TMOS Reviews Thread - Non Spoiler Review and Discussion - Part 2

[GreenKToo]

.....

 

[Caode]

I just won a pair of tickets for a screening on Wednesday night! Of course... I'll still have to go and see it again on Friday.

 

[JOE]

Have the reviews surfaced yet? The embargo ends today!

 

[Dragon_316ca]

Have the reviews surfaced yet? The embargo ends today!

Less than 15 hours away......

 

[Notrip]

spoilers in this review, it is positive. I did not read it because I will not read any reviews. so, I guess I will just let you all know if it is positive or negative.

EDIT - The wrap reviewed Man of Steel - Positive - Man of Steel "flies" but does not quite "Soar."

Review!! Embargo is broken 12 hours early

 

[Knightstalker]

Its June 11 here in Australia. What time is it in the States?

 

[hopefuldreamer]

That review is a bit spoilery for this thread isn't it?

I mean, I only skimmed the first few paragraphs, but it seems to mention a fair amount of plot...

 

[Knightstalker]

That review is a bit spoilery for this thread isn't it?

I mean, I only skimmed the first few paragraphs, but it seems to mention a fair amount of plot...

Yeah as soon as he started mentioning plot details, I stopped reading.

 

[i_Cam]

http://www.thewrap.com/movies/colum...rimmer-superman-might-not-soar-it-flies-96176

Review!! Embargo is broken 12 hours early

Spoiler

3 more days...

 

[Krumm]

spoilers in this review, it is positive. I did not read it because I will not read any reviews. so, I guess I will just let you all know if it is positive or negative.

EDIT - The wrap reviewed Man of Steel - Positive - Man of Steel "flies" but does not quite "Soar."

Review!! Embargo is broken 12 hours early

Hmm, it seems to be gone...

 

[Notrip]

sorry guys, fixed it. I will not post reviews, but just let you all know if they are good or bad. Most all reviews will tell some plot points because that is what reviews do usually. I learned the hard way with reviews on TDK.

 

[Notrip]

Yep, they took it down at the request of WB

 

[Knightstalker]

Yep, they took it down at the request of WB

The review was positive by the way, for anyone that missed it.

 

[king666]

the review was positive by the way, for anyone that missed it.

edit

 

[Autonet]

I really doubt they'll be that many "negative" reviews, unless they relish being super critical.

 

[Notrip]

yes, I think we will get some 3/5-3.5/5 reviews and those few super negative reviews, with a majority of the reviews being pretty positive. I don't expect anything less than 80 on RT. And if it goes below I want to compare those that reviewed SR to Man of Steel cuz either critics liked them the same or liked SR better.

 

[Autonet]

I can't see it going below 80. It could very well start in the 90's, but I don't think it'll stay there. Starting in the 90's would boost the BO numbers for sure though.

 

[Notrip]

It would put it with Spider-man 2, Avengers, TDK, and Iron Man as 90+RT scores. I expect MOS to be pretty high but not quite 90. Still sticking to my 85 prediction. Seems like it will be on par with Batman Begins.

 

[JangoNate]

So, just checking in and haven't read back too far, but I noticed a fresh review on RT. You can't find the actual review, but it's in the tally at the top of the page. Maybe that's linked with the review being discussed above.

I guess it's good news to see WB pulling a good review. I know some embargoes will let the positives flow and block the negatives to give a good looking early score.

 

[Bran-El]

Batman Begins has a 63% fresh rating from top critics, yet The Dark Knight earned 90%. My guess is that Man of Steel will land somewhere between.

 

[king666]

yes, I think we will get some 3/5-3.5/5 reviews and those few super negative reviews, with a majority of the reviews being pretty positive. I don't expect anything less than 80 on RT. And if it goes below I want to compare those that reviewed SR to Man of Steel cuz either critics liked them the same or liked SR better.

I know a critic who liked SR better. She thought MOS was "too loud", etc.

 

[Autonet]

I know a critic who liked SR better. She thought MOS was "too loud", etc.

Literally or....?

 

[Notrip]

yep ^ SR had lots of soft moments and wasn't in your face. Man of Steel will be MUCH better received from fans and the GA than SR because SR was a little soft for Superman, and nobody really wants a stalker Superman imho. Still did she like MOS at all @king666?

 

[Tra-El]

EDIT: Moved to spoiler thread....http://movies.yahoo.com/news/man-steel-review-grimmer-superman-might-not-soar-150008338.html

 

[Autonet]

yep ^ SR had lots of soft moments and wasn't in your face. Man of Steel will be MUCH better received from fans and the GA than SR because SR was a little soft for Superman, and nobody really wants a stalker Superman imho. Still did she like MOS at all @king666?

Ah I get it. Yeah Man of Steel can be overwhelming, and I can see some critics talk about that. You won't get to rest.