn skippy, everyone can argue all day, but when it comes down to it this is all opinion, so let me have mine. I like arguing, it's fun...don't get me wrong, but I am just being playful...you all are getting a little too serious...and it's kind of creepy.

I'm a huge fan of George Reeves(looks like a man), Christopher Reeve(looks like a man), Dean Caan(looks like a man, a little too pretty though), Welling (looks like a man), but this Routh guy just looks like SuperBoy...that's all I'm saying. Put him in a SuperBoy movie and that would be great, but I have read that this Superman Returns is picking up where Superman II left off...and it looks like Superman got some Botox or something because he looks like he hasn't hit puberty yet. That's my opinion.

And I'm not a hater, I love the Legend of Superman, that's just my opinion. Personally I think DC should calm down on the comic movies, they are just trying to cash in like Marvel and they are going to end up ruining some potentially good movies because they are just trying to throw something out there to join the game. Marvel is overloading the movie scene with too many titles, they are out of control. The Hulk movie blew, they were really pushing it with the Punisher. Look at the new Batman Movie...cheezy...again, my opinion.

I agree with 99% of this post heh except for the BATMAN BEGINS part lol I loved the movie sorry... Bale simply won me over with his role as Batman!
But if it werent for him the movie would have sucked yea.
Like Superman I & II if it werent for Chris Reeve those movies would have sucked something bad also.
Everything else your right on the money! Routh looks WAY to young for this role especially since this is a Superman that's coming back to a planet that's already had him around for years (Cus its a sequel to S1 & 2) and he's been gone for 5 years.
How can they cast someone who looks like a teenager still?
Bad casting man just bad casting...

 

[Saph]

If this was a restart and Routh was playing an unestablished Superman his young look wouldn't be an issue to me. But he's playing a Superman 5 years older than Reeve's Superman, and he looks younger.

 

[antmanx68]

Well be careful calling it a sequel, the term we're using now is "vague history", wouldnt want to ruffle any feathers. But even if you subtract Superman I & II, AND the fact that Reeve was older than Routh what you're left with is a Superman who looks like he's in his very early 20's returning after a 5+ year absence.

Perhaps Supes didnt age much becuase most of his time away was spent traveling at near the speed of light (which would really slow down the passage of time for him) but it wouldnt account for him looking SO young.

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

If this was a restart and Routh was playing an unestablished Superman his young look wouldn't be an issue to me. But he's playing a Superman 5 years older than Reeve's Superman, and he looks younger.

Yeah it doesn't make any sense... NONE AT ALL!

Well be careful calling it a sequel, the term we're using now is "vague history", wouldnt want to ruffle any feathers. But even if you subtract Superman I & II, AND the fact that Reeve was older than Routh what you're left with is a Superman who looks like he's in his very early 20's returning after a 5+ year absence.

Perhaps Supes didnt age much becuase most of his time away was spent traveling at near the speed of light (which would really slow down the passage of time for him) but it wouldnt account for him looking SO young.

LOL Vague history is a lazy way out of having to explain why his Superman looks like a Teen, and why his Lois looks like a highschool cheerleader.
The only person who was cast right in the movie is Perry White, and Jimmy Olsen.
Everything else has been a big let down.
By the way the whole thing with Superman going the speed of light would not explain it cause he's still going to have to atleast look as old as he did in Superman 2 which he clearly doesn't, and this wouldn't explain why everyone else looks so much younger also.
The whole sequel idea is what's really wrong with this movie.. If it had been a restart like Saph said then most wouldn't have a problem with him looking young.

 

[antmanx68]

Yeah it doesn't make any sense... NONE AT ALL!



LOL Vague history is a lazy way out of having to explain why his Superman looks like a Teen, and why his Lois looks like a highschool cheerleader.
The only person who was cast right in the movie is Perry White, and Jimmy Olsen.
Everything else has been a big let down.
By the way the whole thing with Superman going the speed of light would not explain it cause he's still going to have to atleast look as old as he did in Superman 2 which he clearly doesn't, and this wouldn't explain why everyone else looks so much younger also.
The whole sequel idea is what's really wrong with this movie.. If it had been a restart like Saph said then most wouldn't have a problem with him looking young.

hehe, you dont have to convince me. Your post read my mind.

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

Yeah.....Not Really....Routh looks like a kid...He looks like Superboy....NOT...I repeat....NOT Superman!

Look, I can totally dismiss your opinion too!

Venom, I think you should consider that there just MIGHT be a problem if a number of people think Routh looks too young. I think instead of glorifying your opinion over everyone else's, you should accept the fact that people DO think Routh looks young.

lol carefull dude there going to start saying that your that Fanboy guy!
You know since everyone who hates on this movie is obviously him lol
But yea I agree with you Routh just looks way to young.... Still looks like a teenager to me.

hehe, you dont have to convince me. Your post read my mind.

hehe happy to see im not alone here
Trust me there's alot more of us around the world who are just shaking our collective heads over how screwed up the casting went in this movie then there are supporters...

 

[Mary]

I'll give my opinion only after i watch the movie...but i trust Brandon.

 

[Venom71]

lol carefull dude there going to start saying that your that Fanboy guy!
You know since everyone who hates on this movie is obviously him lol
But yea I agree with you Routh just looks way to young.... Still looks like a teenager to me.



hehe happy to see im not alone here
Trust me there's alot more of us around the world who are just shaking our collective heads over how screwed up the casting went in this movie then there are supporters...

Hmmmm Group picture please...don't buy that for one second

and ROUTH DOES NOT LOOK TOO YOUNG and it is VAGUE HISTORY...NOT A SEQUEL....Yeah I think that just about covers the last few posts

 

[The Game]

Hmmmm Group picture please...don't buy that for one second

You do know that outside of these boards, most people do not like the pic of Routhman in the suit.

 

[venomadness]

You do know that outside of these boards, most people do not like the pic of Routhman in the suit.

I showed the picture to my step-dad, who used to be a diehard Superman fan back in the day. He was disgusted. He said it was mostly the kid in the suit, but the suit itself looked a little over done. I looked at it a little closer, he's right. I read that the "S" is made up of a bunch of little "S" encrusted diamonds or some *****. wtf? Superman grew up Clark Kent from a hick town. All I'm saying, about the suit, is 'keep it simple stupid'.

 

[The Game]

I showed the picture to my step-dad, who used to be a diehard Superman fan back in the day. He was disgusted. He said it was mostly the kid in the suit, but the suit itself looked a little over done. I looked at it a little closer, he's right. I read that the "S" is made up of a bunch of little "S" encrusted diamonds or some *****. wtf? Superman grew up Clark Kent from a hick town. All I'm saying, about the suit, is 'keep it simple stupid'.

Lol

 

[Venom71]

I showed the picture to my step-dad, who used to be a diehard Superman fan back in the day. He was disgusted. He said it was mostly the kid in the suit, but the suit itself looked a little over done. I looked at it a little closer, he's right. I read that the "S" is made up of a bunch of little "S" encrusted diamonds or some *****. wtf? Superman grew up Clark Kent from a hick town. All I'm saying, about the suit, is 'keep it simple stupid'.

Hmmm imagine that..another person who showed the pic to someone else and that person didn't like it...funny how that is always how it works out.

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

I showed the picture to my step-dad, who used to be a diehard Superman fan back in the day. He was disgusted. He said it was mostly the kid in the suit, but the suit itself looked a little over done. I looked at it a little closer, he's right. I read that the "S" is made up of a bunch of little "S" encrusted diamonds or some *****. wtf? Superman grew up Clark Kent from a hick town. All I'm saying, about the suit, is 'keep it simple stupid'.

Yeah mostly everyone I know who I have shown the pictures to who don't even know about the hype or any of the Superman related forums hate the pics of Brandon in the suit.
They hate mostly Brandon cause of how young he looks, and that the one thing I keep hearing is that he looks like a water down version of Chris Reeve which nobody seems to be diggin much.

 

[Venom71]

You do know that outside of these boards, most people do not like the pic of Routhman in the suit.

You do know that the general public who are not online and have no clue a new Superman move is coming out have no clue what Routh or the new suit looks like.

 

[Venom71]

Yeah mostly everyone I know who I have shown the pictures to who don't even know about the hype or any of the Superman related forums hate the pics of Brandon in the suit.
They hate mostly Brandon cause of how young he looks, and that the one thing I keep hearing is that he looks like a water down version of Chris Reeve which nobody seems to be diggin much.

Blah Blah Blah

 

[The Game]

You do know that the general public who are not online and have no clue a new Superman move is coming out have no clue what Routh or the new suit looks like.

Stop lying to your self, when the pics of Brandon was leaked on the net, countless newspapers and magazines showed it or maybe it was just in England

 

[venomadness]

Hmmm imagine that..another person who showed the pic to someone else and that person didn't like it...funny how that is always how it works out.

What do you want me to say? I showed it to him and he loved it? That would go against everything I've been saying. That would bring no relevance to my case whatsoever. Besides, I honestly haven't heard any good things about this damn Routh kid except on this board, so obviously this is where all the Routh fan come to gather...but we "the haters" have found you here as well. Now where shall you hide??? Muhahahaha haha Muha ***cough***cough***...

 

[FEAR THE KNIGHT]

Blah Blah Blah

HEY that's my line! THIEF!

 

[venomadness]

You do know that the general public who are not online and have no clue a new Superman move is coming out have no clue what Routh or the new suit looks like.

Yah, that's what I meant when I "showed the picture to my step-dad". Pay attention, dude. More people know about than you think though. You'd be surprised.

 

[Venom71]

What do you want me to say? I showed it to him and he loved it? That would go against everything I've been saying. That would bring no relevance to my case whatsoever. Besides, I honestly haven't heard any good things about this damn Routh kid except on this board, so obviously this is where all the Routh fan come to gather...but we "the haters" have found you here as well. Now where shall you hide??? Muhahahaha haha Muha ***cough***cough***...

Not hiding....Backing Routh every step of the way.

Ohh and the few people I have shown the pic of Brandon as Supes and CK BTW...say he looks GREAT! One even said he doesn't understand what the people on these boards problem is...Routh looks like Superman and he agrees that as CK he looks alot like Mr. Reeve!

 

[The Game]

Yah, that's what I meant when I "showed the picture to my step-dad". Pay attention, dude. More people know about than you think though. You'd be surprised.

See the Routh super-fans dont want to believe that others know about this film and may not like it, so they try and make it seem like Superman Returns was made just for them so they camp in here where they can hero worship. Disgust!!!