Chapter 9: "CAUTIONARY TALES" Discussion 11/19/07

[neemer5]

West ftw. t: He did have some ridiculous cheesy lines though. He makes Peter look like Batman in comparison.

You mean "Mr. Butler, what are you doing?" wasn't the cheesiest line?

 

[Abaddon]

that was chessily delivered.

 

[Sawyer]

Um Claire is a teenager if I recall. Its not uncommon for them to get pissed at their parents. Plus once she was found out she understood what Bennett was doing for her. And she has known West longer then one week.

When Hiro went back to the night of Kaito's murder (same episode she met West, so I'm guessing they are around the same time) it said one week ago.

 

[Sawyer]

You mean "Mr. Butler, what are you doing?" wasn't the cheesiest line?

NO. The whole first scene between Claire and West was awful. Both side were terrible, not just West.

 

[neemer5]

When Hiro went back to the night of Kaito's murder (same episode she met West, so I'm guessing they are around the same time) it said one week ago.

Yeah but that's assuming the 2 story lines followed the same time line, which they likely don't.

Look at how Maya and Alejandro crossed through an entire country and came in and out of jail in the same episode where all Ando did was read a single scroll.

 

[Sawyer]

Yeah but that's assuming the 2 story lines followed the same time line, which they likely don't.

Look at how Maya and Alejandro crossed through an entire country and came in and out of jail in the same episode where all Ando did was read a single scroll.

Yeah, i guess thats true, but Claire taking West's side is just ridiculous.

 

[javphonic]

Hey, so now that the 12 or so are revealed, could anybody help me fill in/ finish this list of the 12, and their abilities?

1-Arthur "Dallas" Petrelli: ?
2-Angela Petrelli: ?
3-Bob: make things gold
4-Adam/Takezo: self healing
5-Linderman: external heal
6-Mr. Parkman: telepathy
7-Mr. Deveaux: ?
8-Kaito Nakamura: ?

 

[javphonic]

When Hiro went back to the night of Kaito's murder (same episode she met West, so I'm guessing they are around the same time) it said one week ago.

Wow that's crazy, to think a boy could turn Claire against her dad in a mere week

 

[Sawyer]

Hey, so now that the 12 or so are revealed, could anybody help me fill in/ finish this list of the 12, and their abilities?

1-Arthur "Dallas" Petrelli: ?
2-Angela Petrelli: ?
3-Bob: make things gold
4-Adam/Takezo: self healing
5-Linderman: external heal
6-Mr. Parkman: telepathy
7-Mr. Deveaux: ?
8-Kaito Nakamura: ?

It's more of a group of 13. The others are Carlos Mendez (Isaac's dad? Probably), Victoria Pratt, Suzanne Ammaw, Harry Fletcher and Paula Gramble. Still have no freakin idea of what their powers are.

 

[javphonic]

It's more of a group of 13. The others are Carlos Mendez (Isaac's dad? Probably), Victoria Pratt, Suzanne Ammaw, Harry Fletcher and Paula Gramble. Still have no freakin idea of what their powers are.

Are they all dead as well?

 

[Sawyer]

Are they all dead as well?

Supposedly.

 

[SuperDaniel]

All I have to say is that this episode was ****ing amazing and probably the best in the entire series!!!

 

[Sawyer]

All I have to say is that this episode was ****ing amazing and probably the best in the entire series!!!

Close, but no. That would be Company man.

 

[Eddie Brock]

Hey, so now that the 12 or so are revealed, could anybody help me fill in/ finish this list of the 12, and their abilities?

1-Arthur "Dallas" Petrelli: ?
2-Angela Petrelli: ?
3-Bob: MATTER MANIPULATION
4-Adam/Takezo: self healing / IMMORTALITY
5-Linderman: external heal
6-Mr. Parkman: telepathy / MIND CONTROL
7-Mr. Deveaux: ?
8-Kaito Nakamura: ?

I highly doubt Bob's abilities are limited to just turning things to gold. He showed Nathan that headline about snow saying it could have been a hurricane. I have a feeling that he somehow manipulated the matter in the storm...making it harmless.

As for the other two annexations, that's just me being more specific.

 

[Sawyer]

I kinda hate that they're dragging out Angela and Kaito's powers. Just tell us what they are already.

 

[Abaddon]

 

[Whiskey Tango]

Years later, Ralphie would finally get his Christmas wish: an Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle.

West: Oh, ****! He shot his eye out!

Claire: Nooo!

 

[Neptune]

Wow that's crazy, to think a boy could turn Claire against her dad in a mere week

Yeah well HRG did lie to her about being on a training camp. Claire knew he was doing something shady. He promised her that there would be no more secrets. Plus he had abducted her boyfriend. I'm not saying was right to turn on her father but i understand where she's coming from.

 

[knockturnal23]

Close, but no. That would be Company man.

Company man was great! But Cautionary tales beats it (IMO)

Was (literally) at the edge of my seat for the last twenty minutes or so!

 

[Red]

I actually put this episode in my favorite top 5. I think it might of benifited if it focused squarely on Noah, Clare, Bob etc.. like "Company Man" but that's open for debate.

 

[DarkSuperman]

Years later, Ralphie would finally get his Christmas wish: an Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle.

West: Oh, ****! He shot his eye out!

Claire: Nooo!

HAHAHAHA! Effin Hilarious! A Christmas Story is the best X-Mas movie EVER!

 

[squeekness]

Years later, Ralphie would finally get his Christmas wish: an Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle.

West: Oh, ****! He shot his eye out!

Claire: Nooo!

LOLs.

 

[gadgetfusion]

This is definitely in my Top 5 as well, probably at #5 for me though (Five Years Gone, Company Man, Fallout, and Six Months Ago are still better), but it's the best episode this season. I bet that next episode will be even better.

 

[squeekness]

I hope so with only two more to go.

 

[Eddie Brock]

1. Homecoming
2. Fallout
3. Company Man
4. Cautionary Tales
5. Five Years Gone

In my opinion.