Pfeiffer's version is valid, and we're allowed to have an attachment to the Burton movies. Some of us were little kids when they came out and so it was the first Batman, Joker and Catwoman that we got to see. I dont mind the idea that Olsen thinks Pfeiffer is her favorite or the best. It's how she said it. It was a lighthearted moment, but she says it like she doesn't know why they keep remaking Catwoman because in her eyes, Pfeiffer is the one and only Catwoman. She can't be improved and shouldn't be remade after Michelle. That's the vibe Olsen had. Not just "oh i find Pfeiffer's interpretation to be the greatest one". It's that snarky attitude that made me roll my eyes instead of just having fun with it.
She should know anyway, from being with Marvel, that reboots happen and sometimes the new version is an improvement.
I can appreciate people liking Newmar too, even though that's not my thing. Hathaway, in my eyes, was Selina Kyle, more than Michelle ever was. Not just in appearance. Sometimes Michelle was sexier or crazier or had a better suit that looked more like the comics for some people (or sl***ier i should say, and being a crazy with 9 lives was never a Selina thing). But i care a little more about character and so when somebody says "Catwoman", i think Selina, and Anne was more Catwoman than Pfeiffer. I dont go around saying that Hathaway should be the last one to be the character because i thought she was the best.
