Chapter 37- “One of Us, One of Them” – Discussion Thread 9/29/08

[Hush]

Well I don't think Sylar or Noah really feel fear. Sylar maybe but Noah no.

 

[Gilpesh]

sadly people wont see that an effort is made they will only just say OMG Sylar owned all ....weak....

That's actually why I am saying Sylar owned all, weak.

 

[Sentinel X]

I just remembered Jesse getting "darth vadered" by Sylar...Its really annoying how he is becoming untouchable. Sylar needs to die , imo.
Actually this is my death list for the moment:

Nathan
Sylar
Tracy/Barbra/Nikki/Jessica/Gina/ Samantha/Bobbi Ann Joe/ Rupaul/ etc
Maya
Matt

A lot but the cast needs to start clearing out, the same people keep coming back from the dead! Its annoying. I would put Peter (cause I hate his guts) but he seems very essential to the "future" storylines.

 

[The Geek Vault]

After reading Hush's post that got me wondering about two things,
1. When are we gonna see echolocation as a power? I mean in real life there's a guy who can do this for sake!

2. I'm actuallly wondering if Sylar will feel fear? and if not, would that be an extention of any power? What about claires?

 

[Ion Kenshin]

That's actually why I am saying Sylar owned all, weak.

sorry i meant that whole line to be a sarcastic quote of what people will say....should have made myself clearer...it did not really bother me that much

 

[Ion Kenshin]

noah can feel fear..granted it may hel fuel his anger...but noah fears for claire's well being

 

[Gilpesh]

Yeah... cause you're a Sylar fan.

 

[gambitfire]

I just remembered Jesse getting "darth vadered" by Sylar...Its really annoying how he is becoming untouchable. Sylar needs to die , imo.
Actually this is my death list for the moment:

Nathan
Sylar
Tracy/Barbra/Nikki/Jessica/Gina/ Samantha/Bobbi Ann Joe/ Rupaul/ etc
Maya
Matt

A lot but the cast needs to start clearing out, the same people keep coming back from the dead! Its annoying. I would put Peter (cause I hate his guts) but he seems very essential to the "future" storylines.

Unless they're actually planning on making him God, I say throw Peter on that list.

Personally I'd take out Maya and Matt from your death list and bring back Elle into the show spotlight.

 

[Ion Kenshin]

Yeah... cause you're a Sylar fan.

was that directed at me?

 

[Gilpesh]

was that directed at me?

I think it was...

 

[Ion Kenshin]

just asking no need for the eye rolling...there are actually very few characters i dislike on the show..im a fan of most of the characters equally give or take...was a fan of mohinder but he's been becoming more and more of a tool...maya would have been more interesting to me if they sent her down the villain path. If you try hard enough you can come up with reason to hate every character....but no im not a Sylar fanboy

 

[The Caped Knight]

Man Sylar's a badass criminal Mastermind.

 

[Gilpesh]

I didn't say fanboy.

I used to like Sylar... when he was the bad guy with good motivation and a nice character arc where you learned more about him before of course the big battle of the season where he dies and you feel a little bad for him.... whoops. They didn't kill him. He survived not only a sword through his body, but a trip to another country, infection of a virus, and of course all because of a random character that had to be written back into the show... to die just to keep him living.

I guess I missed in season 1 where he stole Claire's powers in the present.

 

[Primal Slayer]

I realized that something they need to add to Claires overall storyline is a BFF ala S1. She needs another teen who she can confide in and who can skip school with her to do her hero deeds.

 

[The Incredible Hulk]

I realized that something they need to add to Claires overall storyline is a BFF ala S1. She needs another teen who she can confide in and who can skip school with her to do her hero deeds.

too bad he's off saving the world from SkyNet...

 

[Jennifer Walters]

If Sarah Connor doesn't make it (as much as that would sadden me), maybe they can write Zach back in.

 

[CFE]

too bad he's off saving the world from SkyNet...

I realized that something they need to add to Claires overall storyline is a BFF ala S1. She needs another teen who she can confide in and who can skip school with her to do her hero deeds.

If Sarah Connor doesn't make it (as much as that would sadden me), maybe they can write Zach back in.

So wait...what happened to her flying friend from S2? I haven't seen S2 episodes in awhile...

CFE

 

[Cmill216]

They conveniently forgot about him.

 

[bullets]

I didn't say fanboy.

I used to like Sylar... when he was the bad guy with good motivation and a nice character arc where you learned more about him before of course the big battle of the season where he dies and you feel a little bad for him.... whoops. They didn't kill him. He survived not only a sword through his body, but a trip to another country, infection of a virus, and of course all because of a random character that had to be written back into the show... to die just to keep him living.

I guess I missed in season 1 where he stole Claire's powers in the present.

Sylar is too awesome to kill off.

 

[Tyrinus]

I think i enjoyed this episode more than the previous two.

And my god that speedster girl is hot.

 

[TheCompanyMan™]

Wait, the Waterboarding scene confused me. Claire only feels pain when reminded of Sylar's attack? I hope they delve deeper into that.

No...she dosent feel pain at all...she has no nerve endings (which sylar stated while digging through her brain)...therefor she can't feel pain when a wound is inflicted upon her body. Merideth was taking oxygen out of the air w/ her fire ability suffocating claire. Im assuming she can technically still die if she suffocates...or mabey she just suffocates...then comes back 2 life a while later...who knows...lol...

 

[TheCompanyMan™]

Though im assuming that if u remover her brain she can die as well since "powers" are controlled through the brain.

 

[TheCompanyMan™]

If Sarah Connor doesn't make it (as much as that would sadden me), maybe they can write Zach back in.

I agree...we need zach back...though he is in texas nd claires in cali...dont know how that would work...

 

[Poetic Chaos]

Dear Hiro,

Please die.

-Heroes Fan

 

[Cmill216]

Am I the only one who screamed, "It's the ****in' Haitian!" tonight?