Chapter 37- “One of Us, One of Them” – Discussion Thread 9/29/08

[The Apocalypse]

Hiro needs to die soon. His character is boring, not funny, pretty much lame. If Hiro turns out to be villain (why Ando kills him) that would be a nice change of pace.

The ep was alright though. I thought it was pointless that Magneto-Man couldn't just rip the damn vault open.

 

[Sawyer]

Hiro needs to die soon. His character is boring, not funny, pretty much lame. If Hiro turns out to be villain (why Ando kills him) that would be a nice change of pace.

The ep was alright though. I thought it was pointless that Magneto-Man couldn't just rip the damn vault open.

While I dont think Hiro should die, I really dont like him as much as others do. He's very over-rated. The writers just need to tone down their Hiro love.

If any character needs to die, its Mohinder.

 

[Silicon Surfer]

I like Mohinder well enough and Hiro as well. Sylar has to die though, slowly and painfully.

 

[shadowdog]

I'm willing to stick it out for Hiro in hopes that he will soon become the future Hiro we've seen, who is a badass. maybe it will take Ando becoming his enemy to push him over the edge.

 

[boydston_14]

Man, I feel really sorry for Micah after this episode. I guess he's living with Nana Dawson still. I just wish they had made it clear that he was living with someone. He seems so alone.

 

[Not_Sane]

I think that was their point to show that Micah doesn't really have anyone left to give him the support a parent would.

 

[Trainwreck2100]

Question if Sylar has some sort of "hunger" that drives him, why did he still have it when he was injected with the virus?`

 

[Sentinel X]

Question if Sylar has some sort of "hunger" that drives him, why did he still have it when he was injected with the virus?`

HAHA!! Seriously, I just remembered this. So they're trying to say this "hunger" is part of his ability (so basically his abilities make him mean, other than that he is a nice guy) he shouldve certainly been nice when he was powerless.

 

[Anubis]

I think it was meant more to sound like, he's addicted to it, rather than drawn to it because of his powers. He's a brain touching junky.

 

[BLACKVULCAN]

i gotta say i really like the Speedster chick. she even got a code name from Hiro "nemesis". i dig girl.

 

[bullets]

Exactly. The German was shown to be far more incredible in the novels. Then we see him and he is offed by the Caliban ripoff Knox. Who is then casually dismissed by Sylar. These guys are supposed to be the really upper level bad guys who are so dangerous the company removed them permanently from the world in Level 5, and yet they act like little pathetic two bit thugs.

I agree that it was a total letdown to have these characters easily dismissed by episode three. They may have served there purpose but i
don't want sylar to be the main bad guy everytime.


Other than that , I've enjoyed the season so far. I'm hoping that there isn't any clones , i hate clones.

i also enjoy the speedster and damn she is hot.

 

[Dr. Evil]

Sylar working with Noah was very interesting. Those other bad guys were a letdown though. Two of them are dead, one went back to his cell and the other escaped.

And did the African dude show a future vision of Matt with the Speedster girl? And from the previews of next week, Mohinder is showing signs of turning very bad.

 

[Neptune]

Awesome, awesome, awesome episode!

- Now that Peter is in his own body i wanna see him kick some ass.
- The Hatian still owns all.
- Sylar is cool and all that but can he please use a different power for once?
- What is Claire up to?

 

[Dr. Evil]

Awesome, awesome, awesome episode!

- Now that Peter is in his own body i wanna see him kick some ass.
- The Hatian still owns all.
- Sylar is cool and all that but can he please use a different power for once?
- What is Claire up to?

She wants to prove that she can be a hero and gets one of HRG's files and goes after one of the bad guys.

 

[Poetic Chaos]

While I dont think Hiro should die, I really dont like him as much as others do. He's very over-rated. The writers just need to tone down their Hiro love.

If any character needs to die, its Mohinder.

Mohinder and Hiro having a fight to the death (hopefully ending in a draw) would be an awesome scenario.

 

[Golgo-13]

Is Elle/Kristen Bell coming back or has she been written out, permanantly?

 

[The Apocalypse]

Mohinder and Hiro having a fight to the death (hopefully ending in a draw) would be an awesome scenario.

Agreed.

 

[Neptune]

They really need to do something interesting with Tracy fast. I want to like her but a clone story is certainly not going to accomplish that.

 

[YoungE808]

Awesome, awesome, awesome episode!

- Now that Peter is in his own body i wanna see him kick some ass.
- The Hatian still owns all.
- Sylar is cool and all that but can he please use a different power for once?
- What is Claire up to?

...Does he still have the radioactive power? For now it only seems like he has Telekinesis, his original ability, the object history thing that he stole from that girl, and now Jessie's sound manipulation.

 

[Ghostvirus]

Not to mention he's being kind of a dick to Ando.

So he killed you in the future, so what?!

I know right! Being a dick to Ando in the present gaurantees Ando turning on him in the future.

 

[The Question]

Sylar working with Noah was very interesting. Those other bad guys were a letdown though. Two of them are dead, one went back to his cell and the other escaped.

Well, they said there were twelve inmates on level five.

 

[Krozee]

The african bushman is so cool! People complaining about him being a rip-off of Isaac need to get slapped with some sense. He's wayy better than Isaac because he doesn't need drugs, he controls it and Isaac was always complaining about how he can't do it without the drugs.

And did I mention they guy's a BLACK DUDE?!?

nuff said.

 

[Ion Kenshin]

The african bushman is so cool! People complaining about him being a rip-off of Isaac need to get slapped with some sense. He's wayy better than Isaac because he doesn't need drugs, he controls it and Isaac was always complaining about how he can't do it without the drugs.

And did I mention they guy's a BLACK DUDE?!?

nuff said.

i think the african dude is way cool ...but let us not forget that Isaac overcame the need for drugs and realized he could paint without it.

 

[Matt]

Parkman's story is too far off. It needs to interact with the rest of the show or else it is pointless. Same with clone-girl. Every season you have one or two stories that really don't fit in, but the writers are just so damn persistent. It would make a much tighter story if they only focused on what is necessary and not pointless subplots that ultimately go no where.

Also, anyone else think they are flying through the villains? 2 dead, 1 back in prison...and its only the second episode.

 

[Ratcrawler]

If anybody needs to get killed off it's Lyle.