hafizbat
Superhero
- Joined
- Nov 15, 2011
- Messages
- 5,450
- Reaction score
- 636
- Points
- 103
I am talking about all Batman films. They never really depicted him as detective, like comics tend to do.
This was a great scene showing Batman's strategic prowess in battle (though it is a bit spoiled by the fact that in order to do so, Batman had to rely on a technology that is a bit too "out there" for this grounded universe), but one can count scenes like this in entire trilogy on the fingers of one hand.
And my "problem" with Batman in TDK trilogy is that he was either punching, threatening and asking questions (which is quite legitimate part of Batman's M.O.) or was relying too heavily on ridiculously advanced technology from Wayne Ent. (something which also irks me with "Arkham" games).
He never really sat down and tried to connect the dots. For example, in "Batman Begins" it was told to us that he wanted to understand criminals, so he even immersed himself in criminal life to learn how they think, but we never really got to see him do psychological profiling, trying to understand what motivates his opponents and trying to out-think them.
Granted, both sequels told stories that demanded this approach - Joker was supposed to be the character one cannot fully understand and to lesser extent him failing to understand his opponent was needed in "The Dark Knight Rises" as well. He was far from Batman in his prime, but what made him lose the first fight with Bane was him completely underestimating him - "Ra's al Ghul was the League of Shadows and I defeated him. Bane is just a mercenary."
Story called for him to do so, but dismissing and underestimating his opponents like this is not something an experienced Batman should do.
I'd like to see the version that is not simply tech-reliant, but actually carefully thinks about his real and potential enemies and comes up with elaborate plans to defeat them.
You make fair points, especially about over-powered technology, but I'm gonna have to disagree with your overall point. There were plenty of detective moments in the TDK trilogy. They may not have been as in-your-face as Batman analyzing a crime scene like Sherlock, but it was there. Just a few things off the top of my head,
-Eavesdropping on Crane in BB
-He definitely figured out Ra's by the end of BB, turning his use of the environment against him. "You never learned to mind your surroundings.."
-Figuring out the Joker's plot to kill the Mayor and finding the tied-and-gagged guards by cross-referencing addresses of Arkham inmates
-The bullet-reconstruction scene. Hokey, I know, but it's there.
-Reprimanding Dent when he interrogates Thomas Schiff, a "paranoid schizophrenic. The type of mind the Joker attracts."
-Knowing nearly all of the GCPD members names and faces (shown during the Coleman Reese scene)
-He again showed how quickly he learns about his opponent when he says "It's not that simple with the Joker. It never is." when the police are formulating a plan to take out the clowns on Prewitt. Without his intervention, they would have played right into the Joker's hands.
-He also shows how well he knows Dent, when he says just the right thing to appeal to Dent's sense of justice and shift the blame onto the three of them, buying himself time and opportunity to save the boy.
-Showing his knowledge of cat-burglary when Selina Kyle robs him, which prompts Alfred to say "Maybe you should exchange notes over coffee."
-Fixing the Bat's autopilot by himself
And I'm sure that's not all of it. I tried to keep out the instances where technology was involved, because I agree with your distaste for it. As for an experienced Batman not underestimating his opponents...didn't Batman do exactly that in TDKR when he fights the Mutant leader the first time? I don't think overconfidence is really out of character for Batman.

